4 ms·
From the paper, they appear to be using a rather extreme definition of free will: that free will means a radically unconstrained-by-the-material-world decision-
by _delirium 16y ago
From the paper, they appear to be using a rather extreme definition of free will: that free will means a radically unconstrained-by-the-material-world decision-marker, who lives somewhere outside the world (perhaps in some sort of Cartesian "mind" or Christian "soul"), making completely free decisions on some ethereal plane, and then swooping into the material world to enact those decisions now and then. Hence their "bits of free will" metric, which appears to measure just how ethereal and outside-of-physics's-control each bit is. But that's hardly an uncontroversial definition of free will, and probably actually a strongly minority view among modern philosophers (it was dominant in the middle ages, but not anymore). For alternative views, see, say, Daniel Dennett, who argues that free will isn't even incompatible with determinism---the "free" in "free will" doesn't mean "free of physics", but a description of a certain kind of behavior within physics.
- bitdiddle 16y agoIf you're interested in this sort of thing Vaughan Pratt has an excellent paper explaining all this mindy/body dualism using Chu spaces[1]. When I was reading linear logic I found it a pleasant diversion [1] http://boole.stanford.edu/pub/ratmech.pdf http://boole.stanford.edu/pub/ratmech.pdf