4 ms·
by connecting via USB and flicking a switch in the options menu, you get SSH access, as well as a REST endpoint where you can upload your files via curl. So if
by userbinator 9y ago
by connecting via USB and flicking a switch in the options menu, you get SSH access, as well as a REST endpoint where you can upload your files via curl. So if you don't like their cloud offering, you can turn of wifi and be sure your data is local
Maybe it's just me, but why do the defaults for devices like this seem to now always require either a special app or reach out into the Internet? Whatever happened to simple USB mass storage where you can just plug it in and copy files back and forth? The hardware is certainly capable of it.
That said, I don't mind the presence of WiFi, but the default behaviour of requiring one to send files from a computer out far away to some server on the Internet, and then back to the tablet sitting only a few metres away seems rather silly and wasteful.
- blub 9y agoMost customers are ignorant of security issues and the privacy regulations are too weak. This has resulted on one hand in only noticing the conveniences of cloud sync on the customer side and an information greediness on the side of the companies. My enthusiasm for this device instantly evaporated when I found out about the mandatory cloud integration. I already know from a customer support situation that Amazon has remote access to kindles, they can tell you what files you have on device, etc. It's depressingly bad... Bonus: this reMarkable website does not work without third party JS. It's completely blank. One of the 3rd parties is hotjar, which does all sorts of shady analytics like clickstream and keylogging.
- ReverseCold 9y ago> My enthusiasm for this device instantly evaporated when I found out about the mandatory cloud integration. From GP: "So if you don't like their cloud offering, you can turn of wifi and be sure your data is local"
- blub 9y agoThe GP and lima have both claimed that one can transfer files without the cloud, but this is not mentioned in their FAQ (https://support.remarkable.com/hc/en-us https://support.remarkable.com/hc/en-us). This is a direct quote: "Use the reMarkable desktop app or the reMarkable mobile app to transfer documents and ebooks onto your device. Once imported, your files will be synced across your connected devices. reMarkable works best with our custom built apps for iPhone, Android, PC and Mac." By using a search engine on their web-site(!) one can find details about USB support: "NB: This functionality is currently experimental, as we haven't fully implemented it yet. We will work to improve how this works and looks in future software updates." Maybe this is a great device which allows open access, but it's very difficult to figure this out from their website.
- sangnoir 9y ago> Maybe this is a great device which allows open access, but it's very difficult to figure this out from their website. Isn't that par for the course for esoteric information only useful to highly advanced users in the consumer electronics[1] space? I'm yet to see an Android device that touts unlockable bootloaders on their websites. 1. Being "open" isn't the ReMarkable's tablet schtick/selling point. It's a consumer product that happens to be open. The minority users who want to take advantage of that know where to look/can find that out on HN.
- blub 9y agoI'm talking about being able to transfer your files between two devices sitting 10cm apart, without using someone elses servers. This is a very basic feature, supported by everything except those spyware products which are selling customer information or those that reserve the right to do it in the future. If reMarkable is not one of those, they should make it clear in their marketing.
- crtasm 9y agoTo make it more likely you'll stay within their ecosystem and buy more from their app/book/etc. store, is always my first assumption.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThey can always steal from Amazon's playbook and randomly delete sideloaded files.
- lima 9y agoThey tried, but exposing a "simple USB mass storage" isn't easy at all from a running operating system. USB mass storage requires exposing a block device with a filesystem, which is error-prone and complex. This is why file-based protocols like MTP exist. But, since you can SSH into the device, rsync works just fine on the Remarkable. :)
- cptskippy 9y agoSo because it's not easy, it shouldn't be done? Personally I would be ok with my device disabling it's UI while it emulated a mass storage device when plugged into a host.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoThey had a variety of pretty big engineering challenges to solve: getting the form factor right, making sure your hand didn't interfere with the screen while using it, getting the pen-and-paper feel right, and getting the e-ink refresh rate down to where you could draw and write on it and have it feel natural. I'm fine with them choosing to solve those challenges instead of supporting USB mass storage.
- userbinator 9y ago...and designing, developing, and supporting your own custom application and its associated protocol isn't an "engineering challenge"? USB mass storage requires exposing a block device with a filesystem, which is error-prone and complex. The point is, USBMS is a solved problem. My MP3/MP4 players, my Android phone, my satnav, even my soldering iron[1] can do it. The Linux kernel, which reMarkable uses, already includes support for this[2]. It's conceptually very simple --- in its most basic form, if the device detects that it's plugged in, it unmounts its internal block device and lets the host control it, and vice-versa. More advanced functionality, such as found on Android and many MP3/MP4s, lets you choose whether the device or the host controls its storage, via a very obvious interface on the device itself (one position is "charge only", the other is "transfer files".) [1]https://hackaday.com/2017/07/24/review-ts100-soldering-iron/ https://hackaday.com/2017/07/24/review-ts100-soldering-iron/ [2]https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/usb/mass-storage.txt https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/usb/mass-storage.tx...
- ReaderReader 9y agoLock in. Without it you won't get investor money.
- cptskippy 9y ago> Whatever happened to simple USB mass storage where you can just plug it in and copy files back and forth? I agree that it should definitely be an option because there are plenty of situations when using this device where you might not even have connectivity. > the default behaviour of requiring one to send files from a computer out far away to some server on the Internet, and then back to the tablet sitting only a few metres away seems rather silly and wasteful. It is definitely silly and wasteful but it's oh so simple when it works correctly. Instead of dealing with SMB shares, email, FTP, rsync, cables, mass storage devices, properly ejecting things, or any other technology; you instead just put a file in a designated folder and it's available on all of your devices in a matter of moments.
- tjoff 9y agorsync is much easier than creating an account and gives me more control. It was one of the first things I thought of, "I hope I can run rsync on this thing to sync notes".
- cptskippy 9y agoI guess if this device is targeted only at power users then rsync support is great. If they're hoping to make this a mass market device then they probably need something more user friendly.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoIt's because Microsoft exerts it's patents on FAT32.