3 ms·
Before I say what I'm about to say: I know nothing about Airbnb's finances (aside from what's mentioned in the article) and I have no idea if it actually does o
by kelnos 9y ago
Before I say what I'm about to say: I know nothing about Airbnb's finances (aside from what's mentioned in the article) and I have no idea if it actually does or does not make sense for them to go public this year from the standpoint of the success of their business.
However, in a general sense, I believe that any company that provides their employees equity as a part of compensation has a moral obligation to get to a point where they can provide liquidity to those employees. It seems the founders and some early employees of Airbnb were able to cash out some of their shares in previous VC rounds, but that likely leaves the bulk of employees holding options or stock in a position of hanging onto something they aren't sure they'll ever be able to cash out.
Obviously there needs to be a balance of priorities: going public in a situation where the stock price will likely tank or the business will fail before employees can sell will of course not help anyone. But ignoring the fact that you have a ton of employees depending on some sort of liquidity event (even if it's just a company-initiated stock buyback) is IMO unethical.
Not saying that's definitely what's happening here at Airbnb, but the article sure makes it smell that way.
- ericd 9y agoSounds like employees may have been able to cash out a bit via tender offers. The founders and early employees have little financial incentive to push for an IPO. They have cashed in about $350 million worth of equity, said people with knowledge of the matter.
- dalbasal 9y agoWell... that's a small number of "insiders," essentially. The person most vulnerable to the OP's concerns is a rank and file employee with $100k of paper wealth structured as an incentive to stay long-term, the 162nd hire. Equity starts as part of ordinary compensation, but converts to long term employee retention incentives as times goes on and the company increases in value. To be indifferent to these employees' interests is immoral, after you've essentially asked them to make long term decisions based on this deal. These employees understand the least, have the least amount of information. They have the least negotiation power, and hence have equity deals with the fewest protections. They have the least influence over strategic decisions like this, so their interests come last. Owning so much private shares in one company is typically a bad wealth strategy for them, possibly 100% of their "portfolio." Typically after leaving, iliquid shares must be purchased with cash (exercising options) or the options are lost. At the very least, (1) employees should have their options exercised, converted to shares at the companies' expense, after vesting. (2) The protections (preferences, anti-dilution etc.) an average investor would demand should be attached to these shares. That would leave them with an asset they may prefer to sell, but at least they unambiguously own it. Generally though, I agree with the OP. If after raising significant funds and expanding the employee equity pool past 10-20 employees, you can either go for a 5 yr race to IPO or find another liquidity solution for employees. It's possible.
- jtmcmc 9y agosounds like the softbank purchase could do this. That seems to be what softbank was doing with Uber as well.
- ggg9990 9y agoSorry, you must not know that AirBnb is in the Silicon Valley/SF Bay Area. “Moral obligations” don’t mean jack shit here.
- kelnos 9y agoCan't downvote because you're a direct reply to mine, but please, there's no need for this. I get (and often share) your cynicism, but your comment doesn't add to the discussion at all.
- joeblau 9y agoIf these companies were profitable from the beginning, some sort of profit sharing mechanism could compensate for providing a financial reward. The challenge is that these businesses are setup to lose money until they get to some "scale" not profit margin. The scale goal leads founders to raise tons of Venture Capital and even VC's like Bill Gurley says that the constraint of profitability has been relaxed across the industry[1]. Bill says it's 10 or 100 times easier to lose 40 million to make 100 million than it is to run a profitable company to 100 million. If you extrapolate that out, there is no incentive from the majority stake holders (VC's) to IPO until they are ready. [1] - https://youtu.be/-cxK1YQfMXA?t=1165 https://youtu.be/-cxK1YQfMXA?t=1165
- mathattack 9y agoAirBnB still has all their VC money in the bank.
- kelnos 9y agoSure, but I expect not all companies can be run profitably from day one, or even close. Some markets also benefit from network effects, so prioritizing profit over growth can lead to your eventual failure. Arguably the excessive availability of venture capital makes it a lot easier to go the growth/scale route, and to do so on someone else's dime, and this encourages people to ignore the idea of building a profitable business from the beginning. And that sucks, but if you're trying to enter a market where the norm is to run at a loss in order to gain scale, you probably aren't going to be successful avoiding VC money and charging higher prices, unless you can differentiate yourself as a premium product, or something.
- empath75 9y agoIf they’re making profits, they could buy back shares from the employees, gradually.