3 ms·
Maybe a better question is how to prepare in advance. You can design your systems to avoid retaining user data. Or you can do business from a jurisdiction that
by mirimir 9y ago
Maybe a better question is how to prepare in advance. You can design your systems to avoid retaining user data. Or you can do business from a jurisdiction that doesn't recognize NSLs. Or perhaps from an unknown jurisdiction.
- jonnybgood 9y ago> Or you can do business from a jurisdiction that doesn't recognize NSLs. Or perhaps from an unknown jurisdiction. That means not doing business in the US at all.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoWhich makes it fair game for direct targeted attacks by the NSA.
- jonnybgood 9y agoYou can still be targeted if you’re a foreign business operating in the US.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, you can and will be targeted. So if you go that route, you'd better know what you're doing.
- bpanon 9y agoThe entire universe is fair game for the NSA.
- mirimir 9y agoRight. They pretty much do whatever they want, and lie as necessary to frustrate oversight, and protect operational methods. They are, after all, a branch of the military.
- cesarb 9y agoFor someone outside the USA, a targeted attack by the NSA is no different than a targeted attack by anyone else. They are breaking the law, and you are allowed and supposed to defend against them. If you are within the USA, however, they can use things like these National Security Letters which you are not allowed to go against.
- geofft 9y agoThis is incorrect for a few reasons: you can certainly defend against NSLs, even those that you can't defend against are targeted (see the ones Twilio received), they're from the FBI and not the NSA, and as hackers the NSA is more skilled and more well-funded than most other attackers you're defending against.
- mirimir 9y agoThe NSA does have lots of skilled hackers. But so do other national TLAs. And there are many freelance hackers.
- Feniks 9y agoMost countries will happily throw anyone under the bus if the US intelligence services ask them too. Besides if you're doing something the NSA doesn't like local law enforcement probably won't like it either.
- mirimir 9y agoMost countries, yes. But some countries, clearly no. Snowden is still in Russia, for example. And China typically doesn't cooperate with the NSA and its friends.
- MertsA 9y agoThe NSA has made direct targeted attacks at US companies in the past. Just look at Google, they got NSLs and had to cooperate with PRISM yet at the same time the NSA still dug up their fiber and tapped it. With the NSA's twisted logic that a search is not a search unless it matches and it's fine to search data so long as there's a chance it involves a non-US citizen I think jurisdiction is largely irrelevant for attacks other than the necessity of one seeing as the NSA has access to a secret court that has a history of never siding against them. I'd view eliminating tyrannical government orders as a plus.
- mirimir 9y agoIndeed. The NSA has also intercepted device shipments, in order to install backdoors. And some US firms have resorted to shipping through more-or-less anonymous intermediaries to circumvent that.
- wyager 9y agoIf you sell physical goods, maybe not. If you’re a middleman or you sell digital goods, you still can do business with people living in the US.
- mirimir 9y agoYou can do business with US customers. It's not uncommon. Maybe they need some OPSEC, but hey.
- tylermadson 9y agoit means US isolates it self from immigrant s?
- nolok 9y ago> Or perhaps from an unknown jurisdiction. Good luck with that, unless your vision of doing business doesn't involve ever charging customers, especially for b2b.
- wyager 9y agoThis is one of the primary use cases Bitcoin was invented to address.
- jebeng 9y agoI'm interested to see if the US is able to do anything to Bitfinex now as a litmus test to see how wide their reach is in 2018. As far as I know they have zero US presence, and don't offer services to US customers. BTC-e went down hard for example. But they had some much more obvious links with criminal enterprise. Although even if it is possible to stay outside of the reach of the US, losing access to the international banking system is quite the handicap for any business.
- nolok 9y agoGiven that even payment processors like Stripe are removing it because the verification time is too long, it is sadly not satisfying solution in any way. Also, again, good luck getting any b2b when you tell them they need to pay in bitcoin only.
- linuxps2 9y agoLuckily that's no longer an issue now that interest has faded and the mempool has cleared. Also, reducing on-chain transactions (and thus keeping the mempool clear, on-chain fees low, and verification times low) is pretty much the main use case of Lightening Network. The massive rise in fees and tx congestion was caused by the massive interest in BTC at the end of 2017. Something tells me if you are doing B2B in a shady jurisdiction, the companies you are doing work with would be more than willing to jump through hoops to deal exclusively in BTC
- 9y ago
- dboreham 9y ago>You can design your systems to avoid retaining user data. This helps for data from the past, but TLAs can order you to change your code such that it will in future retain data they want to see.
- mirimir 9y agoRight, that's why Lavabit shut down. And that's why ProtonMail operates from Switzerland, and CounterMail from Sweden. But the best hardcore option is not being vulnerable to coercion.