2 ms·
The complaint is that a device which was once useful is getting less so year by year because of vendor lock in and planned obsolescence, and not because of hard
by ryandrake 9y ago
The complaint is that a device which was once useful is getting less so year by year because of vendor lock in and planned obsolescence, and not because of hardware failure. This is a “should” question: Should a device manufacturer be able to decide to make an otherwise fully functional device less and less functional until it is useless?
Case 1: Like others here I have an old iPad 1 which is stuck on iOS 5 or so, and although the hardware is still as flawless as the day I bought it, I can use it for fewer and fewer computing tasks year after year, can install fewer and fewer software on it, and have no way to fix the problem.
Contrast that with case 2, my 12 year old Dell PC which has undergone a number of software updates (currently running Linux beautifully) and continues to be very useful and updatable to this day.
The trend seems to be to move us more and more towards case 1 and away from case 2, which is in my vein an overall loss for end users.
- panglott 9y agoIt's not just hardware upgradability: some of the problem could be solved if app developers created simple, lightweight iOS 5-compatible apps. But of course there's no business case for supporting early iPads, and I don't even think many early iPad owners necessarily think there should be. The iPad is great because it is compact and a specific, coherent design. I could use a 12-year-old desktop tower for my evening reading, but I don't want to.
- ryandrake 9y agoThe current version of Xcode will not even let a developer target 5.0 even if he/she wanted to.
- dkonofalski 9y agoWhile I understand the complaint, I have a fundamental disagreement with these types of arguments. If you were to restore this iPad to factory settings, it would function exactly the same way or just as well as if you had just purchased it. The apps that you get from the App Store are additions to the product and you know going in that they could stop working or stop being updated and get trampled in the march of technology. As long as you have a WiFi connection, though, that iPad will be useful for web browsing, notes, calendars, email and everything else that it was good for when it was purchased. In fact, I just restored an iPad 2 (Not an iPad Air 2, an original, non-retina iPad 2) and my parents are now using it as their Facebook/email machine. It's just as zippy (maybe a little slower but it doesn't feel slow) as it was when I bought it for those tasks and I can even FaceTime them on it without issue. There are tons of applications on the PC that no longer work because of changes in Windows. Unless the manufacturer decides to give you some kind of backwards support (like Microsoft including an XP emulator in later versions of Windows which, kudos to them, is not something they should have done or needed to do), I don't see how there can be an expectation of the hardware outliving the software. The software has always been the bottleneck and it always will be. I think it's great that the iPad is still the same out of the box as it was all that time ago.