4 ms·
Edit: You know what? This post sucked. Here's a good link I used while babbling thoughtlessly (unless it wasn't good per _delirium): http://www.dof.ca.gov/budge
by jerf 16y ago
Edit: You know what? This post sucked. Here's a good link I used while babbling thoughtlessly (unless it wasn't good per _delirium): http://www.dof.ca.gov/budgeting/budget_faqs/information/documents/CHART-B.pdf http://www.dof.ca.gov/budgeting/budget_faqs/information/docu...
See my reply to reynolds, which was the only valuable part. The second paragraph is my real point, and I mean that "if" clause.
- reynolds 16y agoHe mentions in the article that California has plenty of money but aren't spending it on education.
- jerf 16y agoI will admit I'm reading into things a bit by assuming that he's not advocating cutting government back when he says things like "your parents and their parents lashed out at government (as though there were something else that could replace it) with tax limits, term limits, safe districts, throw-away-the-key imprisonment no matter the cost, smoke-and-mirrors budgeting, and a rule never to use the words taxes and services in the same paragraph." That doesn't sound like a fiscally-conservative libertarian to me. If he believes in refocusing the priorities and perhaps even seeing a net spending drop while ending up with more education spending, I would consider that defensible and the numbers I produced can certainly support the position that there is some room for rethinking here. If he believes this should manifest as yet more money given to this government, no, I don't think piling more money on is the solution. That's why I'm looking at the total income for the state rather than exactly focusing on the exact amount dedicated to the worthy tasks. It is only one part of the story.
- _delirium 16y ago> on expenditures growing faster than inflation and faster than the growth of the economy I can buy that they've grown faster than inflation, but have they indeed grown faster than the growth of the economy? I haven't been able to dig up good data on what CA state expenditures were as a percentage of state GDP in, say, the 1960s. (They're currently around 24% of state GDP, if you can find something to compare that to.) Incidentally, the document you linked doesn't appear to cover most of the actual budget; it's the kind of fake official budget that's passed every year, which currently covers about 1/4 of actual spending. This site has better estimates for the past 20 years, but doesn't go back past 1992: http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/downchart_gs.php?year=1990_2010&view=1&expand=&units=b&fy=fy10&chart=F0-total&bar=1&stack=1&size=m&title=&state=CA&color=c&local=s http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/downchart_gs.php?year=19...
- jerf 16y agoSee bokonist's post(s), caveats and all.
- rjprins 16y agoIt should be noted that government is expected to get relatively more and more expensive because it's most of it's duties are of the service type. Services like schools, public transport, health care generally defy automation but costs still rise to stay on par with other industries. As the costs of other products become lower, expect to pay more for services.
- bokonist 16y agoThe numbers on total state nominal income are here: http://www.bea.gov/regional/remdmap/REMDMap.aspx http://www.bea.gov/regional/remdmap/REMDMap.aspx So it looks like state spending rose from 11% of total income in 1977 to 14% today. And total income usually grows slightly faster than the economy (economic growth = change total income - change in the price level). Thus state spending has been growing faster than incomes rise, faster than inflation and faster than the economy has been growing.