3 ms·
One thing I don’t see acknowledged in the enthusiasm for rail-based public transit is its propensity for cascading failure. A road network has the very nice pro
by closeparen 9y ago
One thing I don’t see acknowledged in the enthusiasm for rail-based public transit is its propensity for cascading failure. A road network has the very nice property that a disabled vehicle can coast off the road, or only block a subset of lanes, leading to a “graceful” degradation and creating backpressure that encourages other drivers to take different routes, which exist. It isn’t fun, but it’s a pretty amazing resilience story compared to alternatives. Many commodity parts, failing in ways that the system as a whole recovers from. You would think software engineers would be more positive about that.
We build train systems in such a way that if any component fails, the entire network is fucked. There’s only one way to get between A and B, and if it’s blocked by an emergency situation or the failure of some bespoke part, no trains will pass until the situation is resolved. From a distributed systems perspective, that’s horrifically bad engineering.
Maybe there’s some way to make rail networks more road-like in this way, or to build better bus systems that people will enjoy and embrace, but as it stands, the differences in failure modes motivate drivers to stay in their cars.
- avianlyric 9y agoRail based transport on cities makes a lot of sense. In cities usually the only way to significantly increase transport capacity it to dig tunnels. Building on the surface is just too difficult. When you build tunnels your cost proportional to the volume of earth you remove, which means your cost is the square of your tunnel diameter. Double the diameter, quadruple the cost. This is where rail shines. Rail let’s you run faster, longer, vehicles in much smaller spaces, because the rails guarantee you won’t collide with the walls or each other. Just look at the London tube, with trains only slightly smaller than the tunnels. This means smaller cheaper tunnels, so you can build more of them. In this system the tunnels already eliminate any real ability to reroute, so you may as well put the biggest vehicles in there and maintain them properly.
- closeparen 9y agoA system experiencing cascading failure has no capacity, and at this point it should be considered engineering malpractice to imagine that American democratic institutions will do the maintenance on anything, in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
- avianlyric 9y agoI’m not sure what your point is. It’s not viable to build more roads, so tunnels it must be. Tunnels are expensive, so rail is a requirement. Maintenance is must, regardless of political will. Saying that US institutions can’t/won’t maintain things, thus don’t build things that need maintenance is just unhelpful. You might as well say we should all give up now and go home.
- Animats 9y agoThe NYC subway system is four track in most places, and there are lots of switches, so a stalled train can be bypassed. This also allows maintenance while the system is running. That's why NYC can run 24 hours a day, unlike most other subway systems.