8 ms·
I feel like the first thing we should talk about is how this is effectively a keylogger, similar to Windows 10's inking and typing setting, albeit with likely p
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I feel like the first thing we should talk about is how this is effectively a keylogger, similar to Windows 10's inking and typing setting, albeit with likely poorer security.
Collecting everything you type into a web browser (or MS Office) and sending it to them seems like a really bad idea.
- fiatjaf 9y agoYes, it is crazy. For these cases we shouldn't be using SaaS at all. Installed applications can still be useful, I guess.
- oneweekwonder 9y agoAnything you can recommend that integrates with a browser but runs locally and check grammar and spelling mistakes?
- adjwilli 9y agoA quick Google search and I found https://grammark.org/dist/#/ https://grammark.org/dist/#/ which could be incorporated into a Chrome extension.
- rak 9y agoI put "teh game is a art" into this one and it told me there were no problems with the writing.
- dspillett 9y agoI've not found time to try any of them yet so I can't comment on how they compare to Grammarly, but there are F/OSS alternatives. https://languagetool.org/ https://languagetool.org/ for one supports running your own instance of the server-side portion out-of-the-box. You could run it truly locally assuming your device is appropriate, or your own server which might be more flexible as you can support a greater range of devices and share custom dictionaries between them.
- oneweekwonder 9y ago> This extension will check your text by sending it to https://languagetool.org https://languagetool.org over an encrypted connection. Your text will not be stored. Gives me a "privacy policy", "continue and don't ask again" or "cancel" hyperlink, nothing else. If I want to use it the first time. But if you open the extension options under the "more tools" > extensions tab you can set the LanguageTool API server URL[0]. Going to try to setup a server over the weekend, thanks. [0]: http://wiki.languagetool.org/http-server http://wiki.languagetool.org/http-server
- neuralnetguy 9y agoImproving user input through learning and trying harder.
- tomc1985 9y agoYour browser can do spellcheck...
- shagie 9y agoIt doesn’t detect the passive voice, punctuation errors, or tense mismatch. While spelling catches many, it doesn’t catch them all.
- mygo 9y agoI, for one, don’t really care if someone has written to me in the passive voice. Or is changing tense. The message is still received. If it will mean they are more secure that way, then I will allow it.
- IanCal 9y agoOk, but others want to correct those issues,and are specifically asking for ways to do so that don't require sending all typing away to a third party.
- tomc1985 9y agoThat sounds more like you need to work on your grammar. One should be able to do those things on their own
- IncRnd 9y ago> Your browser can do spellcheck... Yes... But your browser won't detect "spellcheck do can browser your" Grammar is more than just spelling.
- JoshMnem 9y agoYour brain. If you offload too many tasks to computers, those skills will weaken.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoBut our brain logs our keystrokes!
- danieldk 9y agoIt doesn't. How many times haven't colleagues asked, 'how did you do that in vim?' Only for me to stutter and literally having to repeat the command while looking at the keyboard?
- oneweekwonder 9y ago> Your brain. Trying I promise, even different languages. But I'm not a native speaker and a bit dyslexic. So someone or thing looking over my shoulder would be nice.
- mrguyorama 9y agoI highly recommend friends and family as proofreaders.
- skellera 9y agoRealized this when it wanted to install the plug in. Pretty much installed it. Used it for what I needed then uninstalled. They have a word plugin which I believe needs to be explicitly turned on so that’s a better use.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoAren't all password managers keyloggers too?
- the8472 9y agoThere are password managers that don't involve any cloud services.
- ransom1538 9y agoI am too paranoid to use them, but, from what I read (regarding the biggest one): "LastPass encrypts your Vault before it goes to the server using 256-bit AES encryption. Since the Vault is already encrypted before it leaves your computer and reaches the LastPass server, not even LastPass employees can see your sensitive data" If there is an attack still possible (even using LastPass employees) can you post it here?
- rileyteige 9y agoNot sure if you're using the credential "autofill" feature, but somewhat recently there was an attack in which their autofill extension could be tricked into "autofilling" specific sites' credentials on a malicious webpage. (Not sure if this has been fixed by LastPass) The fix for that was to not use autofill and revert to manually grabbing your username/password when filling out a login form. Aside from that, I am not aware of other "hot" attack vectors.
- LocalPCGuy 9y agoLastPass has been very diligent in fixing issues like the one you list. Usually very quickly (sometimes in hours, not even days.) And most of the issues you've read about with LastPass have been fixed before being disclosed because of how responsive they are. Users still need to practice skepticism and ultimately it is their responsibility to protect their passwords. But LastPass has been a very good citizen when it comes to being as secure as possible.
- 9y ago
- eejdoowad 9y agoKeylogging is just the beginning. Any (and many) browser extensions have the ability to record everything you do on every page you visit. All it takes is specifying the <all_urls> permission in the extension’s manifest and adding some event listeners. It has to work this way or browsers wouldn’t be truly extensible. Be mindful of which extensions you install.
- ameister14 9y agoAnd pay attention if the companies that make your extensions are sold.
- kakarot 9y agoIt's ridiculous that we're at this point where using a handful of software applications means keeping up to date with the social life and financial situation of the developer, reading changelogs, etc. And you only can spare both the time and cognitive load to do this for at most a dozen or two applications, if you really care. The rest, you just have to trust that enough other people are watching carefully. But the average person isn't going to keep up with even one application. They only bought their computer so they could browse the web and check emails, not so they could learn the details of how it works. Likewise, most of us don't buy a car in order to spend a lot of time learning about exactly how a combustion engine works. We don't have the time. Granted, this board is laden with engineers who will make the time to understand how their tools work, but we simply cannot expect this kind of effort from most people. So, like we have to trust lower-level components to be scrutinized elsewhere, and trust we will be alerted in case of critical issues, the general population must trust the "nerds" to get things right and keep them safe. This means that typically, the best attack surfaces will be small, widely-distributed, low-level software stacks whose developers can easily be compromised. Not just software either, but hardware. It does seem like this is ultimately a battle we are going to lose without regulatory legislation in domains that require mass-deployment of software that can potentially breach Constitutional rights. In order to be federally qualified as "privacy-friendly", you have to meet certain guidelines both on a hardware and software level. This would include automatic transmission or collection of certain kinds of data without very express permission.
- IronWolve 9y ago>I feel like the first thing we should talk about is how this is effectively a keylogger,.. Same as Google/Firefox autocomplete and history, or keyboard spell checker, or email autocomplete and spell checker, etc. So linux and android are also in the boat of having apps that make your life easier, also need security enforced. Just wanted to say, its not a Windows only issue, OSX, iphone, android, they are all going to be affected to simular issues.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoIsn't this also true of nearly all installable keyboards on mobile devices?
- DougBTX 9y agoProbably yes, through at least by default on iOS custom keyboards don't have network access.
- giobox 9y agoOn iOS you currently have to explicitly allow network access to third party keyboards in the settings app (the not very clearly named "Allow Full Access" toggle), which as others have pointed out, is disabled by default on all newly installed keyboards. I have no idea how this works on other popular mobile device platforms.
- nakedrobot2 9y agoWhy is this story not bigger news? Grammarly is excreting ads into my eyes before nearly every YouTube video I watch, yet I don't see any mainstream sites covering this.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoMostly because cloud-connected keyloggers are mainstream. As I mentioned, Windows does it if you have their "inking and typing" setting enabled. A lot of mobile keyboard apps do it, especially if they say they use the cloud to help correct your typing. Of course, in the case of Microsoft or Google, you presumably either have disabled the setting or you place your trust in their security practices that it is okay, because they are top tier companies, and most people send them all their private data anyways. There are a LOT of things out there that collect everything you type these days, and rarely to people want to define them as keyloggers.
- Feniks 9y agoIf it acts like a keylogger its a keylogger. When people want privacy they will inevitably have to give up usability. I ditched Swiftkey for an open source Android keyboard that doesn't connect online or asks for any permissions. Its CRAP but it doesn't leak.
- rhizome 9y agoOoh, what keyboard? Does it have gesture typing, and is it better than gboard (Google's own), which is the worst I've ever used?
- lcampbell 9y agoI can't speak for GP, but I switched to Hacker's Keyboard[1] which doesn't support gesture typing. I'm pretty happy with it, though it's pretty barebones (it doesn't even turn on the phone's radio). Took a bit getting used to -- the recommendations are different and it felt like the key hitboxes weren't the same as gboard, but it felt pretty familiar after a couple of weeks. [1] https://github.com/klausw/hackerskeyboard https://github.com/klausw/hackerskeyboard
- 77pt77 9y agoAny difference between that and say fcitx?