3 ms·
I know I'm going to be downmodded, but I don't care, I want to share my feelings. Java is one of my least favorite things in the world. Yeah, I know, starving
by jrockway 16y ago
I know I'm going to be downmodded, but I don't care, I want to share my feelings.
Java is one of my least favorite things in the world. Yeah, I know, starving children, war, genocide, that stuff is bad too. But Java is what I hate most.
So it makes me ... gleeful ... to see that Oracle is doing such an amazing job killing it. People want to keep using it, they want new features, they want to improve the ecosystem, they want to pay Oracle lots of money for the privilege of using it. But instead, Oracle sues its users, fires the innovators that made it, and does everything in their power to kill it. And now we have a "dead language"(which, as a Perl programmer, is a term I really like to throw around and mean).
Anyway, good work, Oracle.
- mcav 16y agoThose of us who work with the JVM (in spite of Java) feel otherwise.
- jrockway 16y agoWhy doesn't the "active" JVM community fork the OSS dump from a few years ago and start improving that?
- artsrc 16y agoFrom what I can tell, there is a patent grant on the OSS version provided you pass the closed source compatibility suite. > (iv) pass all test suites relating to the most recent published version of the specification of the Java 2 Platform, Standard Edition, that are available from SUN http://java.sun.com/docs/books/jls/second_edition/html/jcopyright.doc.html http://java.sun.com/docs/books/jls/second_edition/html/jcopy...
- jrockway 16y agoAh, so not open source at all. That's a shame.
- _delirium 16y agoThat's an explicit Java patent grant separate from the open-sourcing (note the 2000 date, long predating OpenJDK). The exact patent status of OpenJDK is somewhat murky, though. Some people (incl. some lawyers) think that there's an implicit patent grant in the GPL, because the GPL explicitly prohibits distributing under the GPL any software that does not have all relevant patents licensed under royalty-free licenses. So if you gave someone a license to use your software under the GPL but didn't give them license to use a relevant patent, your licensing is self-contradictory: you will be simultaneously giving them a license to use your code under the GPL, and then that license is immediately terminated by the GPL's Section 7. Therefore it's possible that a court might infer that giving someone a GPL license must imply a patent grant, because it would be absurd to assume that the licensor intended to give a license that was immediately self-terminating. Courts do generally try to avoid interpretations of parties' actions that would assume they were meaning to undertake null or self-contradictory actions. But I'm not sure how much I'd bet on that outcome. edit: Forgot another unlitigated possible angle. It's one thing to open-source something with a very explicit reservation of patent rights, like "this source code may be used under the terms of the [license], but Sun reserves any rights to patents that may cover portions of the software, which must be licensed separately". But what if you open-source it with a more blanket statement? With the OpenJDK release, there was a lot of rhetoric about openness from Sun, that amounted to: Java is now open source, you may use it for anything you want, as long as you comply with the terms of the GPL. It's possible that a "here, use this for free if you want" offer implies a license of any patents needed to use it. At the very least, it'd be somewhat dishonest to go up to someone and say, "hey, I've got this great thing you can use... here I'll give it to you free", and then come back five years later and accuse them of violating a patent. I mean, you're the one who gave it to them in the first place and told them it was okay to use it! So this might either imply a patent license, or at least present some sort of "inducement" or "estoppel" defense to a patent suit.
- donaq 16y agoWhile I am no fan of Java the language myself, there is no reason for schadenfreude. I would like to see Java survive, if only because of its virtual machine (and Jython, Clojure, JRuby, etc).
- jrockway 16y agoProbably no reason that Clojure and Scala can't be ported to their own VM, especially with Clojure's self-hosting push. Yeah, the JVM has a lot of libraries, but the libraries will follow the developers when the dead-ness of Java starts getting in the way.
- ldh 16y agoJava the language != JVM
- jrockway 16y agoIt's kind of like when you jump into the water to save your drowning friend, and you both die. The JVM was just trying to be nice, but its friend was too much weight for it to save.
- jbooth 16y agoWell, no offense, but remind me never to work with you. I'm sorry that the Java programmers were condescending to the Perl programmers back in 2002 but could you just get over it? Sometimes Java is the right tool for a given job. If you're against any platform on principle (aside from the single-vendor principle), then you're guaranteed to be wrong some % of the time. If all you do is webapps, fine, Java sucks for webapps, continue hating.
- jacquesm 16y ago> If all you do is webapps, fine, Java sucks for webapps, It sucks, but is actually amazingly performant. (much to my surprise I might add)
- jbooth 16y agoOf course it's performant, HotSpot FTW. That is, if you're not leaking memory or file handles. But assuming you're competent and not using JBoss, long-running process with hotspot native compilation means that it'll soak into a performance profile that's perfect for what it's doing. Entirely different category of performance than scripting languages.
- loewenskind 16y agoThe Perl programmers I personally know hate Java because it's always been more popular and had more libraries.
- jrockway 16y agoI hate it because it's designed to prevent me from writing good code. I like writing good code, so I don't like tools that stand in my way. Perl lets me do whatever I want. (Which in my case, is to use a state-of-the-art object system, instead of Java's baked-in 1970s era object system.) Perl has many more high-quality Free libraries, and I personally know a good percentage of the authors, which makes it all that much more appealing. Java may have more programmers, but there is no community; it's all 9-5ers that couldn't care less about programming. Honestly, the only language I've ever used that didn't have enough libraries was Common Lisp.
- snom370 16y agoBe gleeful all you want, but this is mostly a _patent_ suit. In fact, if you're running a fully compliant Java stack, Sun has given you a patent grant for that and you should be in the clear. But Perl6 running on Parrot? Oracles JVM-related patents may very well apply, so your best bet is to hope that your favourite language never gets used by a high profile company in one of the next leading mobile platforms. Google went out of its way not to use any code created by Sun, and didn't even use the JVM as a foundation in order to (hopefully) be in the clear. So be careful what you wish for. My first reaction was also that of "good riddance!", but in the end the whole situation is just sad. I never liked programming Java, so I decided to keep it out of my programming life. Maybe that's why I don't hate it so much. :)