6 ms·
The marbled crayfish is a mutant species that clones itself
- pixl97 9y ago>Only 1 in 10,000 species reproduce by clones. When you see a statistic like that it points to a filtering event in a species. Much like the previous type of banana was clones, once a disease rises up that attacks that type of clone there just isn't the genetic diversity and rate of change to save the species.
- danimal88 9y agoI dunno, given the number of bugs alone, a statistic like that strikes me as just numerical drama.
- frozenport 9y agoMissing from the article is that unlike most self-cloning animals (I know of no other), Marmorkrebs, has a triploid genome.
- diego_moita 9y agoIf I understand this correctly, asexual reproduction in plants is called apomixis[0] and the dandelions and blackberries have been doing it for millions of years. In animals it is called parthenogenesis and happens in lizards, snakes, birds and sharks[1]. All of them have been around quite some time on earth, also. What helped these species to be so resilient to a devastating infection when other animals that reproduce sexually (Central American frogs, North American bats) are being wiped away so badly by fungal infections? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apomixis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apomixis [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenogenesis#Natural_occurrence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenogenesis#Natural_occurr...
- justinjlynn 9y agoAsexual reproduction gives an individual (in the genetic sense) more time to reproduce while also acting as something of a checksum on the genome as a whole. Survival during disease outbreaks would certainly be increased if one didn't need to balance infection versus dying of old age against somewhat more genetically advantageous sexual reproduction. It's an interesting delay tactic.
- icegreentea2 9y agoIt could literally just be time and luck. We started mass production (cloning) of cavendish bananas around the the 1900s, and REALLY started mass production (cloning) in the 1950s, we only started seeing strains of banana blight effect it in the last few decades. Obviously there are all sorts of differences between these cases, but it's probably worth thinking about a bit. Oh, also it looks like most animals capable of parthenogenesis can also under go sexual reproduction, helping them hedge against certain types of threats. Also remember that we're looking at animal population on human generation timescales. One might say that a species with a population of millions being wiped out to a population of thousands (that are fungal resistant) over a time scale of 60 years as a 'disaster'. It in our life time it probably is, cause our activities would probably completely fuck over whatever is left. But in the absense of our activity, those thousands or so could still form a viable population and if they still have a good ecological niche to occupy, could easily within a few hundred/thousand years regain their original population. And we'd be all completely blind to that, cause that's not how we tend to think.
- IncRnd 9y ago> we only started seeing strains of banana blight effect it in the last few decades. ... it's probably worth thinking about a bit. It was likely an oversight to not mention why we started to clone the Cavendish. Panama disease devastated the also cloned Gros Michel cultivar over 60 years ago. That's why, today, we eat a different banana than those who came before us.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> All of them have been around quite some time on earth, also. Asexual species have been around for "quite some time" by comparison to, say, all of recorded history. They tend to be very recent on a geological timescale. http://www.razib.com/wordpress/?p=101136 http://www.razib.com/wordpress/?p=101136
- jobigoud 9y ago> Asexual species have been around for "quite some time" by comparison to, say, all of recorded history. They tend to be very recent on a geological timescale. Asexual reproduction was there first and predates sexual reproduction by several billion years. Some species then evolved back asexual reproduction, like this marbled crayfish.
- masklinn 9y agoAsexual reproduction yes, but GP's point is that asexual species seem much younger, seem to generally speaking not "last" on long timescales. Which would make sense, if an individual has great fitness they can "boom" extremely rapidly, but then any change in condition or emergence of specialised predator or disease will take down the entire population just as quickly because it has very low variability and flexibility.
- jobigoud 9y agoAh, thanks for the clarification. But then all species, asexual or not, are young with regards to geological times. I think the order of magnitude for longest species lifespan is about 10 million years. Is there really a correlation between species lifespan and method of reproduction?
- Scarblac 9y agoThis crayfish evolved 25 years ago. The article cites another study on asexual flea species, where the mutation was 1250 years old. That's two examples and both very far away from 10 million years.
- vanderZwan 9y agoLow genetic diversity can have unexpected benefits; within Argentine ants it has given rise to a global supercolony, because the pheromones of different hives have become indistinguishable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ant_colony#Supercolonies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ant_colony#Supercolonies
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoNeat. Ants really are one of the most interesting species. (Or, if not species, whatever the appropriate taxonomical term is.)
- ioddly 9y agoIIRC some of those animals that can reproduce asexually don't necessarily do it exclusively (sharks).
- baybal2 9y ago>What helped these species to be so resilient to a devastating infection when other animals that reproduce sexually (Central American frogs, North American bats) are being wiped away so badly by fungal infections? At least some plants have genes that randomise genetic code if I recall my high school biology well. I also read that polyploid plants have something to randomly shuffle chromosome sets. Quite alike a stack randomisation it is
- Brockenstein 9y ago>What helped these species to be so resilient to a devastating infection when other animals Well for starters asexual reproduction is an option for them, not the sole means of reproduction. Secondly, diseases and catastrophes strike all sorts of critters and sometimes no amount of genetic variation will save them. For example you mention snakes and their resilience: http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-42428528 http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-42428528 Thirdly, snakes, lizards, sharks, make up a huge number of species and genetic variability with global distribution. That provides some protection. And for most of history global pandemics were probably less common or were slow enough that it didn't happen at once everywhere. And if enough individuals survive for the species to recover, then that's that. Fourth, sexual reproduction isn't a guarantee of immunity to disease, it's a survival strategy to help increase the odds of surviving as a species or having individuals with immunity because of all the possible combinations of genes being tried. For example, AIDS (without treatment) is lethal for most of the human population. But there are a few Scandinavian groups that have partial or full immunity, something like less than 1% of the total human population. That's what sexual reproduction gets us as a species.
- gboudrias 9y agoThis is absolutely mind-blowing. Also, since humans are now very numerous and so good at surviving, makes you wonder if humans could mutate this way too. Makes it seem like you'd just get outright pregnant instead of ovulating, which may be a bummer.
- dmix 9y agoThe article ends by explaining why asexual cloning is a bad idea in the long term and how few species exist like this, outside of some relatively new ones, because they lack the evolutionary benefit of sexual adaptation (such as fighting diseases and other evolutionary traits). I guess technology and modern medicine could counteract that but it's still not ideal in the long-term. Nor would genetic clones create a very interesting society.
- sohkamyung 9y ago> Nor would genetic clones create a very interesting society. One of the more interesting attempts at creating a human society made up of clones is the James Tiptree, Jr. story, "Houston, Houston, Do You Read?" [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houston%2C_Houston%2C_Do_You_Read%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houston%2C_Houston%2C_Do_You_R...
- RepressedEmu 9y agoTheres also an Outer Limits episode of a guy trapped on another planet who self replicates clones of himself. Although I think it does it more through "splitting" than an actual birth cycle. Very freaky episode with lots of "body-horror" as he begins to split.
- burfog 9y agoIt would make a very interesting society. Mass-produced clothing would fit well. Public schools would not need to worry much about the extremes of ability. Shared mental traits would encourage a high level of trust, but identification difficulty would undermine it. With everybody having the same innate ability and interests, the pay differences between different jobs would be much higher.
- jimmywanger 9y agoOne way to get rid of this problem is if they taste good, market them to Asian restaurants. Right now spicy crawfish boils are fashionable in China, and I'm pretty sure the other East/Southeast Asian countries like crawfish also. Just like with jellyfish. Chinese people already eat jellyfish, so if there's an infestation of jellyfish in the ocean, figure out a way to eat that species. A billion people can really put a dent in any wild population.
- rcpt 9y agoYou're getting downvotes but it's a completely reasonable effort, cf blackened snakehead and lionfish.
- ams6110 9y agoNot just Asian. Crayfish are popular in Cajun and other Southern cooking.
- jimmywanger 9y agoSure. But I'm pretty sure that there are more Asian people than Cajun/Southern people, and if you want to create a large market, it makes sense to focus on the really big markets.
- flukus 9y agoWhy just asian restaurants? They're basically fresh water lobsters, you should be able to market them anywhere that serves lobster/prawn/shrimp.
- jimmywanger 9y agoWell, you'd do a general marketing push, but Asian markets are a fairly narrow target market, some of them specialize in spicy crayfish boils, so it seems easier since the supplier and the demand are both there and you'd get more bang for your marketing buck. But if you could pick up 150 crawfish in an hour with just your hands, think of what a lighted trap could do overnight.
- 9y ago
- Triesault 9y agoThe explanation is found halfway through the article. > Normal sex cells contain a single copy of each chromosome. But the mutant crayfish sex cell had two. > Somehow the two sex cells fused and produced a female crayfish embryo with three copies of each chromosome instead of the normal two. Somehow, too, the new crayfish didn’t suffer any deformities as a result of all that extra DNA. > It grew and thrived. But instead of reproducing sexually, the first marbled crayfish was able to induce her own eggs to start dividing into embryos. The offspring, all females, inherited identical copies of her three sets of chromosomes. They were clones. > Now that their chromosomes were mismatched with those of slough crayfish, they could no longer produce viable offspring. Male slough crayfish will readily mate with the marbled crayfish, but they never father any of the offspring.
- im3w1l 9y agoCould it somehow mutate again in a way that makes it able to reproduce sexually?
- tzakrajs 9y agoGood idea, I was thinking it would be interesting if the species could turn asexuality on and off as conditions required.
- okket 9y agoIt's «Marmorkrebs» not »Marmokrebs». From Marmor -> Marble. Also, a simple Google/Wikipedia search should have been possible, dear NYT :( https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marmorkrebs https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marmorkrebs
- emmelaich 9y agoThe mistake might have come from this 2010 Scientific American article which uses the wrong spelling in the title. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/the-decade-the-clones-came-beware-the-mighty-marmokrebs/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/the-decade-t...
- sohkamyung 9y agoI've sent a tweet to the author and NYTimes about this. Hopefully they'll correct it.
- ComodoHacker 9y agoThey did.
- fulafel 9y agoIs "mutant" here used to invoke comic book imagery, or is there some meaning in science writing to "mutant species"?
- xbmcuser 9y agoMutant is a scientific term taken over by comics it means something changed in the gene that made it different from others. Mutants are actually quite common in the animal kingdom but usually die out as they can rarely reproduce if they reproduce they become a seperate and unique species the difference with this crayfish is that it is reproducing on its own. We are all descendents of mutants that seperated into homospaiens.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- iskander 9y ago>Mutants are actually quite common in the animal kingdom but usually die out Naw, every person is likely to carry at least one de novo mutation in their genome. Mutations happen constantly, they're just usually unremarkable.
- fulafel 9y agoHence the pondering about the meaning of "mutant species".
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoYes, "mutant" and "mutation" are legitimate terms in genetics, and they apply here.
- singularity2001 9y agoMistranslation: "German Cancer Research Center" should be "German Crabs Research Center"?
- MandieD 9y ago"Cancer" is the right English translation in this case - the German original is "Deutsches Krebsforschungszentrum". A center dedicated to studying crustaeceans would probably be called "Krebstiereforschungszentrum" ("Crab-animals" research center). "Krebs" means either cancer (the diseases) or crabs (the animals). The tumors that early physicians saw reminded them of crabs, so that's what they called them. English forked cancer (Latin word for crabs) to mean the diseases and uses the evolved colloquial word for the animals, but German uses its evolved colloquial word for both. "Krebstiere" is often used to refer to crabs as a group, probably to avoid misunderstandings. Prof. Dr. Lyko seems to primarily study epigenetics, and it's just coincidence that the animals he's studied here are crabs: http://www.dkfz.de/en/epigenetik/ http://www.dkfz.de/en/epigenetik/
- usrusr 9y agoJust glanced over a german language interview, it's basically the introductory question, "sounds like a bad joke, please explain". Actual cancer researchers, looking for a cloning species to observe environmental influence on gene expression (which seems to be a candidate cause for some kinds of cancer or so). So they basically did it for confirming the availability very big, naturally occurring twin experiment. http://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/natur/genetik-forscher-sequenzieren-flusskrebs-der-sich-wie-krebs-vermehrt-a-1191524.html http://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/natur/genetik-forscher-se...
- chriskanan 9y agoSupposedly they taste good and part of their spread is intentional. See the bottom of this article: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-01624-y?utm_source=fbk_nnc&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=naturenews&sf181403583=1 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-01624-y?utm_sourc...
- dr_zoidberg 9y agoI was thinking about a culinary solution to this problem. They could even be farmed, considering their numerous offspring.
- tritium 9y agoSeems like an ideal protein source for space travel. Even if the genomic monoculture represents a serious starvation hazard.
- m3kw9 9y agoVery well written article to capture your attention on a subject that isn’t really unique