3 ms·
The parent never said that companies are scared of auditors, merely that companies have developed processes that auditors have signed off on, and they become sc
by kelnos 9y ago
The parent never said that companies are scared of auditors, merely that companies have developed processes that auditors have signed off on, and they become scared (I guess a better term might be "resistant") to change those processes because it's time and effort (aka money) to get those new processes approved (which might require some back and forth and iteration). This is absolutely true, and I don't find anything in the parent's post that's inconsistent with that.
From what I've heard from people at my company who deal with auditors, there's no fear or antagonistic relationship; both sides want a positive outcome (which shouldn't be surprising at all). But the cost of the audits and the cost to develop compliant process is real, and I wouldn't blame a private company for eschewing public markets to avoid having to deal with that, especially if they have enough access to private capital.
- exelius 9y agoA more realistic framing would be to say that the auditors having accepted something gives a middle manager an excuse to not have to do something when you ask. But here’s the thing; any company over a certain size is going to have internal compliance. Because that’s just good business; you want to know if money is walking out the back door. Parent companies are still going to audit their subordinates; they don’t want the risk. Banks audit private companies before giving them loans. Investment bankers and private equity do the same. These auditors publish standards. So good internal controls processes will still be necessary, just for different reasons. If you want access to funding and resources, you had better be compliant.
- pfarnsworth 9y ago> You literally can ask, why in the world do we do crazy procedures X/Y/Z? Because the auditors accepted it and we are too scared to change it. I interpret it as the parent saying that they're afraid of making changes because they're afraid that the auditors won't sign off on it. "Scared" is a funny word to use when they could have called it a "pain in the ass", etc.
- Retra 9y agoFear of pain, hassle, loss, or discomfort is still fear. "Scared" is a perfectly acceptable word to use when someone decides not to do something they should do because they don't want to take a risk.
- mamon 9y ago>> both sides want a positive outcome (which shouldn't be surprising at all) Well, it is suprising to me. In my country, when there is some audit by government agency, be it tax office, or stock market regulators the usual approach is that auditors won't rest until they find something against the company, some reason to fine it. I think that auditors simply consider their time wasted if their come back to their office empty handed (i.e. without fining the audited company). There are many cases where tax office made a company go bankrupt by first charging it with some crime, then blocking its accounts, then fining it. After few years of lawsuits company wins, court finds them innocent and orders refund of all the fines, but by the time this happens it is already too late: company is long bankrupt. So I think you are lucky to live in a country where auditors are this friendly :)
- sah2ed 9y agoI think the parent is talking about periodic internal audits i.e. conducted routinely but you are referring to forensic audits which are conducted occassionally when there is suspicion of wrongdoing (e.g. manipulated tax returns, inflated contracts etc).