3 ms·
Yeah if I ever went to a non public “paid in stock” I would pay a lawyer to ensure my contract let me cash out whenever I wanted, and couldn’t be diluted, and d
by olliej 9y ago
Yeah if I ever went to a non public “paid in stock” I would pay a lawyer to ensure my contract let me cash out whenever I wanted, and couldn’t be diluted, and didn’t have lower payout priority.
- kelnos 9y agoI doubt any company would accept those terms. Unfortunately the power dynamic is on their side during these sorts of negotiations. Even if you're amazing in your field, special terms like that wouldn't fly.
- olliej 9y agoI'll happily take payment in cash if you don't think that I'm worth paying in actual stock with actual value. If you're paying in stock with the argument that I'm buying into the company, then I should be able to realize that income. If you're paying in stock without actually saying I can cash out that stock why would I accept being underpaid. If you are an engineer that takes a salary+stock comp where the company gets to choose the value of "stock" -- is it salable, is it zero-value until we've repaid our creditors is being foolish. If a company is not willing to guarantee your ability to cash out they are /explicitly/ stating that the stock part of your salary is worth zero. If that's their claim I would expect a salary >200k to compensate.
- kelnos 9y agoFor better or worse, your expectations do not match reality in some (many?) cases. I'm sympathetic to the idea that many early employees get screwed over by promises of riches through equity, but the solution to that is education. Sometimes these big bets pay off; most of the time they do not. If you're unwilling to place one of those bets, that's fine: there are plenty of more mature (or better capitalized) companies that you can choose to work for instead. Some people are willing to make that bet, or have at least decided that the work is interesting enough to take a lower salary. You're free to look down on them for their decision, but I suppose that says more about you than about them.
- seattle_spring 9y agoAre you C-level? Otherwise, those terms would be laughed out of the room.
- olliej 9y agoI'll happily take an actual competitive salary instead of stock if you're not willing to grant me an ability to sell or exchange stock.
- jacquesm 9y agoYour lawyer can write that contract but the other side needs to sign it. And unless you are a resident magician somewhere I really don't see how you would get that done, I have never seen a company agree to terms that would begin to approach that. Even management and early investors regularly get diluted and if they don't want to dilute in later rounds they have to pay up. As for the 'payout priority' (you probably mean 'liquidation preferences'): later investors tend to have a pretty powerful hand to play when it comes to establishing their priority: if they don't get their liquidation priority over and above the bulk of those already in the company they simply won't do the deal. And your 0.01% of the stock certainly isn't going to be allowed to block future rounds. So I really don't see any of this happening in a realistic setting.
- olliej 9y agoYou mistake what I'm saying -- I'm not saying "my lawyer writes the contract" I'm saying that for a non-public startup I would want to have a lawyer ensure that my contract allowed me to exercise the stock grants the company claims to be offering. I am following that with the simple "if they aren't willing to sign such a contract, neither am I". I have no expectation of forcing a company into a contract they disagree with, I'm saying that if I sign a contract with such a startup it's going to give me a reasonably predictable income. That means either a real and competitive salary, or an ability to exercise the "stock compensation". I'm not going to subsidize someone else.
- jacquesm 9y agoWell, then you won't be working for any startups unless it is as a founder, and then that particular startup will have a hard time finding funding.