3 ms·
> Think about the other things our kids could spend time > doing instead of learning "i before e except after c or > sounding like 'A', as in neighbor or we
by wahern 9y ago
> Think about the other things our kids could spend time
> doing instead of learning "i before e except after c or
> sounding like 'A', as in neighbor or weigh, except for ...
> oh, just go ahead and memorize this list."
Children in China and Japan spend a tremendous amount of time simply learning basic orthography, such that literacy is delayed by several years relative to Western students. But does it really effect outcomes? AFAIU, neither does delaying the start of formal eduction in developed countries like Germany and Switzerland, despite theoretically losing 1 or 2 entire years of formal instruction.
Maybe these things matter at the margins, but for the most part it seems that all that matters is keeping kids engaged in the process of knowledge assimilation, regardless of form or substance.
The problem of getting kids to _enjoy_ and _appreciate_ this process... I don't think that's possible. The whinging seems inevitable even when kids are given choice of materials (but notably no choice to opt-out or to focus on something to the complete exclusion of everything else) and only gets worse with age, long into adulthood and then some.
- eesmith 9y agoI don't have a direct way to answer your question. I do know that whenever discussion about, say, "we need to teach programming/algorithmic thinking at school" comes up, one of the responses is "what do we cut?" Right now in the US there is a push to focus on those things which are testable on state-wide standardized tests. As a result, schools are cutting back on other topics, and on recess. I would rather have a more regular language, less time spent on spelling lessons, and more time spent on recess and the arts. Spelling lessons do not (in my opinion) keep "kids engaged in the process of knowledge assimilation." I remember taking home spelling lists of words to memorize, and being tested on it. We had spelling bees, which I think best encourages those who don't need encouragement. In languages with a more regular spelling, such tasks are less important. It's obviously hard to conduct this sort of experiment, but I don't think it's hard to see where a more regular spelling would (in principle) help. As for Chinese, the literacy rate in China was low, in part because of the written form. China carried out language reforms as part of an effort to improve literacy (which in turn was part of a ideological movement towards social equality.) This, I think, supports the hypothesis that there are negatives in having a more complex written form.