4 ms·
Why is there this underlying theme that Careers are more important than Children? They are not. The measure of your life is not how much money you made, it's
by ars 9y ago
Why is there this underlying theme that Careers are more important than Children?
They are not.
The measure of your life is not how much money you made, it's how many people love you, and actually care that you are alive.
Someone with lots of money how dies alone and unmourned, is not better off than someone with less money, who is surrounded by his descendants.
- shultays 9y agoHaving a children does not automaticly make you a more likable person. Two is not related at all
- Mikeb85 9y ago> Why is there this underlying theme that Careers are more important than Children? Because, to a corporation and society's ruling class, all that matters is having productive workers. Having a life gets in the way of that.
- collyw 9y agoI think thats for each individual to decide for themselves. My career is more important to me than children, because I don't particularly want to raise a child and am not intending to have any. Plus I think there are already too many people on the planet. Doesn't mean I can't love others around me.
- lerchmo 9y agoThe question of purpose is alot more nuanced than that. biologically it is hard to argue that reproduction is a significant part.
- mempko 9y agoLet's also consider that most jobs are bullshit jobs anyway. The children are literally the future of humanity and taking care of them is more important than anything else.
- collyw 9y agoWith the population levels at present not having kids seems like a good choice.
- svantana 9y agoNowhere was that implied, I'm pretty sure most people agree that both are important, no need to create a false dichotomy. You're argument is reminiscent of some who opposed the suffragettes, who argued that raising children is much more important than voting. Even if that's the case, that is no argument for injustice.
- desmonds22 9y agoGet with the program - a woman is enslaved and subjugated to her husband if she is raising children in any way. True freedom is being single, childless and working 60 hour weeks at work (edit: likely for a man)
- simsla 9y agoTo each his own. I'm not a very family oriented person. I really enjoy solving problems, learning, etc. The measure of your life is following your dreams / passion. For some, that's interpersonal relationships. For others, it may be work.
- cryptonector 9y agoThe measure of life is happiness. For many this involves parenting (probably, one imagines, biology drives this, no?). Some people will choose to be stay-at-home parents. There is nothing wrong with that. That is a career. The household income... is the household income, not the wage earner's, because for a couple with children the family is their life project, and the stay-at-home parent's "service" is "paid for" by the wage earner. If we really want to compare apples to apples then we have to allocate a fraction (say, half) of the wage earner's income to the stay-at-home parent for the purpose of analysis. Alternatively compare singles' income to singles and childless couples' individuals, and separately analyze married-with-children-and-both-working couples, and then separately analyze married-with-children-and-one-stay-at-home-parent couples.
- v3rt 9y agoPeople take stock of their lives in many different ways: using happiness as the unit of measurement is called hedonism. Pursuing hedonism is a defensible position to take but I'm alarmed by its rise as the default system of value in the educated/cosmopolitan world that most HN readers presumably inhabit. Things like raising children well, championing unfashionable but important positions, fighting injustice and poverty - the really worthwhile things in life - are often extraordinarily difficult and can cause more despair than pleasure. But I choose to believe that they are nonetheless important, and not only because there is the promise of the glow of contentment in the case of a possible future triumph. Many in the tech industry achieve extraordinary success in modern society. But when someone rises to that position, the single-minded pursuit of stimulating one's own reward circuits can look quite callous in the eyes of those who haven't been able to rise to wealth and power. In the days of the hereditary aristocracy, there existed the idea of "noblesse oblige", or the obligation of the upper classes to be a positive force for all those who lived in their society. It might do us some good to revive that idea.
- cryptonector 9y agoAre you saying one cannot take pleasure in / derive happiness from things like raising children well??
- samhain 9y agoPersonally, I think that having children is immoral. Yes, it can provide you with little workers to help you on the farm, and provide care and love for you in old age, but what if the child is born with a severe disability and is guaranteed to live a life of suffering? Not only will you experience some pain through their suffering, but you are literally wholly responsible for their life, which they had no consent in giving for their own birth. A happiness that is never experienced by an unborn child is neutral, while the suffering of a born child is negative. What is your opinion for how much a child can suffer before they should not have been born? How much happiness? For most lives there is a tradeoff between the two, so what is the tipping point where they should not have been born? Is it the point of suicide where not only do they not consent to being born, but the no longer consent to being alive?
- bassman9000 9y agoErgo, your existence is immoral.