3 ms·
"the Bank of France maintains files which are only available to financial institutions holding a licence delivered by the Bank of France. The files only relate
by astura 9y ago
"the Bank of France maintains files which are only available to financial institutions holding a licence delivered by the Bank of France. The files only relate to a person if they have written bad checks, have participated in fraudulent activities, have been declared bankrupt or have bounced checks in France."
So the bank of France is a centralized credit bureau. So going by that, it's actually much more similar than different from the US system. The US system adds proprietary algorithms designed by actuaries to that rather than, or in addition to, manually underwriting. But it's not all that different other than being for profit.
We have many private companies act as data brokers here in the US, as opposed to a single central bank or government agency, because Americans hate government and love private businesses. The US is like "the government can't do anything, let private companies handle it and make money off it and the free market solves everything." We seem to be just learning that the free market can have problems too...
Designing a centralized government run system is a non-starter in the US. Even now.
- dozzie 9y ago> So the bank of France partly is a centralized credit bureau. So going by that, it's actually more similar than different. Only by what data they gather, and this stems from what the data is needed for. There is vast difference in purpose, though: the Bank of France is (a) a public institution that (b) does not earn money solely by selling every personal data they could put hands on to just about anybody. The incentives are totally different from Equifax'. Note also that the data collected is not even remotely about everybody, as with Equifax.
- astura 9y agoMy point is 1) banks need this information for underwriting 2) the US doesn't have and won't ever have a centralized government/public database that contains this information So 3) the private market takes over and compiles that information for profit
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThe Equifax problem was poor data handling plus a lack of government interested in punishing them for it. Neither of those problems would be avoided if Equifax was a government agency.
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoWhile I'm inclined to agree that it would be better to have the government run it, you seem to be suggesting that this would be an, uh, ironclad silver bullet, as it were. Doing so wouldn't guarantee either good security or general system effectiveness.