3 ms·
Interestingly, the divergence between spelling and pronunciation of English words is frequently mentioned as a special difficulty for speakers of languages that
by yorwba 9y ago
Interestingly, the divergence between spelling and pronunciation of English words is frequently mentioned as a special difficulty for speakers of languages that are written phonetically, but it seems like this would be a problem for everyone. Probably, those who are already used to non-phonetic scripts don't expect English to be any easier and therefore that particular point isn't as salient.
It would also be interesting to have a comparison in the opposite direction: things that English speakers frequently struggle with when learning the respective language.
- gumby 9y agoInterestingly, the divergence between spelling and pronunciation of English words if frequently mentioned as a special difficulty for speakers of languages that are written phonetically, but it seems like this would be a problem for everyone. I am glad that English doesn't try to accomplish this (French is even more extreme in this regard). In English words are roughly spelled in terms of their root meaning, which makes it easier for a native speaker to figure out the meaning of an unfamiliar word. In fact the fashion for "phonics" (trying to learn English starting with phonetic structures) has screwed up reading and spelling for two generations of American kids. A phonetic approach has a couple of problems. The first is the choice of whose phonemes to use. Any language with many speakers will have several dialects, so one single dialect must be chosen as authoritative. The second is that pronunciation inherently shifts over time so you must continually tinker with spelling or end up with a written language full of head-scratchers (it's no surprise that spelling bees have been prime time TV fodder in France). German is a good example: offical spelling and grammar corresponds with Hochdeutch (which is not used at home by a majority of people, though perhaps recently a plurality?) and which was offically adjusted twice in the 20th century alone to account for pronunciation shifts. I don't know Korean but with 80 million speakers I'd think that it suffers from the same issues, although perhaps hangul's structure manages to exert a conservative force on pronunciation.
- yorwba 9y ago> In English words are roughly spelled in terms of their root meaning, which makes it easier for a native speaker to figure out the meaning of an unfamiliar word. I was under the impression that words are spelled according to their etymology, which only rarely helps with the meaning of unfamiliar words. > German is a good example: offical spelling and grammar corresponds with Hochdeutch (which is not used at home by a majority of people, though perhaps recently a plurality?) and which was offically adjusted twice in the 20th century alone to account for pronunciation shifts. I learned Hochdeutsch at home and can't even do a credible impression of the local dialect, but I admit that the experience of others may differ. However, I'm quite sure that the German spelling reforms are not related to shifts in pronunciation, rather they were attempts to simplify the rule system.
- eesmith 9y agoAnd fake etymology. "Island" is spelled with an 's' because people in the 1400s thought it was a cognate with 'isle' so changed the spelling from 'iland'. More at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_reform#16th_and_17th_centuries_AD https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_refo... : > From the 16th century AD onward, English writers who were scholars of Greek and Latin literature tried to link English words to their Graeco-Latin counterparts. They did this by adding silent letters to make the real or imagined links more obvious. Thus det became debt (to link it to Latin debitum), dout became doubt (to link it to Latin dubitare), sissors became scissors and sithe became scythe (as they were wrongly thought to come from Latin scindere), iland became island (as it was wrongly thought to come from Latin insula), ake became ache (as it was wrongly thought to come from Greek akhos), and so forth.[
- wahern 9y ago> I am glad that English doesn't try to accomplish this AFAIU, English was phonetic, more or less. When English spelling was first formalized it closely reflected the pronunciation of Middle English. Events like the Great Vowel Shift systematically divorced the pronunciation of many syllables from their original spelling. British and American attempts to reform the spelling in response complicated things further. The spelling of diphthongs in English make much more sense after reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift The process continues. See, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Cities_Vowel_Shift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Cities_Vowel_Shift
- ajuc 9y ago> In English words are roughly spelled in terms of their root meaning, which makes it easier for a native speaker to figure out the meaning of an unfamiliar word. Polish doesn't do this, almost everything is phonetic, and I don't have any problems decoding meaning of borrowed words. We have lots of loan words from Latin, German, French, Italian, and it's usually straightforward, because the polonization of spelling works with simple rules (English does this as well BTW). transposition = transpozycja position = pozycja opposition = opozycja conjugation = koniugacja computer = komputer battery = bateria accumulator = akumulator engineer = inżynier logic = logika mathematics = matematyka algebra = algebra I don't see how English version is any easier. > The second is that pronunciation inherently shifts over time so you must continually tinker with spelling Not really? Last spelling change was before WW2, and it was very minor. Polish texts from renaissance are readably by middle school students with no preparation. Sound a bit archaic, but perfectly understandable. Having smaller country with common media helps I guess.
- yebyen 9y ago> > The second is that pronunciation inherently shifts over time so you must continually tinker with spelling > Not really? Last spelling change was before WW2 I am not an expert but I've taken a class called language variation and identity, and I can tell you at least that this is a generally accepted principle of language evolution, that one of the most common ways that languages change is by shifting pronunciation over long periods of time. There is also always a counter-example to every rule such as this one; this is not a hard science like chemistry or physics where the results will be the same every time, but the general principals are definitely reoccurring all the time in all languages. Consonants that are difficult to say will be "elided," or omitted in colloquial pronunciations, and sometimes this will result in a spelling change. Phonemes will be "assimilated" into the other sounds that they are nearby so that the combinations are easier to say, or easier to distinguish from one another, and sometimes this will also result in a spelling change. Or you can imagine sometimes language might change for no other reason than because a new large migrant population finds a word is confusingly similar to a swear/curse expression from their native language, and it makes them uncomfortable to pronounce it in the native way... or more predictably because the migrant population does not agree on the pronunciation of a vowel, the regional dialect may change over time to favor their native pronunciation. Or other reasons we won't have thought of, but these changes are often gradual and not noticeable by a person within their lifetime. That the last spelling change in Poland was before WW2 does not sound like strong evidence that it does not undergo the same transformations over time. Some languages with stricter phonetic rules about how spelling of words maps directly to pronunciation may shift less. Some changes are harder to detect from written records of the language (especially vowel shifts.) Sometimes a linguistic authority will intervene, with varying degrees of success, to prevent (or instigate) a change. Even in Polish, if you go back far enough you might be surprised: this poster on Stack Exchange[1] seems to be saying that there was a big vowel shift in Polish, but it was more than 400 years ago. [1]: https://english.stackexchange.com/a/127564 https://english.stackexchange.com/a/127564
- eesmith 9y agoI think the Cherokee syllabary gives an idea of what we're missing out on. Quoting from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee_syllabary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee_syllabary : > After the syllabary was completed in the early 1820s, it achieved almost instantaneous popularity and spread rapidly throughout Cherokee society.[17] By 1825, the majority of Cherokees could read and write in their newly developed orthography. ... > .. when Albert Gallatin saw a copy of Sequoyah's syllabary, he believed it was superior to the English alphabet. He recognized that even though the Cherokee student must learn 85 characters instead of 26, the Cherokee could read immediately. The student could accomplish in a few weeks what students of English writing could learn in two years. Think about the other things our kids could spend time doing instead of learning "i before e except after c or sounding like 'A', as in neighbor or weigh, except for ... oh, just go ahead and memorize this list." While I agree that a phonetic approach emphasizes one dialect over others, is it really a serious problem? I mean, Norwegians have two ways to write Norwegian. You mentioned German; in Switzerland, as I understand it, people who speak Swiss German dialect write in standard German. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_dialects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_dialects describes a variety of dialects, with different numbers of vowels and consonants, and including the Yukchin dialect, which it describes as being a tonal variant. I personally think we should have regular (every 50 years or so) language reforms. The pros and cons have long been discussed, and are summarized at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_refo... .
- wahern 9y ago> Think about the other things our kids could spend time > doing instead of learning "i before e except after c or > sounding like 'A', as in neighbor or weigh, except for ... > oh, just go ahead and memorize this list." Children in China and Japan spend a tremendous amount of time simply learning basic orthography, such that literacy is delayed by several years relative to Western students. But does it really effect outcomes? AFAIU, neither does delaying the start of formal eduction in developed countries like Germany and Switzerland, despite theoretically losing 1 or 2 entire years of formal instruction. Maybe these things matter at the margins, but for the most part it seems that all that matters is keeping kids engaged in the process of knowledge assimilation, regardless of form or substance. The problem of getting kids to _enjoy_ and _appreciate_ this process... I don't think that's possible. The whinging seems inevitable even when kids are given choice of materials (but notably no choice to opt-out or to focus on something to the complete exclusion of everything else) and only gets worse with age, long into adulthood and then some.
- ajuc 9y agoIt is very difficult, especially if you first learn from reading/writing. 25 years later and I still unconsciously pronounce some words like they would be pronounced in my language :(