7 ms·
Yup, another father here: I'd love an always-on camera that I can tell to save the last 30 seconds of playback. There are a lot of moments I'd love to have on v
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
Yup, another father here: I'd love an always-on camera that I can tell to save the last 30 seconds of playback. There are a lot of moments I'd love to have on video or camera that are there-and-gone - even if I had my phone in my pocket, by the time I pulled it out, it would be too late.
- nogridbag 9y agoAnd from my short experience even if you manage to pull out your phone or DSLR quickly to capture that special moment, the baby immediately stops cooing/smiling and instead is staring at this black object you're sticking in their face. I think Google's onto something with Google Clips. But I think there's more to this concept. Would definitely be interested in a v2 that is able to capture video.
- tlrobinson 9y agoGoPros (and other action cameras, I assume) have a feature like that. But please don't be "that guy" constantly recording unwilling subjects (except in your own home, of course)
- JustSomeNobody 9y ago> ... unwilling subjects (except in your own home, of course) Not even.
- tlrobinson 9y agoWell, not secretly, but otherwise people are free to leave your home if they find your recording obnoxious.
- maltalex 9y agoWould you love that camera if it was pointed at you? The trade-off between the convenience of having an always-on camera and living in a society in which everyone has an always-on cameras seems like a no-brainer to me. There's even a Black Mirror episode like that - "The Entire History of You".
- naasking 9y ago> Would you love that camera if it was pointed at you? If the camera had a light indicating when it was actually recording, that seems better. There are probably many small changes to make such cameras more acceptable.
- oarsinsync 9y agoGoogle for “activate webcam without light” Ever noticed people have covered their laptop cameras even though they have a light to indicate if it’s on? How do you do that to someone else’s camera that has been remote activated with the light disabled?
- naasking 9y agoYou don't make it software controlled, you hardwire it so it can't be hacked.
- gpm 9y agoThat camera is already pointed at me, via security cameras, strangers cell phones, etc. This just makes the situation symmetric. So yes, I would be fine with that.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoNo all of us live in the UK or some city that has cameras everywhere. Private CCTV footage and most government footage not part of a dragnet collection program is usually discarded after a few weeks or months if it's not needed. Cell phones are not always on. I agree that everything being recorded all the time is somewhat inevitable considering the way things are going. While this does make the situation symmetric to some extent as far as the capacity to record interesting things goes. However, I believe that in the foreseeable future the negatives outweigh the positives. You might be able to get the clerk at the DMV to be nicer if they're on camera but your ability to influence society with the ability to record video doesn't extend much beyond there. Only the incumbents (tech giants and the government) have the ability to store and mine this sort of data for interesting things that are only interesting in retrospect. You do not have access to a big chunk of the data set. Your bank, insurance company and government do. They can mine that data to punish you or others for whatever behavior they deem bad and to extract compliance to their whims. You, neither as a individual nor as part of a group do not have the capacity to do the same analysis, the means to use what you learn to manipulate individuals. Even if you did you don't have access to a large enough chunk of the data set. Until the power to access and draw meaning from this sort of data is in everyone's hands the situation is not symmetric. I hope you and those who agree with you reconsider your opinions.
- keville 9y agoYou have described the exact use case the Google Clips [0] camera seems to have been designed for. [0] https://store.google.com/us/product/google_clips https://store.google.com/us/product/google_clips