3 ms·
"Compositing used to recreate what an observer at the right place and time would see is ok by me." To me part of why I admire a picture is the fact that someon
by maxxxxx 9y ago
"Compositing used to recreate what an observer at the right place and time would see is ok by me."
To me part of why I admire a picture is the fact that someone did the work to get to the right place at the right time. So compositing something that could have happened but the photographer wasn't there when it happened is still disappointing.
- ghaff 9y agoSomeone I know used to be a fairly serious amateur photographer back in the film days. Did a lot of bird photos among other nature-related things. He pretty much got out of the camera club and photo contest scene a number of years back because, once digital scanning and then digital cameras became a widespread thing, most of the winning photos were increasingly "faked" in various ways. This piece in Outside Magazine in 2009 describes the beginning of this sort of things. https://www.outsideonline.com/1825491/photo-lying-you https://www.outsideonline.com/1825491/photo-lying-you
- alistairSH 9y agoTotally agree. I know a few professional photographers and some of their best shots were HARD to get. Days of recon, precise timing, sometimes significant physical exertion, and a healthy dollop of luck. Learning that they had composited those shots would be really disappointing. Learning that some hack was "stealing" their income by compositing hard-to-achieve shots would be maddening.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt's a also a big problem for aspiring photographers. You practice a lot to get as good as the pros only to find out that they are manipulating their images. It's like trying to get really good at a sport and later finding out that the top athletes are all on steroids. It makes you very cynical.
- igouy 9y ago> some of their best shots were HARD to get For some definition of "best" ! Pictures succeed or fail on their own merit, not on how much work was needed. otoh House painting we value by how much work was needed.
- igouy 9y ago> Days of recon, precise timing, sometimes significant physical exertion, and a healthy dollop of luck. How disappointing it must be to learn that so many of those widely admired Ansel Adams' photos were taken from the road side, standing on his car roof. > "stealing" Now you're just name-calling.
- alistairSH 9y agoI assume Adams still did some amount of recon. Driving around, sees something he likes, comes back when the lighting is better. Two of the pros I know shoot professional cycling. Lots of time on the back of a motorcycle to get action shots. But some of panoramic shots of the peloton are what takes more work/planning. And of course, my own personal biases come in as well. I strongly prefer photos that are on the "journalism" end of the spectrum vs pure art, if that makes any sense.
- igouy 9y agoBy all means "strongly prefer" and resist the temptation to insist those personal preferences are truths.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAdams was also an avid hiker and spent a lot of time in the mountains.
- igouy 9y agoWhat would be relevant, is if you could show something to suggest that Ansel Adams considered his best photographs to be those that had required the most "physical exertion": those that were "HARD to get". Meanwhile: "Looking at Ansel Adams: The Photographs and the Man" https://books.google.com/books?id=SsGMtgAACAAJ&dq=isbn:0316217808&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiss7zq-JbZAhWBLmMKHZ6OALgQ6AEIJzAA https://books.google.com/books?id=SsGMtgAACAAJ&dq=isbn:03162... http://anseladams.com/looking-at-ansel-adams-the-photographs-and-the-man/ http://anseladams.com/looking-at-ansel-adams-the-photographs...