12 ms·
> But those "frequent professional audits" have been slow in coming. The accounting firm Friedman LLP had been working on an audit of Tether and Bitfinex—a cryp
by koolba 9y ago
> But those "frequent professional audits" have been slow in coming. The accounting firm Friedman LLP had been working on an audit of Tether and Bitfinex—a cryptocurrency exchange that is closely linked to Tether—since May. But last Saturday, Tether admitted to Coindesk that its relationship with Friedman had "dissolved."
In the normal business world it's a very bad sign when your auditor fires you as a customer.
> So it's possible Tether is keeping the identity of its bank secret to avoid attracting scrutiny from local regulators. This could also explain why some of Tether's funds are being held in the personal account of a Tether associate—perhaps the bank would have refused to open the account if it had known it was really for Tether.
When this finally blows up it's going to blow up big. How pervasive is parking money in tether in the crypto world? Is it bitfinex specific? I'm curious how bad the shock waves will be across the industry.
- sharemywin 9y agoI used it on bitterex.com
- csorrell 9y agoA number of exchanges have USDT pairings. https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/#markets https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/#markets
- tehlike 9y agoIt is not just parking money. When yoy find that the price of the asset you own has propped up price panic ensues.
- random_rr 9y agoI mean... are people worried about Dogecoin blowing up? Or any other coin? There is basically no problem here. If you don't believe in USDT... don't buy it. It's like saying government-issued currencies are going to "blow up" because Zimbabwe keeps printing fat stacks. Don't hold Zimbabwe dollars - problem solved! Traders want something like USDT for the utility it provides. I don't think most traders care about the backing of USDT or it's potential redeemability for USD. I think most people enjoy the utility of a token that is always ~1USD. There are other tokens that promise to bring the same utility to crypto (DAI, etc). If USDT disappears (as NZDT just did, RIP Cryptopia's bank accounts), another stable coin will fill the void. So even if Tether explodes, and it's actually been running with 0 financial backing this whole time - uh, well, tell me how that's different from any other cryptocurrency that has exploded and imploded in the last few years? It would seem to me that the healthiest thing for crypto right now is to figure out Tether's financial health (so people can decide if they want to safely use it) - but I don't think the marketplace will feel any "shockwaves" from a possible collapse.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I mean... are people worried about Dogecoin blowing up? Dogecoin isn't used by exchanges as a vehicle to allow dollar-pegged ated trading without handling actual dollars, and Doge:BTC prices aren't treated by cryptocurrency price trackers as if they were, at some fixed multiple, USD:BTC prices. USDT and Doge don't play a similar role in the ecosystem.
- random_rr 9y agoThat's interesting, my Cryptopia DOGE trading pairs (and LTC) beg to differ. Will there be a crisis of confidence if Doge crashes to 0 on Cryptopia? Of course not. USDT is one of many trading pairs offered by crypto exchanges. It matters no more or less than NZDT, Dogecoin, Litecoin, Bitcoin, Ethereum, or any other common trading pair in the crypto world.
- Grangar 9y agoYes it does, because USDT is (supposedly) inherently pegged to the dollar. It's used as a vehicle for stability when normal banking is not available. See: binance, liqui.io. These exchanges don't have fiat deposits/withdrawals. BTC is meanwhile taking all alts down with it.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> That's interesting, my Cryptopia DOGE trading pairs (and LTC) beg to differ. How? > USDT is one of many trading pairs offered by crypto exchanges. USDT is not a trading pair, it's a single cryptocurrency. The issues that give it a special role, both tied to it's USD peg, is that: (1) It is sometimes treated as equivalent to, and commingled with, USD by exchanges (notably, Bitfinex), and (2) USDT:<X> trading pairs, on exchanges that don't handle USD lat all, are often treated by the community as if they were USD:<X> trading pairs. (3) The special role USD has in world markets.
- hluska 9y agoThere is basically no problem here?? There is an organization that claims its security is backed by an equivalent number of American dollars (thus promising relatively stable liquidity). Yet, this organization can't get through an audit and it's looking rather unlikely that that security is actually backed by anything more than website copy. And there is basically no problem here? Tether has a special place in the cryptocurrency ecosystem that makes it completely unlike Dogecoin. This special place means that the types of sketchy things that Tether is doing could ripple through the entire ecosystem.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoTether is in the top 20 in cryptocurrencies by Market cap. What generally happens when an altcoin goes bust is that people try to cash out (buy bitcoin with tether and then sell bitcoin or HOLD). Also, miners will stop mining tether and will move to other cryptocoins. I think it will have a large measurable affect but we shall see.
- simias 9y agoWhat surprises me most is that despite all these red flags USDT still holds its peg mostly well. Right now it trades less than a cent below the dollar on kraken for instance. It seems like cryptocurrency traders are paradoxically pretty trusting.
- conanbatt 9y agoI think bitfinex is holding the peg on where you can see it (kraken). Nobody else can buy /sell tether. Even a guy saying tether probably has the money on twitter was only willing to buy at 45% premium. Now, bitfinex looks super solvent though, so its not like the exchange can dissolve like mtgox.
- DennisP 9y agoHow is Bitfinex involved with Kraken?
- simias 9y agoI think the idea is that Bitfinex might have enough money to prop USDT up as long as the trading volume is low enough. Just buy on kraken when the peg starts to break. Similarly they can probably afford to actually exchange the USDT for USD up to a certain limit, the question is how deep their pockets are. Do they actually have the full amount in their accounts? $1 billion? 100 millions? 10 millions? We'll know that for sure when there's an actual audit or when there's a bank run and they collapse because they don't have the money to pay for the USDTs.
- tim333 9y agoI don't think Bitfinex is directly involved with Kraken. Bitfinex is a shady offshore operation [1] and Kraken is a fully US regulated company with their main office in SF. Kraken is however about the only place you can actually trade USDT for real USD. Or indeed short the things. [1] >[people] have attempted to visit the company’s registered address in Hong Kong only to find an accounting company which served as a registration agent for the company >most of the executive team is distributed across the globe.https://medium.com/@cadammitchell/bitfinex-has-a-true-working-office-in-taiwan-a7ab8c55f7c5 https://medium.com/@cadammitchell/bitfinex-has-a-true-workin...
- stult 9y agoI think you're right that this is a mess, my only uncertainty is whether it's garden variety incompetence or active bad faith. For an auditor to fire you, either you have to not be paying your bills for a long time or you have to be deeply uncooperative or insanely demanding. That said, the consensus I've heard from my audit colleagues (I work in public accounting) is that no one has the slightest freaking clue how to audit crypto. So I could see the audit taking exceptionally long, causing friction in the relationship which eventually blew up into a full on breakdown. If that's the case, Tether's leadership probably had a poor understanding of the complexities involved. Sometimes that's the client's fault, but sometimes it's the accounting firm making too aggressive of a pitch to sell the work. But the bank account issue makes me think bad faith. That shows a willingness to disregard rules and mislead fiduciary business partners, which is pretty much an auditor's nightmare client.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> no one has the slightest freaking clue how to audit crypto This is a fair statement. Auditor resignations are a red flag, not a conviction. Given the background scumminess of the cryptocurrency space [1], Bitfinex/Tether's management's evasiveness and structure's murkiness [2] and the $2 billion with a "b" figure, heightened skepticism is warranted. In that light, the Tether spokesperson blaming the "excruciatingly detailed procedures Friedman was undertaking" for the auditor's resignation, with no corroborating statement from the auditor, is unsettling. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ico-ernst-young/more-than-10-percent-of-3-7-billion-raised-in-icos-has-been-stolen-ernst-young-idUSKBN1FB1MZ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ico-ernst-young/more-than... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-05/mystery-shrouds-tether-and-its-links-to-biggest-bitcoin-exchange https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-05/mystery-s...
- gst 9y ago> That said, the consensus I've heard from my audit colleagues (I work in public accounting) is that no one has the slightest freaking clue how to audit crypto. Shouldn't the crypto part be trivial for Tether? You'd just need to check how many Tethers were issued on the blockchain. The hard part ensuring that those Tethers are backed by real Dollars - and that should be a regular accounting task that doesn't have anything to do with crypto.
- panarky 9y ago> So it's possible Tether is keeping the identity of its bank secret to avoid attracting scrutiny from local regulators The whole purpose of Tether is to trade USD after Bitfinex lost USD banking relationships. No naturally, if banking relationships were public, they would be at risk. More likely, these aren't traditional bank accounts at all. These are probably dollars pledged by corporations and hedge funds but held in bank accounts of those corporations and hedge funds, not in Bitfinex's name.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The whole purpose of Tether is to trade USD after Bitfinex lost USD banking relationships This is willful money laundering. If true, everyone who ever beneficially owned USDT would be subject to federal money laundering charges. AML law doesn't care about intent or knowledge, just actions. > if banking relationships were public, they would be at risk Any bank which holds electronic U.S. dollars reports, directly or indirectly, to American regulators. Large deposits owned by foreign institutions with possible connections to Americans trigger FATCA filings. American financial regulators are somewhat forgiving when it comes to mistakes; less so when those "mistakes" are willful. If a bank is hiding its direct or indirect relationship to Bitfinex, they are betting the bank on Bitfinex. At that point, laundering drug money is probably a better reward for the risk being taken. (Disclaimer: None of this is legal advice. Do not launder money.) > These are probably dollars pledged by corporations and hedge funds but held in bank accounts of those corporations and hedge funds, not in Bitfinex's name This is plausible, trivial to demonstrate (repo and overnight wholesale financing aren't novel concepts), and a different risk model if true (for the lenders as well as Tether). It would also fly in the face of the Tether spokesperson's claim that Tether has a "relatively simple balance sheet."
- panarky 9y agoI'm the last one to defend Tether because it looks as shady as hell, but ... > This is willful money laundering Money laundering is the concealment of the origins of illegally obtained money. If the money was legally obtained then it can't be money laundering. Just creating an alternate way to move clean money isn't prima facie a crime. > If a bank is hiding its direct or indirect relationship to Bitfinex, they are betting the bank on Bitfinex Banks probably don't even know about Bitfinex. If Fuckwit Capital Partners has $100m on deposit with Wells Fargo and pledges 10% of it to buy Ethereum, those dollars stay in FCP's account and the bank has no idea that the funds are pledged. Upon receipt of the promissory note from FCP, 10m new Tethers get created with the Ethereum as collateral. > claim that Tether has a "relatively simple balance sheet." The balance sheet could be very simple, but devilishly difficult to audit. ASSETS Accounts Receivable from Investors, $2.4 billion LIABILITIES Tethers Payable to Traders, $2.4 billion If Friedman LLP wanted to prove all the pledged USD to back up the receivables, that could be an expensive and invasive audit of counterparties who don't want their banks get wind of their cryptocurrency activities.