3 ms·
Most people are actually quite happy to be manipulated. When my newborn cries because he made a poopy diaper, I come running to change it and think it's cute,
by nostrademons 9y ago
Most people are actually quite happy to be manipulated. When my newborn cries because he made a poopy diaper, I come running to change it and think it's cute, because millions of years of evolution have pruned the gene pool of everyone who is indifferent to these cries. When people donate to a political party, they're being manipulated, but they happily view it as civic engagement and people power. When charities send out fundraising solicitations, they're manipulating their donors (sometimes quite blatantly), but people give anyway. When your manager gives you praise for a job well done in lieu of additional financial compensation, he's manipulating you, but most people want the praise anyway.
Questions of good vs. bad manipulation usually center around regret. When your future self looks back at your present, manipulated self, do they regret the interaction? For the door-to-door salesman, the answer is usually yes: best case you're like "I want those 5 minutes of my life back", worst case you're like "I bought something I totally didn't need". For the charitable donation, usually your future self continues to believe "I did a good deed", unless your values change significantly, and so you willingly participate in their manipulation. Advertising (particularly search advertising) is in that grey area where if you end up finding the product useful, the ad performed a vital service, while if you ended up buying something useless, you were manipulated.