8 ms·
Voice UI Is the Future. But When?
- Mononokay 9y agoIt'll happen when the average user stops caring even moreso about privacy, and when an always-recording microphone doesn't drain battery intensively.
- taneq 9y agoAnyone who's tried to explain to another person how to do something on a computer (or what to do with a computer) and eventually, in exasperation, said "here just let me drive", knows that voice UI is not the (only) UI of the future.
- clort 9y agoAs I work with schoolkids, I've found the best way is to direct with long thin stick like a baton. You can keep your hand well out of their vision and indicate where you want the mouse to go. If you drive for them, they will not know what you did. (to be fair, when I point and tell, they don't always know what they did either)
- onion2k 9y agoVoice as a user interface doesn't scale. If you have a lot of people in a small space (an office, a coffeeshop, a metro train, etc) then voice just won't work. From a technical perspective it could work with good direction microphones to isolate the user, and excellent voice recognition to eliminate accidental activations from other people, but the cost of those things would be prohibitive, and it'd still fail if the background noise level was too high. Where voice really fails is the simple fact that a lot of people would have issues dictating a sensitive or intimate message with their voice in public. There will always need to be a second screen- or keyboard-based UI. That doesn't mean voice won't be hugely important, but it does mean it'll never be the whole story. Consequently, I don't see it being 'the future' of UIs.
- singularity2001 9y agoMostly agree, but why would a directional microphone be 'prohibitive'? When it becomes the dominant UI it can be called 'the future', no?
- onion2k 9y agoI don't think it'll ever be the dominant UI. It works brilliantly in some situations (your house, your car) but there are more situations where it doesn't (everywhere else).
- singularity2001 9y agothey work brilliantly in dedicated offices and even in cubicles if there are isolated enough, just like people mumble into their telephone at work and in trains today.
- rowyourboat 9y agoAround here, if somebody is talking into a phone on the train, they get dirty looks. It really is not at all common and pretty awkward. I have never witnessed anybody give a voice command to their phone. At work, we isolate the frequent-phoners from those who have to concentrate for prolonged periods of time. If more poeple start talking at work, the distractions are going to get worse.
- clort 9y agoActually, only those who are talking loudly into a sensitive microphone held right next to their mouth get dirty looks. Plenty of people sit there having a quiet conversation and even from the seat in front or behind you can't hear them speaking
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIndeed, back in my Google Glass days, I could "ok glass" a voice command, but heck if I ever actually wanted to. It's also super awkward in public... and I still look at people strangely today when they "ok google" something or the like. In a home, I do totally get it. If it wasn't for the always listening microphones, I'd be up for it. But even then... I might ask my house to do something, I'm still going to manually want to type this comment.
- baxtr 9y agoThis might be the beginning of the “Trough of Disillusionment” for Voice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle
- zeofig 9y agoYep, it should integrate nicely with virtual reality and driverless cars! Just around the corner...!
- dingo_bat 9y agoMaybe not exactly voice, but natural language UI is definitely the future. It would be awesome if I could talk to git and tell it to do exactly what I want in English. Instead of rote-learning arcane incantations.
- andrewfong 9y agoIt depends on the complexity and dangers of the command. Git actually seems like a very poor candidate for natural language. Consider: Legal documents initially began as natural language evaluated by very effective natural language processors (other people). Over time, as the edge cases and ambiguities built up, the language of law diverged to the point that legalese is hardly considered "natural" today.
- rimliu 9y agoNatural language is very poor for anything requiring precision.
- otabdeveloper1 9y ago> It would be awesome if I could talk to git and tell it to do exactly what I want in English. Considering that even high-IQ native English speakers have huge, huge problems "just doing what you want", even after explicit and unambiguous instructions -- don't hold your breath. (Maybe after the flying moon car.)
- BjoernKW 9y agoI don't think that natural language is a useful interface for tools like Git. Natural language is inherently verbose and ambiguous. That's precisely what you don't want when using tools like that. Natural language has a low signal to noise ratio compared to explicit verbs and keywords. Git just has less than stellar usability when it comes to performing common actions. Most of that probably is intentional because on the other hand it affords you a great deal of flexibility. If you want to improve the usability of Git standard UI patterns like providing better keywords and shortcuts to frequently used features will suffice. It's just a matter of the design philosophy behind the tool.
- CoolestBeans 9y agoI'm less interested in voice assistants and more interested in how speech recognition will interact with existing interfaces. One advantage GUI has over CLIs is the "graphical" component. Graphics can output to the user so much more information in so much less time than text (colloquially "a picture says a thousand words"). Text-to-speech output has the bandwidth problem a CLI has and it isn't persistent. If you didn't hear the voice assistant the first time, you have to make it repeat the entire sentence. What I think is really the killer feature of speech recognition is its role as an input. Anecdotally, I find the only times I use any voice UI is for setting alarms (because iOS's time input makes you scroll thru every minute) and asking a sufficiently long question to Google (because touchscreen keyboards are still imprecise and I've got fat fingers). Even though both Android and iOS have speech recognition built into their keyboards I think there's something someone is missing on the input side.
- kumrr 9y agoCouldn't agree with you more. So much so we actually are building a company to help developer do just that - http://slanglabs.in http://slanglabs.in :) Provide tools to developers to build a voice interface on top of existing mobile apps that in our mind would marry the best of voice (as an input mechanism) with GUI (as an output mechanism).
- otabdeveloper1 9y ago> Voice UI Is the Future. No it isn't.
- pymai 9y agoits the future in the same way that 'smart' watches were the future
- coldtea 9y agoVoice UI without general AI is not the future. Forget about it. Even for long form text entry it's tiresome (ever tried speaking for 1 hour?) -- never mind the noise (e.g. in an office), privacy issues, discoverability of options, and all that.
- ksec 9y agoI guess most people dont work in a Sales Job? Or they have such a decent package that they work 9-5 on the dot in office and get home very early? Because most of my days when I am tired, the last thing i want to do is to open my month.
- ttflee 9y agoBitrate of voice UI is miserable.
- simias 9y agoTFA briefly mentions it but I can't imagine how "Voice UI" can be even decent without strong AI. In order to be more efficient than inputting commands with a keyboard or mouse you want an "assistant" that will be able to infer what you want from context. And of course you want to be reasonably certain that it'll get it right without having to double check everything all the time. Also, make it available offline. I don't want $bigdata to know everything I do on my computer. Amazon Echo & friends are way too orwellian for my taste. I don't know if the general public will care about that however.
- hailk 9y agoWouldn't having a strong AI require lots of user data? And having the option to make it work offline means letting go of all the possible precious tidbits that could make your AI strong.
- simias 9y agoMaybe, but I don't really care to use Big Brother AI. I mean, you and I are pretty clever and yet we don't require an internet connection to function, do we? Maybe it'll take longer to perfect but I hope we'll get there eventually when it comes to artificial intelligence.
- hailk 9y agoCertainly. Internet is just a means to an end, a product is successful if it solves the problem it intends to solve, with or without net. A tangential question. What steps can an organisation take to assuage your worries about your data being mis-used?
- laurieg 9y agoVoice UI has some use cases where it is great and some use cases where it is terrible. "Fire and forget" commands are great. "Hey alexa, set an alarm for 8am". Once you trust alexa to do these tasks you don't need any feedback. But tasks where you need constant feedback are not well suited to voice UI. If you accidentally blast music through your hi-fi asking alexa to "turn it down a bit" 4 times and then "turn it up" finally to get to a nice listening volume takes much much longer than turning a dial while listening to the auditory feedback you get.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoReally. Just like the Gesture UI Tom Cruise used in minority report. If it looks good on TV is usually strainfull in reality. I have yet to see a classic gui with a decent NN- which learns your default behaviour in every step, applying those by ctrl+left-click.
- jlebrech 9y agoNOW There should be a keyboard with integrated voice recognition, and a "voice assist" button. Remove any superfluous keys (anything you might have to look down for) and just keep the typewriter keys. and add a voico-correct to operating systems, not "auto". you mistype and you can dictate the correct word for it to fix for you. once we have this paradigm the os will evolve for it. I think FULL voice has privacy issues, and annoyance too. I want to quietly instruct my pc, not talk to it all day (and I don't want to have to hear someone else do that either)
- mnm1 9y agoIt won't be for awhile yet. Add to all the other issues mentioned here its drastic reduction in accuracy when dealing with accents, let alone non English languages. We're far, far from it working universally. And that's before you even get to semantics or whether it even make sense as a UI.
- guy98238710 9y agoNo it isn't. Huge screens are, whether they come as standard monitors, virtual reality headsets, or 3D displays. People consume orders of magnitude more information that they produce. When compared to large display, voice output is just painful. Furthermore, moving eyes is way faster than any kind of navigation input, even voice. That's why displays contain way more information than what people are able to process at any given moment. And then there's this old principle of GUIs: making choices visible. Screen can list all available options. Voice UI cannot. Even command-line UIs support tab-complete for this reason. If I were to be very cynical, I would say that voice UIs shine when people are illiterate enough to avoid typing and reading. A less cynical answer is that voice UI fits where big screen doesn't.