6 ms·
Tackling the Internet’s Central Villain: The Advertising Business
- prostoalex 9y ago> cheap and effective persuasion machine is also available to anyone with nefarious ends In theory, once it’s discovered to be persuasive, then it’s no longer cheap, as advertisers start bidding up the limited inventory.
- jacquesm 9y agoThere is no shortage of inventory. Unless you are going for some obscure niche, if all you want is to reach people en masse there are plenty of channels to do so cheaply. It is targeted advertising that can get expensive.
- prostoalex 9y agoThe recipient attention is still scarce. The article throws out numbers like “were seen by nearly 150 million Americans” without elaborating on interactions, conversions or retention rate. Feels like we’re back to inflated extrapolated audience numbers of billboards and TV networks.
- wallacoloo 9y agoI find movements like "responsible ads" or Adblock Plus's "acceptable ads" to be totally missing the point. Ads are, by design, intended to manipulate you. Most of us don't tolerate people or things that so blatantly manipulate us in the physical realm. If a salesman comes to my door unprompted, I'm perfectly happy to cut him off mid-sentence by closing the door. When he tries to sell something to my grandmother that she doesn't want or need over the phone, I have a right to be angry at him for trying to manipulate someone I love. How is it that so many people agree with me here, but then eagerly defend online advertisers' rights to manipulate them? They claim that so long as the ads are unobtrusive, then no problem - even though the ads still have the same goal in the end. These people want to be manipulated. How is any of this rationalized?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 9y agoWhat is even more disturbing is that people in general have only a fraction of an idea of what is going on behind the scenes. It is much worse than most of you think it is.
- book_mentioned 9y agoCan you point to more details available publicly? (Do you have time to flesh this out a bit?)
- jacquesm 9y agoYou could do worse than to start with reading the open exchange spec, that should give you an idea of what's happening under water.
- wpietri 9y agoI totally agree with you here, and have noticed a variety of attempts at rationalization. My favorite is, "Why do you hate the Internet?!?" Since many things they like are paid through via ads, they see an objection to that as an objection to, e.g., news. I think this argument is dumb in a lot of ways, but the biggest for me is that nobody would have figured another way to pay for anything. The next is, "Why do you hate freedom (of speech)?!?" This is usually phrased in a pseudo-first-amendment way, but as far as I can tell the real claim is some sort of might-makes-right, the-ends-justify-the-means, the-rich-can-do-as-they-please nonsense. All sorts of speech is actually illegal. E.g., fraud, solicitation of murder, conspiracy to commit murder, unlicensed practice of medicine, etc, etc. Capitalism is swell and all, but turning a profit is not a license to be a dick. Another big one is along the lines of the Upton Sinclair quote: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" People who work in ads or for ad-supported companies can't see themselves as doing anything wrong, ergo manipulating people for money can't be wrong. And then there's the one I think of as "suffer, Muggles". The logic goes, "I am smart and don't notice my being being manipulated by ads, ergo all the people who are manipulated by ads are dumb and deserve what they get." It's the same shick that you see whenever people get scammed. This ignores that ads and scams are both heavily targeted; that something is obvious just means they were going for another victim. It all makes me crazy, though. We spend something like a half-trillion dollars annually on mass manipulation. The old justification was that people needed to be informed. That made little sense; the novel informational content of a Coke commercial is approximately zero. But now with the Internet, word of mouth is frictionless, reviews are free, and search is magic. Given that ads also obfuscate and confuse, I suspect their net information content is now negative. Might as well spend that half-trillion dollars on something that matters.
- imron 9y agoI'd just rather be done with advertising on the web completely. Bring on Brave's Basic Attention Token.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSo, blockchain advertising? This is a fix? I'm a blogger. Everyone bitches about ads, but removing ads did not cause an uptick in tips. I later added Patreon. Ads are the magic that allow services to be given away for free to people who have zero willingness to pay for said services. The bills need to be paid somehow. Working for free doesn't keep people fed. I am still trying to figure out how to provide quality content that I think is meaningful and also monetize it. I would prefer to remove ads from my sites. But I am really sick of being poor, which no one has any sympathy whatsoever for, and every single time these discussions come up on HN, the overwhelming consensus is that people hate ads but are simply not willing to support content providers. So if I can figure out how to get enough traffic to get ad money rolling in, but can't figure out some other effective monetization scheme, I will go with that and not lose any sleep. Because I have been told for years that people value what I do, but, no, they don't want to pay me. And I am sick of that.
- imron 9y ago> So, blockchain advertising Not blockchain advertising at all. Rather I nominate how much I want to spend each month and the browser keeps track of what sites I visit and pays them proportionally to the amount I visit or optionally how I feel like rewarding them. I feel this is a significantly better model than advertising.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou can do that now. Go pay for subscriptions to established publications, like The New York Times, and be a Patreon supporter of independent small shops, like me and my web projects. But you probably won't, because every single time someone says they would support content if (insert some condition) they really mean "I just like bitching about the status quo like everyone else, but I have no plans to actually open my wallet. And if this new fangled thing actually gets off the ground, I won't support it either and will have some new excuse."* The people actually willing to vote with their wallet do that in the here and now. They don't just make empty promises to do so in some imaginary future that sounds highly unlikely to ever become reality. * This is a general principle. When people claim they would like to support anything at all if only... Most of the time, that basically means "I am lying as I have zero plans to put my money where my mouth is."
- dzink 9y agoThe advertising system is really bad on all three sides. For users it’s obviously spammy and scammy. For content creators there is absolutely no incentive to be accurate and sell on performance if you are writing your own content (most content ads just don’t perform that well), and even worse so - the way you write content and the content you choose to write is heavily influenced by google keywords and algorithms, instead of usefulness. Even if you take the time to do quality content the algorithms flush you down as soon as automatically generated bad content looks more recent. For ad networks the volume of fake clicks and redirects flushes any decency left - they make money when advertisers see this as a casino with variable rewards based on your luck or presumed skill more than a store where you buy results. Advertisers are left to swim in this and experiment while paying for their assumptions. They don’t know what actually works, overpay for fake clicks, and have a constant toll on their business because even if they perform better for customers, those who play the casino games still get the top placement. Google and facebook and anyone who is upstream in the user attention game (Apple and Android for example)can collect rent on anyone who has a business in a competitive industry or has a consumer reach not viral enough to be used and remembered daily. The system is not going to change on its own. The change will come from a better system for consumers that doesn’t monetize attention and doesn’t charge per use and one is coming. Facebook and Google are too dependent on advertising and will not be able to switch fast enough to keep their investors. Their increasingly worsening experience will eventually be overthrown by a much better one for users. I have been iterating and digging deep into alternatives. Ping me if you are working on this problem.
- isolli 9y agoThe fact that you are not willing to share a single element of your revolutionary alternative makes me slightly suspicious...
- RestlessMind 9y agoI have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, digital adtech seems to have gone too far with intrusive tracking, micro targeting, shitty user experience etc. On the other hand, users have revealed their preference again and again in favor of ad-supported free services (see relative unpopularity of Patreon, Youtube Red etc). Users benefit a lot from free search, emails, messaging, video communication, maps and other services. How many would be willing to pay for these services? Based on my industry experience, a very small slice of the global internet population (though I'd be very happy to be proven wrong). Finally, I am hesitant to root for government intervention. While regulations are great in some cases (eg. EPA, CDC etc), I just fear regulations for internet companies would end up hurting small players and would entrench oligopolies of Google, Facebook et al (eg. German regulations about online news ended up benefiting Google News and hurting smaller players, or "right to be forgotten" in EU, while good in intentions, has just set up another barrier to entry for a new search engine).
- cerved 9y agoThis article has some relevant points but it exaggerates the effectiveness of online adverting. Generic display ads have a CTR of 0.05%. With good targeting it's bumped up to 0.1-0.2%. Newsfeed is somewhat stronger in the 0.5-2% range. There are issues with online advertising that need to be addressed but let's not pretend it's some sort of supremely effective form of manipulation.
- jcoffland 9y agoThe problem with regulating current ad systems is that we are asking company's like Facebook and Google to act as censors, deciding what is acceptable and what is not. Crypto-currencies and the IRA are out but ask-your-doctor drug ads and fast food are in. Corporations are not the people to decide this for the rest of society. I believe any form of advertising where the recipient has not specifically chosen to view the ad should be considered a rights violation and banned. This would force advertisers to produce ads people wanted to watch. It would also put an end to billboards, TV commercials, banner ads and most kinds of inline ads. Basically everything that is currently foisted upon us against our will. This would be a radical change but it is the only change that could solve the problems we currently face with advertising today.
- aplorbust 9y agoInternet not same as web. Public web is just one type of internet usage. Almost all ads are on web, triggered from web or html email, leaving rest of internet ad-free. Certainly there are incumbents who want users to think internet and web are synonymous. Radio and TV were "passive" mediums where broadcasters were in control and audiences passively consumed what was offered. Ads were included. Web has traditionally been more interactive. Users had control of what to consume and when, through specific, focused (HTTP) requests. No web user intentionally requests ads. Think about this. The user requests a specific resource. Then how is advertising being "included"? Answer: Popular web browsers load resources (ads) automatically, by default. Requests for ads are made by the browser, not the user. Companies that sell ads write these browsers and try to dominate the "browser market". Other web browsers (that might avoid loading ads) are discouraged. Web developers take advantage of the popular browsers written by ad sales companies to manipulate the pages users request, filling them with ads. Going back into the history of the www and browsers, the intent of auto-loading resources may have originally had nothing to do with advertising. But today, it has everything to do with advertising (and tracking).