4 ms·
> And a team of economists have now crunched the data proving that zoning and restrictive land-use regulations–forces that contribute to making housing so expen
by crazygringo 9y ago
> And a team of economists have now crunched the data proving that zoning and restrictive land-use regulations–forces that contribute to making housing so expensive in cities like San Francisco and New York–are actually driving fertility rates downward.
Are they actually preventing couples from having children, or are couples simply moving away from those areas in order to have their children elsewhere?
And on top of that, are the kind of people who move to NYC or SF already the kind of people planning not to have a kid over the next 5-10 years, or ever?
Taking a quick look at the original paper, the authors don't appear to address these potential factors at all.
- philip1209 9y agoAlso, it doesn't "prove" anything . . . no statistician would ever make that kind of assertion. Correlation is not causation. The conclusion has an error margin.
- VHRanger 9y agoDepends on the statistical method used. Some quasi-experimental methods like instrument variables or difference-in-differences can plausibly tease causal effect sizes from messy economic data That said, this paper seems to be mostly simple descriptive statistics
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> And on top of that, are the kind of people who move to NYC or SF already the kind of people planning not to have a kid over the next 5-10 years, or ever? For what it is worth, NYC as a whole is quite child friendly. Take a stroll around Park Slope and you're tripping over gaggles of children. Now San Francisco? I'm amazed when I see someone under 18.
- nikanj 9y agoLet's say that huge gaggle of kids is is 850 children. New York has some 8 500 000 people living in it. That's an adult-to-kid ratio of one to ten thousand. It's really hard to estimate birth rates by observing people, as our brains just aren't equipped to handle the numbers present. We see the hundreds of children, and flat out refuse to believe there's a decline in births.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoYou can't compare a gaggle of kids in one particular part of Park Slope to the greater New York City metropolitan area and draw a ratio from that. I might as well say that the ratio of rats to people in the city is one-to-eight-million because I saw one rat this morning.
- nikanj 9y agoI think we're saying the same thing. You can't say NY is child friendly, just because you saw a lot of kids at the park.
- jellicle 9y agoSure, it's child-friendly. How many children do you think I can have in my studio apartment? Park Slope has a median real estate price of close to $2 million, and average family incomes well into the six figures.
- PeterStuer 9y agoWe, typical middle class 2 income and at the time no kids, used to live in a city, which was great for proximity to work and culture/nightlife. When we started to think about having children, we moved to a more rural area with lots of outdoor space and great schools close to a university town.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAre they actually preventing couples from having children, or are couples simply moving away from those areas in order to have their children elsewhere? I once posited that there are so many gay couples in San Francisco in part because people who might, oops, end up pregnant just can't afford it. Homosexual couples who want kids have to arrange it. It doesn't happen accidentally because your birth control failed.
- angmarsbane 9y agoYou are asking very good questions. In my personal experience, I'd say it's preventing. I live in Los Angeles and if I lived somewhere else I would have bought a house and had a child with my partner earlier. We thought about moving, but our networks and support systems are here as is the free baby-sitting provided by two sets of grandparents.
- Sinnesloschen 9y agoSince the 1960 the birth rate has been on a downward trend. At the same time the urban population has been increasing. According to this: http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/us-population/ http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/us-population/