2 ms·
> If that's the only thing keeping the will "free" would it even matter if our decisions are made deterministically or by a dice roll? This is a good point, an
by dahart 9y ago
> If that's the only thing keeping the will "free" would it even matter if our decisions are made deterministically or by a dice roll?
This is a good point, and relates directly to the paradox I see.
It's not that randomness is required for free will, or even desired, it's that all other known processes are deterministic. It's an age-old discussion that if the state of the universe and all the particles in it at any given moment is determined entirely by physical laws like conservation of energy, then, it is theorized, free will cannot exist because the future state of the universe can be predicted.
We may have the appearance of free will, but if our thoughts emerge from predictable phenomena, then autonomy and consciousness as we know it can only be a facade.
Quantum randomness is the only process we know of that can't be predicted by a sufficiently powerful simulation. Therefore, quantum randomness is what some people rely on to posit the existence of free will, only because it's the only thing left by process of elimination.
Your point is similar to my question, namely that even if there is randomness, we still have a problem. What's willful about an unpredictably chance event?