2 ms·
The headline suffers because it's a lot less nuanced than the article. Amazon exploits the lack of any better opportunities, but does not create that situation.
by majormajor 9y ago
The headline suffers because it's a lot less nuanced than the article. Amazon exploits the lack of any better opportunities, but does not create that situation. Better than nothing, less than ideal, is the theme, but we can't expect the benevolence of corporations if we want to get the world closer to "ideal." They focus a lot on one nicer alternative - Stater Brothers - but acknowledge that they aren't of the same size and aren't in a position to replace all the Amazon jobs. Any debate over "will people vote with their wallet to punish ruthless businesses," that might've been started long ago with Walmart or foreign manufacturing or anything else, is long since settled. Someone is going to offer people shitty jobs as long as there is no better alternative, so direct the focus to fixing the system, not the single company.
- jedharris 9y agoAmazon (and Walmart before them) do a lot to create this situation. Walmart notoriously kills local businesses when they move into a town -- not by targeting them directly but by competing them out of business. If the alternative employment is gone then there's a lack of better opportunities. This is not to say that we should rely on the benevolence of corporations -- any more than we did to get 40 hours weeks, standards for workplace safety, or food that doesn't make us sick. However a good way of "fixing the system" will have much more impact on Walmart and Amazon than on neighborhood stores. So to a large extent we are indeed going to be fixing a small number of problem companies.
- natecavanaugh 9y ago> Better than nothing, less than ideal, is the theme, but we can't expect the benevolence of corporations if we want to get the world closer to "ideal. But maybe, we can encourage and highlight the ones that are willing to provide social good beyond profit extraction? I understand how the world's top companies become so cut throat, especially those that are publicly traded. But that's not most companies, at least not in the US. Most of them are reasonably sized, privately owned, and most likely the investors are the members of the board. I'm thinking out loud here, but perhaps if cities played the long tail and offered incentives to the small companies, or those with compensation that is within the top tier, maybe it would draw not just existing business but also spur the creation of new ones that will pay taxes, hire people who will also pay taxes while the company also pays taxes on the employees. It seems like a city diversifying that way (and perhaps accentuating their competitive advantage) would make for a much more stable economy overall. I just feel think that capitalism and business itself have so much potential for long term good and helping folks, and maybe we should, culturally, shift our incentives and thinking about what those priorities should be. Of course, competing globally, this becomes much harder to execute, because you will be tempted to race to the bottom. But personally, and am only going off of hunch and absorbed anecdotal info, but I don't think that most of the businesses in any community are competing globally. I tend to think that most economic activity happens locally, be that city, state, or national. And perhaps like a lot of things in the US, maybe we should treat this as a health issue. Long term company health, and not try to soak anyone dry just because our stock price will go up 0.0002% this quarter.