3 ms·
> By far the biggest danger to Venice is the hoards of tourists that make getting around for a local almost impossible. You've got it precisely backwards. By
by CydeWeys 9y ago
> By far the biggest danger to Venice is the hoards of tourists that make getting around for a local almost impossible.
You've got it precisely backwards. By far the biggest danger to Venice is the absence of those hoards of tourists. Venice is dependent upon tourism income for its economy to an extent much greater than most other cities. Rome, Florence, Milan, and others have big businesses and use tourism as supplementary income, but it's the main source for Venice.
- mschuster91 9y ago> By far the biggest danger to Venice is the absence of those hoards of tourists. No. The danger is any point away from the equilibrium - too few/no tourists and there's no income, but too many tourists and the tourists won't spread the word for other potential travelers anymore when they e.g. cannot go to any popular place or getting ripped off hundreds of dollars for pizza.
- CydeWeys 9y ago"It's such a popular tourist spot, no one goes there anymore." (Apologies to Yogi Berra.) Tourism-based economies can't fail from becoming too profitable. If prices are high, it's only because people are still willing to pay them. It's market forces in action.
- dredmorbius 9y agoJust giving that a cursory thinking through, I can see several ways in which that might fail. "Real-estate-based economies can't fail from becoming too profitable. If prices and rents are high, it's only because people are still willing to pay them. It's market forces in action." Or, perhaps, it's rents-extraction, money-laundering, signs of even worse collapse elsewhere, and killing the underlying fundamentals of the local economy. I suspect there's similar lines of analysis which could be applied to tourist spots. And am wondering what examples of now-failed tourist temples there might be. Say, Niagara Falls, as an example.
- CydeWeys 9y agoNiagara Falls is doing just fine though? Can you think of examples of tourism destinations that failed because too many people went there? It seems tautologically impossible to me. Yes, the character of them may change, and they may go more upmarket, but I can't see them completely collapsing from getting too successful. The much more worn path is tourism spots failing from lack of visitors. You see that at the older Las Vegas casinos that can't compete with the latest and greatest mega-resorts, for example.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI asked because examples didn't immediately occur to me, though this isn't a topic with which I'm particularly conversant. Acapulco, Mexico, is a former tourist mecca that's been transformed, though, as with a few other examples I can think of, largely through violence (here: drugs wars). Niagra Falls remains a tourist destination, but not of a scope that it once was. There are several other destinations I could think of, also largely East Coast U.S., which once commanded a high volume of traffic but which are no longer premier destinations.
- ravitation 9y agoNiagara Falls has seen steady growth in terms of tourism revenue and annual visitors for at least close to 30 years (that's as far back as I could find)... And current revenue numbers are (obviously) all time records... So... I'm not really sure what you're talking about.
- dredmorbius 9y agoMeasures of social significance of Niagara Falls as a destination of significance. Or: who is vacationing to N.F.? Is it Wall Street bankers, or working-class types from Cleveland? I'd also strongly suggest not getting too fixated on that one instance. I'm suggesting it as I suspect it might fit, but not because I'm positive of that. Question is if there are any instances along the lines I'd sketched out above. I'm looking through what tourist destinations (or ventures) have failed. One additional dynamic: if the money's high, then net of financing a fall in the market can be catastrophic due to the loan-service nut that must be covered. It's not viable to drop the price, as that would fail to meet debt obligations. The search here turns up several examples of this. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=failed+tourist+destination&ia=news https://duckduckgo.com/?q=failed+tourist+destination&ia=news