4 ms·
What Amazon Does to Poor Cities
- xt00 9y agoI think amazon can come up with a way to make the job less stressful and all that, but I think the articles point that amazon comes in and replaces jobs that were unionized basically misses the point. Over the past 20 years tons of factories shut down because they realized they could get the same thing built someplace else for far cheaper — in many cases unions had helped the people get paid more and more for the same-ish work for years. So the delta between what the factory in Mexico or China would cost could be massive. So in the case of amazon they are not a factory and they can’t really be moved, but they can decide to contract out their fulfillment to another company who is willing to do it and reset the game by bringing in a new workforce that gets paid less again. So it would seem like the smart thing to do would be to keep the pressure on amazon and target specific things they don’t like, but getting unionized and then demanding way more pay and easier conditions will basically drive amazon to contracting out the fulfillment centers to somebody else and you are back to where you started..
- barrkel 9y agoWhat if the choice as a consumer is between two products, one of which costs 20% more than the other but gives employees a better life? It's a somewhat hypothetical question because markets will usually push the more expensive manufacturer into a market niche with fairly heavy marketing costs to sell their ethical USP. The trouble is that prices don't necessarily price everything in; you don't know how much misery you're buying when you hand over your cash. Child labour, sweatshops, corrupt resource extraction in despotic regimes - real externalities disappear when you only compare on price. People agitate to change the game, since the market is inefficient at solving this problem. Either they lobby to pass labour standards laws, or they unionize. The trouble then becomes arbitrage: unscrupulous employers don't want their negative externalities priced in, so they switch to labour elsewhere, taking advantage of beggar-thy-neighbour strategies employed by other regions and countries. As long as there is free trade to anywhere with lower standards of life and labour, work will tend to migrate towards it. The risk is that competitive regional strategies will keep labour oppressed. The alternative is regional and international pacts, much like the EU, that try to prevent this kind of arbitrage and "regulatory dumping". Of course nothing is perfect. Unions can themselves be corrupt, politicians can be captured by labour action groups, and consumers can suffer. Regional and international pacts can use their mechanisms that enforce fair competition to favour local businesses over remote businesses, or entrench monopolies. There's no panacea.
- gt_ 9y agoWhy doesn’t ‘Stater Brothers’ (the other warehouse in the article) outsource like you say? ‘Stater Brothers’ is paying their unionized employees double the hourly wage with extra earnings potential and significantly better benefits. Are you saying Amazon’s ability to relocate the jobs makes outsourcing easier? I can’t think of much else. What is the difference between unionizing and “keeping the pressure on amazon and target specific things they don’t like”? One begets the other. And do we have any evidence there is any pressure on Amazon to begin with?
- xt00 9y agoThe size of the stater brothers operation sounds much smaller than amazon’s. So I would assume the potential upside would be small for somebody to come in and compete. But good point. I’ve been following the whole union thing with Boeing for years and the situation I described is exactly what happened with them for both the machinists and the engineers. Both groups are heavily unionized for Boeing in the Seattle area. After years of the union continuously pushing Boeing to improve wages and benefits, and that made Boeing start looking for a way to get around the union.. moved to “right to work” states, moved head quarters, outsourced to other contractors.. basically the unions pushed the company to diversify their options for building planes. And this is in one of the most expensive product categories you can imagine. So in low margin industries, unionization is without a doubt risky for the future of those workers. You may say I’m speaking the company line but a review of history in the factories in the US shows that unless the company can directly compete with the overseas competitors, they are run out of business by people buying the cheaper and often similar quality product. There are many people in China right now trying to automate as much of their business as possible so that people in more developed countries cannot undercut them once they figure out how to automate before they do.. and if a particular factory in China decides not to do it to help keep their workers, somebody else will do it that currently is not rich and doesn’t own a factory.. why should they let the other guys who already own the factory be the last people to own a factory and no innovation after them? So yea they will get funding and start their own automated factories. So it’s a continuous race to the bottom and every time people say “oh hey stop, we are good” somebody sneaks past them and keeps the race going.. I think the real take away is we need to figure out how to have something like a union that helps people but doesn’t basically hurt the companies competiveness globally.. maybe having the people get paid the same but the robots do more.. the people should push for that instead of unionizing and asking for more money to work less.. because let’s not kid ourselves, that is what people that are unionizing are hoping happens..
- majormajor 9y agoThe headline suffers because it's a lot less nuanced than the article. Amazon exploits the lack of any better opportunities, but does not create that situation. Better than nothing, less than ideal, is the theme, but we can't expect the benevolence of corporations if we want to get the world closer to "ideal." They focus a lot on one nicer alternative - Stater Brothers - but acknowledge that they aren't of the same size and aren't in a position to replace all the Amazon jobs. Any debate over "will people vote with their wallet to punish ruthless businesses," that might've been started long ago with Walmart or foreign manufacturing or anything else, is long since settled. Someone is going to offer people shitty jobs as long as there is no better alternative, so direct the focus to fixing the system, not the single company.
- jedharris 9y agoAmazon (and Walmart before them) do a lot to create this situation. Walmart notoriously kills local businesses when they move into a town -- not by targeting them directly but by competing them out of business. If the alternative employment is gone then there's a lack of better opportunities. This is not to say that we should rely on the benevolence of corporations -- any more than we did to get 40 hours weeks, standards for workplace safety, or food that doesn't make us sick. However a good way of "fixing the system" will have much more impact on Walmart and Amazon than on neighborhood stores. So to a large extent we are indeed going to be fixing a small number of problem companies.
- natecavanaugh 9y ago> Better than nothing, less than ideal, is the theme, but we can't expect the benevolence of corporations if we want to get the world closer to "ideal. But maybe, we can encourage and highlight the ones that are willing to provide social good beyond profit extraction? I understand how the world's top companies become so cut throat, especially those that are publicly traded. But that's not most companies, at least not in the US. Most of them are reasonably sized, privately owned, and most likely the investors are the members of the board. I'm thinking out loud here, but perhaps if cities played the long tail and offered incentives to the small companies, or those with compensation that is within the top tier, maybe it would draw not just existing business but also spur the creation of new ones that will pay taxes, hire people who will also pay taxes while the company also pays taxes on the employees. It seems like a city diversifying that way (and perhaps accentuating their competitive advantage) would make for a much more stable economy overall. I just feel think that capitalism and business itself have so much potential for long term good and helping folks, and maybe we should, culturally, shift our incentives and thinking about what those priorities should be. Of course, competing globally, this becomes much harder to execute, because you will be tempted to race to the bottom. But personally, and am only going off of hunch and absorbed anecdotal info, but I don't think that most of the businesses in any community are competing globally. I tend to think that most economic activity happens locally, be that city, state, or national. And perhaps like a lot of things in the US, maybe we should treat this as a health issue. Long term company health, and not try to soak anyone dry just because our stock price will go up 0.0002% this quarter.
- prepend 9y ago“Workers say the warehouse jobs are grueling and high-stress” It’s a warehouse job constantly on the move, stocking and filling orders. I’m not sure what expectations employers have or why they are surprised. I wish the article went into this a bit more to explain the disconnect between expectations and reality. It sort of touches on how it’s not information work, but do these areas think that fulfillment centers employee the same as engineering sites? Or if they did, they would hire unskilled labor?