4 ms·
It's a shame that statistics don't back up this hoary old saying. Turns out that modeling drivers as if they were ideal gas particles doesn't give you the numb
by CamperBob2 9y ago
It's a shame that statistics don't back up this hoary old saying. Turns out that modeling drivers as if they were ideal gas particles doesn't give you the numbers you expect.
Meanwhile, lack of respect for traffic laws due to inappropriately-low speed limits arguably does get people killed.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> Meanwhile, lack of respect for traffic laws due to inappropriately-low speed limits arguably does get people killed. This is one area where I believe we need to treat the "lack of respect" part, i.e. beat the people into submission. Because it's not reasonable to optimize speed limits for what a driver feels should be appropriate - a driver takes into account his own position and situation only, while optimizing traffic is a much larger-scale exercise. (Also, frankly, it's the speed that kills. If either the pedestrian or you were dumb enough to get into crash at 50km/h, you'd get into an even harder crash at 100km/h. I cringe when I hear drivers wanting to raise speed limits on the roads that have foot traffic crossing it, children playing on the sidewalks, etc.)
- mantas 9y agoGerman autobahn traffic would like a word with you. Drivers over there are pretty good to find out their reasonable speed. There's a ton of respect between drivers too. Probably the most respectful driving culture I drove at.
- konschubert 9y agoAside from the fact that the parent was talking about city streets, not freeways... I find Autobahn driving very stressful. Crossing the border into Switzerland, which has a general speed limit, traveling becomes much more enjoyable.
- mantas 9y agoI was talking about his general sentiment that people don’t consider others and have to be beaten into submission. Out of countries I drive at, Germany is least stressful. Especially because drivers seem to be very considerate of others. Including, if not more, on unlimited autobahn sections. Haven’t driven in Switzerland yet though.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> I was talking about his general sentiment that people don’t consider others and have to be beaten into submission. It's not that they don't consider others (though there are plenty of angry drivers out there). It's that they're assuming they know better than traffic engineers and legislators. That assumption is full of hubris, and even if sometimes correct, it makes it more difficult for people setting the limits to do global optimization. But yes, ultimately it is - maybe unintentionally - not considering other users of the road system.
- CamperBob2 9y agoIt's that they're assuming they know better than traffic engineers and legislators I think it's very safe to say I know better than legislators who've never been within hundreds of miles of the road I'm driving on. It may not be as safe to say I know better than the engineers, but the engineers' opinions are of very little interest to the legislators.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoWe can't just go changing the laws because some segment of the population doesn't like speed limits.
- CamperBob2 9y agoReal-world driver behavior is exactly what should define the speed limit, if you're interested in safety. Google "85th percentile rule."
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoIf the 85th percentile is faster than what is safe, you need to change the road design so that the 85th percentile goes down, not just raise the speed limit.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 9y agoIt sounds like you didn't actually do any reading on the subject.
- gowld 9y agoA thoroughly researched article vs an offhand gut-check.
- CamperBob2 9y agoFor documentation for said gut-check, do a search on "85th percentile rule."