6 ms·
Spain cracks King Ferdinand's 500-year-old code
- strictnein 9y agoThe message, in Spanish: > Asegúrese de beber su Ovaltine
- jeioncs 9y agoThe secret code of the letters of the Great Captain and Fernando the Catholic that the CNI and the Army Museum announced yesterday to have deciphered, had already been discovered previously. Gustave Bergenroth, a nineteenth-century German Hispanist based in England, published his studies on the General Archive of Simancas in the 'Calendar of State Papers, Spain, Volume 1, 1485-1509' in the year 1862. In the preface he explains his journey in the archive and an introduction to how he deciphered the Spanish codes. https://www.elconfidencial.com/cultura/2018-02-03/codigo-secreto-gran-capitan-gustave-bergenroth_1516192/ https://www.elconfidencial.com/cultura/2018-02-03/codigo-sec... A known mistery
- fovc 9y agoLink is in Spanish. I found the linked blog post from the physics professor who first noticed that the code had been previously cracked more interesting and informative (also in Spanish): http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/2018/02/02/el-cni-y-el-no-tan-secreto-codigo-del-gran-capitan/ http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/2018/02/02/el-cni-y-el-no-...
- dmix 9y agoInteresting, here's a good quote beyond the fact that it was already deciphered a century ago (by a 19th century historian, not a cryptanalyst working for a 3 letter agency in 2018): > First, and contrary to what ABC says, this code is not very sophisticated. It is a monoalphabetic substitution system with homophones to which a set of terms of agreed language has been added. I have a handful of Spanish codes of the time and I can assure you that there are more sophisticated codes than this one. For example, the so-called Clave de los Capitulaciones is similar in form and structure, being at least ten years older; and the General Figure of the Catholic Kings, dated similar to that of the Great Captain, had no less than 670 terms in agreed language. > Third, these types of keys were already vulnerable to cryptanalytic attacks at that time. Manias such as encrypting only part of the letter, or repeating the used encrypted terms, made them relatively easy to decipher by unauthorized users. There's also a pictures of what the deciphered key looks like both in the 1800s version on old paper and the CNI's version on graph paper which is interesting.
- azinman2 9y agoLink to the photos?
- dmix 9y ago1852 = http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/files/2018/02/Clave-Gran-Capitan-1.jpg http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/files/2018/02/Clave-Gran-C... 2018 = http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/files/2018/02/Clave-Gran-Capitan-2.jpg http://elprofedefisica.naukas.com/files/2018/02/Clave-Gran-C...
- azinman2 9y agoNeat!
- relyks 9y agoIt'd be cool if they let you in on how the code was deciphered. Does anyone know of any sources that discuss the process? Sounds like in this case frequency analysis wouldn't have cut it :D
- icot 9y agoThe original document by G. Bergenroth mentioned in the link provided by jeioncs is supposed to have a description of the original procedure. I don't know how/if you can get a document from the National Archives of the United Kingdom, though. Edit: Link to the actual Archives entry: http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C12056 http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C12056
- hordeallergy 9y agoI live a five minute walk from the archives, they're open to all, but closed today.
- jeioncs 9y agoThe Spanish intelligence service has deciphered the code again since they have found a letter used by the great captain. They have found a "rosette stone" with the code encrypted and deciphered. http://www.rtve.es/alacarta/videos/telediario/td2-codigo-020218/4455620/ http://www.rtve.es/alacarta/videos/telediario/td2-codigo-020...
- orblivion 9y agoAny code more than 50 years old should be trivial to crack by modern cryptoanalysis right? Otherwise we wouldn't be told to only use the very best algos we have on hand. It must have just been a matter of taking the time to crack this particular code. On a side note, (as long as they mention Rosetta Stone) does writing in another language count as a form of cryptography? If so, it should likewise be trivial to crack any remaining unknown ancient scripts. But I'm probably being ignorant somewhere here.
- socceroos 9y agoAre you counting the One Time Pad?
- rocqua 9y agoThe hard part is generally figuring out what cipher is being used. Once you know that, and the cipher is old, modern crypt analysis would probably easily crack it. This is down to kerchoffs principle, which states that you should not rely on the secrecy of what cipher is being used, only on the secrecy of the key. As such, writing in another language is not cryptography. There is a name for hiding info by depending on the method being unknown: steganography. This includes different using different languages (see the navaho code talkers), or hiding data in the less significant bits of an image, or hiding a message in the first letter of every sentence and so forth.
- orblivion 9y ago> This is down to kerchoffs principle, which states that you should not rely on the secrecy of what cipher is being used, only on the secrecy of the key. As such, writing in another language is not cryptography. Since "language as cryptography" breaks Kerchoff's Principle, doesn't that just make it bad cryptography? Shouldn't that make it all the easier to use cryptanalysis to translate it? Unrelated point: I thought Steganography was the art of hiding the _fact_ of encryption. If a Japanese analyst hears someone talking in Navajo, it's no secret that some unknown message is being conveyed.
- 9y ago
- YTGRK 9y agohttps://youtu.be/wxU3yWAURE8 https://youtu.be/wxU3yWAURE8
- moyix 9y agoOne of my Italian professors from undergrad, Marcello Simonetta, also cracked a 500 year-old code. He found an encrypted letter [1] sent by Federico da Montefeltro, the Duke of Urbino, that showed he had helped orchestrate the Pazzi conspiracy [2] to assassinate Lorenzo de' Medici. Interestingly, to break the code he relied on a code-breaking manual written by one of his own ancestors, Cicco Simonetta [3]! When I first learned about this, I thought it was incredibly silly that he didn't ask a modern cryptographer for help. But in some ways, Cicco's manual, written around the same time, is more useful: it focuses on precisely the kind of codes that would have been used for the letter, and the techniques it describes are reasonably effective (essentially frequency analysis, with some specific tricks for documents written in Latin or Italian). And it is certainly more narratively satisfying that he ended up breaking it on his own, following his ancestor's manual! If you want to know more, he wrote a book on the subject: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001AL6656/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001AL6656/ And as another fun bit of trivia, he ended up consulting on the historical aspects of Assassin's Creed II, which takes place in Florence around the time of the Pazzi conspiracy! [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/06/books/1478-assassination-solved-the-humanist-did-it.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/06/books/1478-assassination-s... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pazzi_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pazzi_conspiracy [3] http://cipherfoundation.org/older-ciphers/voynich-manuscript/cicco-simonettas-regule/cicco-simonettas-treatise-decipherment/ http://cipherfoundation.org/older-ciphers/voynich-manuscript...
- walshemj 9y agoYou have to wonder if deep in the vaults of GCHQ there are not records going back that long :-)