3 ms·
There are two senses in which we mean "free will". The first is physical non-determinism - "My actions are not decided by deterministic processes", which is abs
by visarga 9y ago
There are two senses in which we mean "free will". The first is physical non-determinism - "My actions are not decided by deterministic processes", which is absurd. The second, is psychological - "I select my actions for internal reasons". That's trivial, no mystery there.
Maybe when we think about free will we actually refer to cooperation-betrayal strategies between people (prisoner's dilemma) which are essential in the functioning of societies. We want to see ourselves as free to choose our strategy in response to other agent's actions. "If they betray me, I have the choice between cooperation and retaliation" - that's what we feel as free will that counts.
- goldenkey 9y agoDeterminism removes internal/external separation. They commute when both are deterministic. Consider deterministic system A and deterministic system B in a deterministic environment C. Then the entire system is deterministic and though the situation might not have played out yet, it essentially was decided for the participants. Non determinism is the best free will can be -- neither nature knows the future, nor the participants. Everyone is blind. So the will is "free" with respect to control.