3 ms·
This is the sort of evangelizing that is more counterproductive than is helpful, because it's arguing a fairly extreme version that distorts the truth. To wit:
by jcranmer 9y ago
This is the sort of evangelizing that is more counterproductive than is helpful, because it's arguing a fairly extreme version that distorts the truth. To wit:
* Physics Barbie: The complaint here is that a doll that gets its spoken facts from the cloud can't be overwritten by parents to have STEM-friendly phrases. Of all of the things, this is truly a stretch because... just buy a different doll if you really care?
* Meme-making DVR: It would be more accurate to say "you can't get HDCP content in a form you can composite for clip-making."
* Rein-and-Train: This is basically a complaint of "the manufacturer won't let me edit the code on my hardware devices." This has nothing to do with DRM or DMCA or even copyright law.
* Ad-free YouTube: Ad-blockers do exist. And they're not illegal, not even under stretchy definitions of DMCA. If you had the ads more or less burned into a HDCP stream, then building an ad-blocker for that might have legal repercussions, but the ad servers aren't going to want to do that for other reasons.
* Machine translation: the complaint here is effectively that the audio-extraction tools could run afoul of the DMCA's anti-copyright-circumvention provision. This is a bit of a legal stretch, but any tool but that one step would definitely be in the clear. It's worth noting that the fansubbing tools actually turned out to push the edges of video editing and distribution technology, and fansubbing is the sort of thing that is almost certainly illegal.
* Text-to-speech: Assistive technologies are, I believe, fully exempt from the copyright laws (particularly if solely for personal use). I don't know if the exemptions are only limited to Braille book production or other technologies, but you could probably get in a ADA lawsuit if you were so inclined.
* 3D printer ink: no idea what's preventing the thing here, especially because the recent Lexmark v Impression case more or less holds that you can legally do some creative things to get around the RFID DRM stuff here.
* E-Reader fonts: Again no legal issue here other than "the manufacturer won't let me do something."
* Adaptive music for mood of books: Similar issue with machine translation. Of course, given the granularity of data, the e-book metadata (which isn't encrypted in the DRM formats) is probably sufficient to drive what you'd want anyways.
Nothing in that list is persuasive that anything in copyright law is wrong, especially because half of the list doesn't actually correspond to copyright issues.