3 ms·
As pointed out, this has been discussed before. The effect is explainable with electrostatics. As in "If you assume a net charge on a human of X and a equal pol
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
As pointed out, this has been discussed before. The effect is explainable with electrostatics. As in "If you assume a net charge on a human of X and a equal polarity charge of Y being generated by the motion of the tape, a force F would be felt by a person approaching that went up with the inverse square of the distance." Simon Field has a great demo where he throws around pie plates using this effect.
The challenge arises with explaining how the charge is contained such that the opposing charge that is being attracted does not break down the insulator between it and this charge. One thought experiment that I heard at the Boston Science museum was to imagine you are inside the ball of a very large Van De Graff type generator. If you were charged to the same polarity of the outer sphere, you would be repelled by the sphere toward the center. The harder you tried to go to the edge, the more you would be repelled. And, assuming you were insulated from the sphere. By clothing or some other apparatus, there would be a point where the electrostatic repulsion would keep you from being able to touch the sphere and effectively discharge your charge into the sphere.
This only works as an explanation if the manufacturing facility was acting as the sphere, and on entering it you found your self inside that sphere and with a net charge of the same polarity.
What is most remarkable about the story, and causes many (myself included) to doubt it, is that 3M is/was a company that was famous for its core competency of taking unexpected effects and turning them into products (the post-it note story is a great example of that). Because of that competence, it is challenging to imagine that they had accidentally created something, which if understood better could potentially be the foundation of a multi-billion dollar product industry (force fields are widely sought out by people wishing to exclude access). And yet they left it as a "wow, that's funny" sort of moment? A more expected outcome would be for 3M to build an identical plant to see if they could replicate the effect and if they did, begin to instrument and remove components until they understood (and probably patented) all of the ways the field could be generated. And then decided if it was possible to make as a product or not.
- Retric 9y agoWhen you are in a sphere you feel zero net forces from the sphere. Here is an example using gravity but electrostatic forces should operate the same way. https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/Numbers/Math/Mathematical_Thinking/grvtysp.htm https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/Numbers/Math/Mathematical_... You can only feel forces if it's some other shape.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoCharge doesn't work the same way. All of the charge is on the surface of the sphere (that is how a Van deGraff generator works). Unlike gravity, like charged things inside the sphere are repulsed by the surface just as things outside the sphere are.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe shell theorem holds true for spherically symmetric distributions and inverse-square laws. The electrostatic force within a spherically-symmetric charged object is exactly 0. (cf. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_theorem for some proofs)
- tzs 9y agoAs you mention, this assumes a spherically symmetric distribution. In the case of a charged conductive sphere, the charges are free to move. With no charge present other than that on the sphere they will arrange themselves spherically symmetrically. But if there is other charge near the sphere (outside or in), shouldn't that cause some rearrangement of the charges on the sphere, breaking in most cases the spherical symmetry?
- ScottBurson 9y agoThat's an interesting question! I think the effect would be the opposite of what ChuckMcM imagines: as a (say) positively charged particle inside a positively charged conductive sphere moves from the center toward one side of the sphere, it repels the charges on that side more than it does on the opposite side. It does seem like that would cause those charges to spread out slightly, making that part of the sphere negative relative to the other side, accelerating the particle in the direction it was already going, until it hits the sphere. The minimum energy is thus where all charges within the sphere are on its surface; none are inside. I believe this is consistent with observation.
- 9y ago