3 ms·
> to physics where they want to get rid of the need for evidence altogether[3] I don't see how you got that from the article you cited. Take string theory. It
by tzs 9y ago
> to physics where they want to get rid of the need for evidence altogether[3]
I don't see how you got that from the article you cited.
Take string theory. It was created to unify gravity and quantum mechanics.
Afterwards it was found that it also could correctly solve problems from several other areas of physics outside of the unification of gravity and QM. It had not been designed to solve those. That came out of it unexpectedly.
If the existence of those problems had happened to have been discovered after string theory instead of before, they would have been testable predictions of string theory that it would pass, and would count as evidence for string theory.
It seems ridiculous to disqualify them from being evidence for string theory just because of the historical accident that they happened to have been discovered earlier.
- nonbel 9y agoThis is what it says: >"Many of today’s theorists — chief among them the proponents of string theory and the multiverse hypothesis — appear convinced of their ideas on the grounds that they are beautiful or logically compelling, despite the impossibility of testing them." Your position seems to be different from that described in the article. Anyway, post-dicting is not as impressive as pre-dicting. How much less impressive is determined by the flexibility of the model. My understanding is that the string-theory/multiverse model is extremely flexible.
- tzs 9y agoYour quote is coming from some people quoted early in the article (around paragraph 5). My position is based on quotes quite a ways farther into the article, from people who are disagreeing with the earlier quoted people.