4 ms·
How does this threaten the security or privacy of the Internet _at all_? Whois data isn't accurate even by horrible standards. They've tried to make it more str
by jchw 9y ago
How does this threaten the security or privacy of the Internet _at all_? Whois data isn't accurate even by horrible standards. They've tried to make it more stringent but I have domains of mine with the wrong address that I'm too lazy to update and it's been wrong for years now. No problem for my Whois records. And to get around whois records, if we as owners of domains want privacy, we have to deal with shady companies that effectively take control of our domain's ownership. Great for selling whois privacy products, but not at all good for internet security.
SSL certificates already aren't good enough to prove the legitimacy of an organization, not even EV ones. Why Whois data would be any use is beyond me.
- jstarfish 9y agoI find whois data less useful every day. 90% of the time when I'm researching suspicious domains, it maps back to one of those shady companies, and the malware author hiding behind it doesn't care about handing over ownership of his disposable DGA domains to said shady company. Even legit sites are starting to hide whois data behind privacy proxies. Hijacked sites only ever map back to a victim, not the perpetrator. As part of my investigative workflow it's largely a waste of time to whois anything. It seems to only benefit domain squatters and spammers.
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> if we as owners of domains want privacy, we have to deal with shady companies that effectively take control of our domain's ownership. Some domain name providers, such as Gandi, offer privacy of address, phone, and email data while leaving your name as the owner of record.
- jchw 9y agoI do use Gandi and trust them, but I'm not sure if this is 100% possible. Gandi still has limitations that largely depend on TLDs.
- newscracker 9y agoI use only NearlyFreeSpeech.net (a web host that also provides domain registration), and its planning to do domains by itself sometime in the future. I like its no nonsense and practical policies.
- quickthrower2 9y agoI think it is weird to have a physical address for a domain. At least that should be optional. Definitely is a pro-company and anti-individual concept. If you are a company no problem using your address. As an individual it is not private, do you want people who hate your site knocking at your door and your kid answers? Then namecheap as whois guard and all that. Extra rent you have to pay to keep your privacy!
- jchw 9y agoYou can always use a PO Box, as I've done in the past. Extra rent, but useful.
- harlanji 9y agoLao Tzu says that in preparing a defense you welcome an enemy. If we create from our thought and intent, why would we take steps? This thinking instantly puts most people into fear mode, but when you live it and nothing happens fear totally loses any gravity, these discussions are tiresome. People ramdomly go crazy and target people on the internet probably less often than home invasions on houses with unlocked doors. But again quantitative analysis brings us back into the fearful analysis mode and out of abundant loving mode. Hard idea to explain, and my analytical brain comprehends the woowoo, but woowoo is critically important in that thought.
- newscracker 9y agoIt's not only about some trolls targeting the content creators. It's also about government, government officials and large (ethically challenged) corporations and "organized crime" that one needs to be on guard against. Even if you host with a provider in another jurisdiction who will resist revealing your information, the WHOIS data is a sitting duck. I don't think this piece of advice from Lao Tzu applies to our post-Snowden world. Definitely not for people who are against the powers that be (and on whom healthy democracies depend on).
- quickthrower2 9y agoOr http://www.fakenamegenerator.com/ http://www.fakenamegenerator.com/
- closeparen 9y agoWe deserve to know how public resources are owned and allocated. Whether it’s land, RF spectrum, or a corporation, ownership being public record is an important part of the social contract. Domains may be too opaque, but completely removing any semblance of transparency only makes it worse.
- wyager 9y ago> ownership being public record is an important part of the social contract. This is silly. Public ownership records are a practical utility, not a deep-rooted moral practice. Incidentally, we’ve figured out how to have digital asset ownership without invoking “the social contract” or any of its many connotations; we have blockchains now. Namecoin solved this exact problem, although it never took off.
- closeparen 9y ago>not a deep-rooted moral practice. How do you think the Freedom of Information Act got there? It may be going out of fashion, but many of us do believe that the workings of public institutions should be transparent because we value transparency itself. The public record would be much smaller if pragmatism were the only reason to make something public record. ICANN (or whatever supplants it, like Namecoin) is the Register of Deeds of the internet.
- newscracker 9y agoGovernments and larger corporations, which are generally a lot more powerful than individuals, ought to be forced to be transparent to individuals, and not the other way around. Anything on the former is welcome. Anything on the latter needs stronger justifications.
- closeparen 9y agoOwnership of a zero-sum resource like land, spectrum, or DNS is the most fundamental form of power.