4 ms·
> "The only reason you are able to make some sense out of it is that you have a human-level understanding of language and that you can place the nonsense string
by the_af 9y ago
> "The only reason you are able to make some sense out of it is that you have a human-level understanding of language and that you can place the nonsense strings generated by GT"
I think you're understating the quality of the automated translation here. It's by definition not nonsense if I can derive a pretty accurate picture of the situation by reading it. While flawed, it's not random gibberish. If it were random, I -- not knowing how to read Greek -- wouldn't be able to understand about someone being in the hospital because of a broken leg, about some friends visiting him, and about the social faux pas of the two girls being in the same room as the patient. Yes, some of the mistranslations are funny, but they are not nonsense.
If an automated translation is good enough for a human-level understanding of language to parse and derive a decently accurate picture out of it, while not understanding a single word of the original text, then that's an impressive achievement!
By the way, those of us who remember the initial results of early Google Translate should be impressed. It was truly, really unusable. It has gone a really long way, to the point I consider using it in places where I really cannot understand a single word or read the script... like in Japan, for example.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoTo restate my previous comment, the fact that you can understand a badly mangled phrase is not evidence that it's not gibberish- it's a testament to your ability to glean meaning even from gibberish. Is a machine that produces gibberish that's not too mangled to understand better than having no translation at all? It certainly is. However, Google's hype machine will not stop there- they consistently overstate the ability of their systems, by a very large margin. If Google was saying "look, we have a machine translation system, it's a bit shit but it gets the job done" that'd be fine. But they don't say that. They pretend their system actually solves machine translation, for real, like AlphaZero solved Go. You just have to watch the triumphant press releases that come out of Google. For instance: https://research.googleblog.com/2016/11/zero-shot-translation-with-googles.html https://research.googleblog.com/2016/11/zero-shot-translatio...
- the_af 9y agoI disagree. By definition, if it's gibberish no amount of human-level understanding of language will be able to glean meaning from it. You cannot extract meaning from random noise. This is better than random noise; in fact it's way better than what Google Translate used to manage a decade ago. It's not gibberish. It's just very bad quality. But it helps me extract the meaning, which is not that far from what I do with some of the emails I receive in my day job -- trust me!
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI'll ask you the same question I'm asking above: if that kind of language is not gibberish, then why are we not all trying to communicate like that? To take this a step further- if your child was speaking in such a manner you would be very, very concerned. But with GT it's OK? Why?
- mseebach 9y agoThis is absurd. You keep insisting on perfection or nothing at all. There is such a thing as incremental progress. Google Translate is supremely useful in the absence of a better alternative. Nobody is contesting that human translation is better than Google Translate, but a human translator isn't always available. Google Translate is better than nothing at all. A child's first many, many attempts at language are absolute gibberish, then slowly individual words, then combinations of words, then gradually more complex sentences etc -- gradually over several years. When you child first says "mama", the common response is excitement, not berating the child and anyone excited that "mama" isn't Wordsworth, and asking if just saying "mama" is acceptable, why aren't we all just communicating using single words all the time? A child being able to express itself at all using language is better than it not being able to, and cause for celebration, and so too it is with Google Translate.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> You keep insisting on perfection or nothing at all. There is such a thing as incremental progress. I think we're talking at cross-purposes here a bit. I don't really care whether GT is useful as a tool. I care about whether the translations it offers are good translations or not. I think you're basically saying that, if it's good enough for you, then it's a good translation. However, this is not a good measure of the quality of a translation! To begin with, what's good for you is a sujective measure. Further, we wouldn't accept "it's good enough for me" for any other translation than a machine translation- and it's accepted for GT only because we understand the limitations of machine translation systems. So basically my pointing out the limitations of machine translation systems has nothing to do with whether it's useful to you. It's an attempt to explain why the results of machine translation are objectively bad. I'll agree if you want that it's very difficult to get to such an objective measure of goodness or badness. But that's actually a reason why it's so hard to do machine translation properly: because it's next to impossible to evaluate machine translation objectively, which in turn makes for a very poorly defined task. So you can feel justified to say that GT is OK for you, because you can understand it. Others can say that it sucks because they can't. And Google can say it's a breakthrough in AI because it scores high on their formal tests, evaluating using BLEU score (or something equally arbitrary). But none of those tells us how good or bad GT translation really is. So we're left with what Hofstadter does (and what I did here): eyballing it. And, eyballing it, you can see that it's making elementary, egregious mistakes that are not justified by the hype surrounding GT as a product. Btw, we can expect a child to get better at using language because most children do. So far, no machine translation system has got a lot better than GT- and I don't even agree that GT has gotten any better over the years, or that it's even any better than earlier systems. It just happens to be Google's system and they advertise it as the best ever- but they can't actually, you know, prove this.