2 ms·
I'm pretty ad-friendly compared to most on HN (people have shown countless times that they don't want to pay if they don't have to, and microtransaction/favor/t
by majormajor 9y ago
I'm pretty ad-friendly compared to most on HN (people have shown countless times that they don't want to pay if they don't have to, and microtransaction/favor/tipping systems are a giant mess and likely always will be), but the "people have to track to keep stuff running!" view strikes me as naive.
a) Right now we have "content" created and tailored more to pull in ad revenue than to do anything user-beneficial. That's not ideal, most pure clickbait going away would not be a net negative. Consider news: was the internet of 15 years ago meaningfully devoid of news content compared to today, or was it better off cause it wasn't flooded with as much polarized crap?
b) There's an assumption here that ad spending will decrease. One alternative possibility is that ad companies have been stuck in arms races for years now, without actually increasing yield. Look at the reasons why companies are "pivoting to video" - even with all this tracking and "AI" garbage, online display ad effectiveness still sucks. As long as every network and publisher has to follow the same rules, I don't believe any advertiser is truly worse off. And from a principle-based view, I think any sort of smart-enough tracking to produce truly well-targeted ads (vs today's "here's that thing you already bought, let me show you it on every website now" crap) is too far on the creepy side to be something we want anyway.
c) The other side of the "sites won't make money anymore" side is that with a more even playing field there's a chance for some of the money to shift away from the people playing tech games and to the people producing the content. There's not a ton of effective competition in ad networks right now, look where all the revenue goes. A Facebook and Google duopoly also only makes the implications of the tracking worse.
d) Finally, from the advertiser's perspective: where else are they going to send that budget? TV? Newspapers? Please. And even the worst case here - a net decrease in ad spending - is hard to paint as such a huge loss since there's a lot of more productive things out there than showing ads.
There are a few other trends that will need to be ultimately addressed separately, though. One is the shift to video even for stuff that's rather stupid to force into the video format, just because the audience is more captive to ads, and this is a big problem IMO. Not really relevant to what we're discussing here, though. A more interesting debate may be around fraud prevention, I could see a plausible claim that if you have less history on the user you have fewer heuristics you can apply for fraud-fighting. I'm mostly meh on that, though, and willing to let fraud be the cost of business with internet display ads and hope it just washes out in the long run. (I'd prefer if it caused people to shift to paid models, but I'm not optimistic.)