4 ms·
The reason for this regulation is the privacy of EU citizens. Businesses (both in EU and outside) don't "behave well" by themselves, since there's an inherent p
by PeterisP 9y ago
The reason for this regulation is the privacy of EU citizens. Businesses (both in EU and outside) don't "behave well" by themselves, since there's an inherent profit motive in violating users' privacy and interests, so this regulation is forcing them to do this.
The best case is just that - businesses serving EU citizens (this includes most large multinational businesses as well, companies hosted outside do have to abide with these stricter regulation at least for EU users, since almost always they also have EU customers or EU presence) have to obey these rules. They don't get to (ab)use user's data that much and are unhappy about this, but figure out on how to live on without that data.
- erikrothoff 9y agoI absolutely agree that privacy is important. However, what I'd like to understand more is: What are the regulators actually expecting to happen? Looking at the first version of the cookie law, basically the end result was a worse user experience across EU websites. Large warnings that take up large screen real estate, people learning to just blindly accept without reading. I was trying to explain to my SO that I'd been to a presentation about GDPR and ePrivacy, and said "It's the new version of the cookie warning" "Oh is that those awful warnings? I hate those I don't even understand what they are trying to say" From a pragmatic standpoint the result of these new regulations seems to be not that publishers and other ad-financed businesses are saying "OK, ads are bad, let's do less of those". They are finding workarounds that abide by the law, but still allow them to target ads as optimally as they can. The true winners in this are obviously the platforms with the largest database of users and user interest: Google and Facebook. The two companies are are dominating already, and in essence killing smaller local (EU) publishers. So from that perspective, are the regulators hoping that publishers and local companies band together, creating cookie pools and sharing user information amongst themselves to strengthen their position against FB and GOOG? Or are they hoping that EU companies come up with the holy grail of new revenue streams that nobody has though of yet? TL;DR: In my mind: T stop bad things regulators make laws against something, and also to promote the "right way". Example: People get hit by cars crossing the roads anywhere. They invent a crosswalk and make it illegal to cross the road anywhere other than the crosswalk. What is the ePrivacy version of the crosswalk?
- PeterisP 9y agoThe main cause with the "cookie law" is that the law as written failed to implement the intent; the intent was to reduce tracking by cookies, but the actual requirement could be satisfied by those obnoxious warnings while doing tracking as before, and so it was. If the concept of "consent to cookies" was worded more strongly, as in the current laws, then many websites would actually have not made these warnings and simply made do without the cookies, since they wouldn't be able to obtain consent from most people anyway. The new laws seem to avoid this mistake (of course, only time will tell for sure) - they are harsh enough to ensure the strategy "figure out what legalese we need to add to keep doing the same things" is not viable, and they have to actually stop gathering and using that data. In my reading, GDPR seems like it will not enable workarounds that still allow targeting ads as optimally as they could in 2017. They'll still try to target them as optimally as they can, they'll probably figure out some workarounds for parts of it but that will by necessity be ads that are less targeted and use less private information (at least for EU residents) than last year. Also, the intent of lawmakers is clear - whatever workarounds the ad industry figures out to circumvent that intent are likely to be closed in 3-5 years with the next iteration of this directive. The regulators are not "hoping that publishers and local companies band together, creating cookie pools and sharing user information amongst themselves" - they are explicitly creating conditions to ensure that it's almost impossible to get consent for that sharing of user information, and also that Facebook and Google will be able to get much less information than they could before - for example, the GDPR has a big impact on information gathered by all the FB like buttons and google analytics snippets in third party websites; and the "4% of global turnover" clause is included explicitly so that it has leverage to force Google and FB to change their behavior (at least for EU residents). There's no such thing as a "service-wide" opt-in for everything anymore; I will be able to deny Google consent to use my gmail data for targeting ads on google.com, and Google will have to obey; I will be able to ask Facebook for the data they've gathered about me on third party websites and get them to remove that data. Since it's expected that most EU consumers will not give that consent (why would they?) it will pull Google and FB down to the level of those ordinary publishers; they will lose the data that historically gave them this advantage. They're not hoping that EU companies will magically grow new revenue streams, they are taking away those revenue streams (regarding EU customers) for all companies, EU and foreign. This seems like what the regulators are actually expect to happen, and from what I've seeing in the internal activities of local businesses, it's going to happen - pretty much everyone here has major ongoing IT projects that will reduce the amount of private data that they are gathering and storing. That is the ePrivacy version of the crosswalk - stop gathering private data about users, anonymize/cleanse the data you already have, and do your advertising in a more coarse-grained manner.