3 ms·
“Well-paid middle managers with no design skills take far too long to produce ugly slides that nobody wants to look at. They also file their own expenses, book
by prepend 9y ago
“Well-paid middle managers with no design skills take far too long to produce ugly slides that nobody wants to look at. They also file their own expenses, book their own travel and, for that matter, do their own shopping in the supermarket. On a bill-by-the-minute basis none of this makes sense.”
I work in an organization that still has a lot of admin assistants and I hear this all the time. That highly paid people should do stuff requiring high pay and not menial tasks. Of course, I get rather upset by the delegation of work to people they think are worthy of rote tasks, but let’s leave that aside and focus on efficiency.
The tasks mentioned above are menial but information needed for them to be completed. If done properly, it takes more time to explain your expenses to an assistant than to just scan them in and file. Same for travel, printing, PowerPoint editing, etc. Having a specialist for these everyday tasks results in more time and money spent, not less.
Almost every day I witness a 10 minute conversation explaining exactly how many printouts, format, binding, etc because someone doesn’t know how to use the print dialog. Or having someone fill out a travel report that is then manually entered into a travel expense system with a few round trips to ask questions.
Probably 1% of presentations require a professional designer and information spinner. The 99% will be fine with the person who has the information taking a few hours of PowerPoint training from Tufte and the audience living with not seeing a TED talk. Typically the purpose is small group information or pursuasian and having some engineer spend a day with a designer to remove/add clip art won’t improve the presentation.
I usually hear these arguments from people with large egos or people who don’t understand tech over the past twenty years. I don’t want to assume anything about the author, but they didn’t really cover any of these typical scenarios.
Also, leaving out the passive productivity gains of Microsoft Office of wasting 5% of $100k salary person’s time instead of wasting 100% of a $25k secretary’s time.
Also, how is this not a problem for LibreOffice? Or Google Docs? Or any other office app?