6 ms·
> “Plants are not just robotic, stimulus-response devices,” said Frantisek Baluska I don't see how this follows from the finding that sedatives can prevent pla
by taneq 9y ago
> “Plants are not just robotic, stimulus-response devices,” said Frantisek Baluska
I don't see how this follows from the finding that sedatives can prevent plants from responding to stimuli. It just means that there's a shared mechanism behind plants' responses and animals' responses, which wouldn't be overly surprising.
Of course, that doesn't mean that plants don't have a lot more going on than we usually realise, just because it happens at timescales so much longer than ours. There's all sorts of cool stuff happening in rainforests with cooperation/competition between plants.
- gowld 9y agoThe correct statement is "Plants are less [more like robotic, stimulus-response devices than people are] than previously assumed."
- omeid2 9y agoThe hard question is, how large is the spectrum between Robotic and Conscious and at which point it is reasonable to suspect Consciousness?
- pharrington 9y agoSpectrum? Between? The hard thing is to be less reliant your assumptions and start figuring out what to start measuring. edit: s/ditch/be less reliant on/ edit2: even that's not quite right; the derivative I'm reaching for is first testing the validity of your assumptions
- Franciscouzo 9y agoFor all I care humans are "just robotic, stimulus-response devices".
- make3 9y agoI mean I also have a physicalist materialist view of the world but that's exaggeratedly simple
- serf 9y ago> that's exaggeratedly simple it's simple, but I don't think that it's exaggerated. If anything I think it just speaks to the hidden power and complexity that can arise from following simple rule-sets. Although not typically used to describe such (internal) behavior, the text-book definition of 'stimulus' is just "a thing or event that evokes a specific functional reaction in an organ or tissue." -- If one were to consider that definition, 'stimulus' would also include everything your brain does; along with introspection, prediction, and everything we include as 'consciousness', and not just external forces that evoke an internal response (like sound,smell, light, touch, taste, etc.).
- askmike 9y agoIf you take that stance you also say there is no such thing as free will, since all your actions are some kind of response from the environment. Not saying that that means you're wrong.
- alexmat 9y agoYou can still experience "free will" without invalidating the materialist point of view: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self_model
- jamesrcole 9y ago> You can still experience "free will" if you have to put quotes around it, is it really free will? I had a look at that link and I don't see anything related to free will there... what's the link you're suggesting?
- alexmat 9y ago
- red75prime 9y agoWhile it's correct, it hides peculiarities of humans' stimulus processing.
- nezzle 9y agoYet this is the same type of work people are using to argue that that crabs/fish can feel/experience pain. Proving or disproving consciousness is basically impossible. E.g. I feel like a lot of people aren't conscious :) Prove me right or wrong?
- knodi123 9y agoI know where I came from — but where did all you zombies come from?
- hux_ 9y agoSo would you allow me to chop up someone you have decided is unconscious? If the answer is no, why?
- nezzle 9y agoI shared the impossibility of making such a decision with any degree of certainty. But we have to eat. I'm no longer sure what's more ethical: eating something dead meat or vegetables that are still alive.
- akvadrako 9y agoThe best explanation demystifying consciousness I've found comes from a claim it's a social phenomena that only arose around 3000 years ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology) These days most people are conscious because you need it to function in society; there is a good deal of evidence in the book.
- fsloth 9y ago"It is one of those books that is either complete rubbish or a work of consummate genius, nothing in between! Probably the former, but I'm hedging my bets." - Richard Dawkins
- pavel_lishin 9y agoI wonder how you'd spot a Bicameral person in modern society.
- jamesrcole 9y agoI'd add that "robotic" is, in most uses of the term, extremely vague. In those uses, it doesn't have a clear meaning, it's just a term for referring to things that appear like how present-day automated machinery appears to us. It's like people who think "computer" means something that appears like the kinds of silicon-based computers we engineer at present, rather than understanding it in terms of the rigorous notion of computation, as something that can perform computation (which can be performed in such widely varying ways, in so many different media)
- colanderman 9y agoMoreover, I can have say, my limbs anesthetized, yet remain conscious. I can also be unconscious (sleeping) yet respond to stimuli. The author of the article seems to assume that loss of responsiveness implies a consciousness which is lost, which is frankly a bizarrely incorrect inference.
- msarchet 9y agoIt reads to me as: Here is a list of examples of things that plants do that would imply some kind of decision making process. When we anesthetize them they lose those abilities, is that something that tells us they have consciousness. Secondarily, one can make the argument that due to the fact that you have a nervous system in your arm and your brain loses the signals from that system, in some way you have lost part of your consciousness when you are anesthetized. Since at it's core consciousness is just an awareness of what is happening to you. Thirdly, whose to say if plants are conscious that their roots don't function in some way as their brain.
- colanderman 9y agoMy understanding of the traditional definition of consciousness is explicitly not the simple stimulus/response you imply it is, but rather, meta-awareness or control over the stimulus/response system. That is, I am conscious of my arm if and only if I am aware of the stimulus/response process taking place (or not, as it were). Whereas, there are plenty of processes in the body of which one is not typically conscious (e.g. heartbeat, digestion, anything occuring during sleep or coma). To claim that you suffer partial loss of consciousness when your arm is anesthetized implies that when asleep, you are not fully unconscious, because your arm still responds to stimuli. This is contrary to almost every definition of consciousness I've heard, and sounds more like a definition of responsiveness. The model of plants wherein all stimuli/response processes are unconscious I claim is not invalidated by the experiment in the article.