3 ms·
Any reading of Tufte's claims about the Challenger launch decision should be accompanied by reading this article, one of whose authors is Roger Boisjoly, one of
by pdonis 9y ago
Any reading of Tufte's claims about the Challenger launch decision should be accompanied by reading this article, one of whose authors is Roger Boisjoly, one of the Thiokol engineers who recommended against the launch:
https://people.rit.edu/wlrgsh/FINRobison.pdf https://people.rit.edu/wlrgsh/FINRobison.pdf
tl/dr: Tufte's analysis itself exemplifies the charge Tufte makes. Tufte presents the wrong information about the way the decision was made, in the wrong way, and that is what drives his conclusions. When the right information is presented in the right way, it is clear that the Thiokol engineers did everything they possibly could, and that it was indeed a case of management overruling good recommendations by engineers.
The article also gives very important background information: Thiokol had previously recommended grounding the Shuttle until issues with the O-rings that had surfaced on previous flights could be understood. NASA refused. So during the discussion the night before the Challenger launch, Thiokol could not make a number of arguments that would have seemed simpler and easier, taken in isolation--because they had already made those arguments and had them rejected.
- gknoy 9y agoOh, wow, thank you for sharing that!