3 ms·
Agree that the data itself doesn't really support the implicit policy recommendation of encouraging startups rather than established companies, but the basic fi
by notahacker 16y ago
Agree that the data itself doesn't really support the implicit policy recommendation of encouraging startups rather than established companies, but the basic finding that firms in their first year account for ten times the gross new jobs created by firms in any subsequent year and thus after a year companies on average lay off more staff than they hire is pretty interesting.
It would be much more interesting to see what the stats looked like excluding firms that fail in a given year (ie. how many net jobs do firms that survive into year five create in their fourth year)
- cperciva 16y agoIt would be much more interesting to see what the stats looked like excluding firms that fail in a given year (ie. how many net jobs do firms that survive into year five create in their fourth year) I downloaded the BDS data from the US census website and arbitrarily picked companies which were age 0 in 2000 to look at. Of the 486k "establishments" (approximately equal to companies), roughly 50% survived 5 years. These 486k establishments created 3.1M jobs in 2000, and 1.6M jobs -- roughly 50% -- were lost over the following 5 years due to establishments closing, for a net gain of 1.5M jobs. Meanwhile, 2.4M jobs were created over years 1-5 while 1.7M were lost (at establishments which did not close), for a net gain of 0.7M jobs. Over a 5 year timescale, it seems to me that startups (in the general sense of "new companies") outperform existing companies in job creation by a 2:1 ratio -- still impressive, but also rather more credible than the article's claim.
- c1sc0 16y agoThis is why I love hacker news! Thanks for crunching the numbers!