8 ms·
What Is Going to Happen With Whois?
- f2n 9y agoThank god. I get somewhere between 2 and 10 spam emails to my dedicated whois address every day. Requiring the publication of email addresses with every domain is absurd and serves no purpose.
- wolco 9y agoIt made sense in the beginning.
- f2n 9y agoYes, but it hasn't made sense in a long time
- petercooper 9y agoI don't get so much spam mail as I do phone calls - quite often from real call centers with real people asking about what sites they could create for me on the domains. I have been very tempted to register an ultra offensive sounding domain name just to get someone at a call center to ask me about it by name :-D
- f2n 9y agoInteresting. I have a DID that routes to nowhere on all my domain's whois, maybe I should route it somewhere and see what happens.
- icebraining 9y agoI know where you should route it to.. https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/ https://www.reddit.com/r/itslenny/
- f2n 9y agoMeh, I prefer something I can operate/monitor. The guy who runs that is very secretive about all of his setup, to "prevent abuse" (unclear what sort of abuse he's afraid of), but highly opposed to others building their own.
- icebraining 9y agoFair enough, I didn't necessarily mean that server. It's true that he's secretive about his setup, but I wouldn't say he's highly opposed to others, after all he's the mod of the subreddit and yet people can freely discuss how to setup their own.
- ams6110 9y agoI own a handful of domains and have my real contact info in all of them. Aside from annual postal (!) mail from registrars offering to renew them at about 10x the normal price, I don't really get any spam from these that I've seen. I never answer the phone if the caller ID is unknown, so I may be missing some there also.
- bowlich 9y agoYeah, I was going to chime in. I've had an accurate whois for my domains since the early 2000s and at most I get a couple pieces of junk mail around renewal time. No idea if I get any spam from it, the spam filter seems to do a good enough job of junking that. The idea of hiding the contact information never quite made sense to me. If you're a business, then you already have to provide an address of record to the state for certified mail to go to. If, as a private citizen, I am running a controversial website then there are already institutes in place that will receive, process, and provide anonymity for your physical mailing address.
- pharrington 9y agoYeah. My anecdote about this is that I've used completely fake info to register at least 1 domain name with an EU TLD with EU registrars that supposedly required residency or some physical presence in the associated countries, with no repercussions. At least regarding whois info, this new law seems consistent with actual usage patterns without enabling more harm.
- terrantech 9y agoI get something like 100 spam emails, and half a dozen spam SMSes every single day, then 2-5 phone calls a week. That's just from a couple of domains where I hadn't noticed PrivacyGuard had lapsed. The emails can be blocked easily, but the SMSes don't come from a number, they just have a random word in the "From" field and they use a random one each time, meaning blocking the "sender" is useless. They also come at all sorts of hours, so I can get 2-3 SMSes at 4am advertising Amazon crap, or other affiliate spam. Spam seems to be getting worse and worse, despite all the efforts to combat it.
- dawhizkid 9y agoYes, I accidentally exposed my personal info for a new .us domain. Spam emails and phone calls immediately.
- parfe 9y agoI had the same issue. Didn't realize .us required your info to be published. My registrar upsold me their whois guard service, but it sat unredeemedable on my account while spammers harvested my info.
- jchw 9y agoHow does this threaten the security or privacy of the Internet _at all_? Whois data isn't accurate even by horrible standards. They've tried to make it more stringent but I have domains of mine with the wrong address that I'm too lazy to update and it's been wrong for years now. No problem for my Whois records. And to get around whois records, if we as owners of domains want privacy, we have to deal with shady companies that effectively take control of our domain's ownership. Great for selling whois privacy products, but not at all good for internet security. SSL certificates already aren't good enough to prove the legitimacy of an organization, not even EV ones. Why Whois data would be any use is beyond me.
- jstarfish 9y agoI find whois data less useful every day. 90% of the time when I'm researching suspicious domains, it maps back to one of those shady companies, and the malware author hiding behind it doesn't care about handing over ownership of his disposable DGA domains to said shady company. Even legit sites are starting to hide whois data behind privacy proxies. Hijacked sites only ever map back to a victim, not the perpetrator. As part of my investigative workflow it's largely a waste of time to whois anything. It seems to only benefit domain squatters and spammers.
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> if we as owners of domains want privacy, we have to deal with shady companies that effectively take control of our domain's ownership. Some domain name providers, such as Gandi, offer privacy of address, phone, and email data while leaving your name as the owner of record.
- jchw 9y agoI do use Gandi and trust them, but I'm not sure if this is 100% possible. Gandi still has limitations that largely depend on TLDs.
- newscracker 9y agoI use only NearlyFreeSpeech.net (a web host that also provides domain registration), and its planning to do domains by itself sometime in the future. I like its no nonsense and practical policies.
- fredley 9y agoFor .uk domains currently, you cannot mask whois details at all!
- petercooper 9y agoYou can under the right circumstances. For example, on my name's .co.uk, it says: The registrant is a non-trading individual who has opted to have their address omitted from the WHOIS service. For companies and organizations though, yeah, they have to be public, but I think that's fair enough.
- tradersam 9y agoNor .io domains.
- deckard1 9y agoMaybe it's just the service you use? My .io has masked whois.
- f2n 9y agoMy .io (finn.io if you want to look it up) says: Owner Addr : Obfuscated whois Gandi-63-65 boulevard Massena Owner Addr : Obfuscated whois Gandi-Paris Owner Addr : WA Owner Addr : FR and my full name. Seems obfuscated enough, especially since the name was not remotely validated.
- shripadk 9y agoI am using Namecheap and it masks .io domains using Whoisguard.
- mr_toad 9y agoWhois belongs in an era where email servers were completely open, telnet and FTP were unencrypted, and people had .plan files for all the world to see. It should have died off 20 years ago.
- shiado 9y agoWhen investigating sketchy sites I have found that domains are pretty disposable and that trying to contact the admin or registrar from the whois data is pointless. They can just pivot to another domain at worst and they probably faked the data they submitted to register it to begin with leaving them unaccountable. Services like Cloudflare on the other hand are fully complicit in making abuse easy on the internet. If you want something abusive taken offline it is better to go after whoever is hosting it instead of some pointer to where it is hosted, which is difficult when they are behind Cloudflare. If you want a laugh search Google for the terms "booter" or "http stress tester" and try to gauge the legitimacy of the results.
- ficklepickle 9y agoI've always appreciated that .ca domains are private by default. Even without whois, you can dig the IP address and find out their ISP (sometimes). I've had some success getting compromised servers shut down by reporting them to the abuse email address in the dig record. If you email amazon with the details of malicious AWS instance, they will notify the customer and/or kill the instance pretty darn quickly. Does anyone know of an open source program that finds malicious IP's in apache / nginx logs and reports them automatically? I've been thinking of making this tool but it must exist already. In my head, I call it the internet hygiene project. It's a slow and very unsexy way of dealing with the botnet problem, but I think it could make a positive difference. Admittedly, it'll only catch the low hanging fruit, but there is so much of it, I think it is a good start. Apologies for going off-topic.
- ryan-c 9y agoI applied for "port 43" access to GoDaddy's normal whois records (still "domains by proxy" if private registration) this week. They require you to sign a very short contract stating what you're using it for and stipulating you can't bulk scrape it or use it for marketing. Still waiting on approval, am somewhat interested to see whether they approve my request. As far as spam goes, I don't generally use private registration, but use dedicated email addresses for my whois contacts, and I rotate them on a regular basis. The scraping seems to happen soon after a domain is registered, but there's a much longer lag when changing the email address.
- contingencies 9y agoMost recently I have found whois a good way to validate the age of domains of certain competing companies. This is a very vague thing to look up but it sure is useful, I am sure that it also adds a dimension to trust metrics in search engine and antispam land. I don't want it to die.
- ggm 9y agoRDAP is going to happen. 1) its UTF-8 clean 2) its JSON 3) its getting Oauth, so LEA requirements can be met while keeping personal data private 4) it uses web protocol underneath so 302 redirect works 5) its fully deployed in the RIR system for numbers, and has a global directory at the root in IANA. RDAP is going to happen to WHOIS. Its long overdue. (bias: I work on RDAP)
- Sniffnoy 9y agoNon-mobile link: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vbpgga/whois-gdpr-europe-icann-registrar https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vbpgga/whois-gdpr...
- bane 9y agoOn the other side of this, I remember a time when you could just download a dump of the registration data and do whatever you wanted (good or bad). Now it's like pulling an arm and a leg to get access to even fractions of the data.
- exikyut 9y agoSerious question: Some months ago I was curious about buying a domain name. So I poked around on various reseller sites to find out the pricing. I couldn't buy it at the time. Only a couple months later (I still couldn't buy the domain), I found the site had been registered. The domain was an obscure but novel sequence of letters; the likelihood that I and someone else came up with the sequence at the same time is objectively possible, but slim. So, I can only conclude that list reselling DEFINITELY DOES happen, and yes, I am very mad. But there is of course nothing that can be done. Now, when I want to find out what domains do and don't exist, I just use WHOIS, because I don't trust any of the "domain lookup" sites. What do I do now? :(
- featherverse 9y agoThis is bullshit. All they need to do is create means to prevent bulk scanning of whois databases. WHOIS information is absolutely vital to the proper operation of the internet. It has to be possible for _regular people_, not special boards or committees with super access, to be able to find the contact information for the owners of a domain name. This is a much bigger problem than anyone has really appreciated. Frankly I expect the worst, because none of the people debating the issue are "regular people", they're all special people with special access and privileges and clout. How are they going to represent the needs of every day internet users. WHOIS privacy works fine for non-organization consumers to protect their information from spammers. For organizations, spam is just part of their daily lives and it's not a legitimate reason to break the entire domain structure. What is really going on here is registrars want to force you to use their brokerage agencies whenever you want to purchase a domain name that's already owned but not being used. The domain name system is a racket, it's been a racket for decades, and if we don't fight them it will continue to be and will become more of a racket.