4 ms·
Stealing from Self-Checkouts
- jgh 9y agoI guess I'm type B for boring because I pay for everything at the self checkout.
- nickstinemates 9y agoHonestly the thought never even crossed my mind
- js2 9y ago> When Voucher Codes Pro, a company that offers coupons to internet shoppers, surveyed 2,634 people, nearly 20 percent admitted to having stolen at the self-checkout in the past. I weep for humanity. But there's no way the grocery stores would tolerate that level of theft. There's obviously strong correlation between people who steal and people who respond to Voucher Codes Pro surveys.
- Fogest 9y agoYes, people who are using a voucher based site sound like they probably are already on the hunt for deals. I am not surprised that the numbers would be inflated for stealing if it gives them a better deal as well with little risk.
- saurik 9y agoFWIW, the local supermarket near where I live decided to get rid of their self checkout, and I heard it was due to theft (and I do not live in a neighborhood where I would have thought theft would be an extra-serious problem...).
- mturmon 9y agoIt could be that supermarket margins are very thin (perhaps 2%), so appreciable extra shrinkage can tip you over into the red.
- pasbesoin 9y agoIn the my major metropolitan area, a major grocery chain is in the course of eliminating self-checkout. They don't broadcast why, publicly, but knowing some of the staff and management, at a couple of the stores, I and another family member have both heard that it's "shrinkage". Just as well, as far as I'm concerned. They are union jobs, and they have a mix of both permanent staff (with benefits including retirement benefits) and "starter" jobs for kids in high school or putting themselves through college. All things our communities need. P.S. Yes, "union". I don't see anyone slacking off. And I know the union's gone for to bat for one quite decent fellow I know, when a new middle manager tried to jerk him around.
- jstarfish 9y agoDon't know about your specific situation, but in my past experience and positions, even if your store is in a "nice" area it isn't insulated from coordinated mobile shoplifting rings operating from the "not-so-nice" areas. I got out when self-checkout was just becoming a thing but even in those early days, the lack of accountability was already being taken advantage of by means of all the very scams listed in the article.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoThis number is meaningless without context. I've stolen from supermarkets - because I'll occasionally run low on space in my basket, and I'll stick an orange or something in my pocket, and forget to check out with it. A grocery store would very easily tolerate 20% of their customers doing that once a year.
- lerie82 9y agoI guess, surprisingly, I'm the good guy for actually paying for my things. Wonder how many small businesses go under because of this kind of theft.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoYou'd have to be an idiot to do that in this day and age of ubiquitous video surveillance and smart machine visual perception.
- mlevental 9y agoyou drastically overestimate the value of catching a couple of people stealing a couple of things vs implementing the system that catches them using video surveillance and cv
- AlexCoventry 9y agoStatute of limitations for larceny in Massachusetts is 6 years. Would you really want to bet that it'll still be that hard in 2024?
- extra88 9y agoRight, like CVS is going to keep all their surveillance video for over six years.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoHmm, I can't think of any reason a chain store would want to keep customer behavior data around...
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoThat wouldn't suprise me, considering the amount of other information they legally must keep on hand for some years on-site and then years in mass storage. (former CVS employee). Some of a pharmacy's surveillance would be kept just for instances of robbery and prescription fraud. The last one isn't always known upfront. There is also the issue of employee theft.
- jstarfish 9y agoEven with video evidence and some theoretical fancy algorithm divining your name from your face and Facebook page, stores aren't always inclined to prosecute unless you're a serial offender or a big fish. The article touches on this. The exact policy varies by store, corporate overlord and the cooperation of the local government. Litigating costs money so for minor cases they'll often try to defer prosecution in favor of other (sometimes terribly unethical) means of resolution. Signed confessions, bans from store, direct restitution, etc. To put it in perspective, I once had a guy return a PSP paid for with a credit card. Inside the box was a brick-- the red masonic kind, not the result of a botched firmware transplant (the cashier neglected to check the contents before accepting the return). We had his name, we had his credit card number and we had his face on camera. We didn't pursue it, so the scammer got away unscathed...but the cashier lost her job. Justice in action!
- DoreenMichele 9y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16292254 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16292254
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoSo, given that the article didn't cite which subreddit, which reddit group made those comments?
- syncsynchalt 9y agoProbably /r/shoplifting or /r/stealing .
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoYeah, I finally found the post by searching the body text. Just crazy on /r/shoplifting - people bragging all the time about their "scores". They don't know that their profiles are pretty readily accessible via snoopsnoo.com , Im guessing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wwweston 9y ago>There is NO MORAL ISSUE with stealing from a store that forces you to use self checkout, period. THEY ARE CHARGING YOU TO WORK AT THEIR STORE.” So, here's the link to that particular reddit gem, in case you want to read it in all its glory: https://www.reddit.com/r/Shoplifting/comments/56saoh/selfcheckout_stealing/daqte1q/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Shoplifting/comments/56saoh/selfche... I'm... almost sympathetic to an argument that amounts to the frustrating/dark side of automated assistance, which is probably something the audience here would do well to consider. I get frustrated with tech too and sometimes want a way around it. But I wish that discussion was still active so I could reply... WTF, man. They're offering an automated way to complete a purchase, and it's not like you got paid to interact with the checkout cashier before. But let's say you see it that way. Let's assume that cashier was costing the store $25/hr (maybe), so the 6 minutes (maybe) they worked on your purchase might be worth up to $2.50. Are you scrupulously making sure you only evened the score/took the store to the tune of ten quarters? Unless you can't for some reason, pay for your groceries, don't inflate the prices everyone else has to pay to offset the cost of "external shrinkage," and keep society in the crucial resource of trust.
- albertgoeswoof 9y ago25 usd / hour? More like 10 usd, at least in the UK
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y ago2.5x salary is a reasonable estimate of the cost of an employee. So $25/hr isn't that high for a total cost. Probably high for the US, it depends on the store, and an $8/hr job would result in lower end costs especially for part-timers without benefits (health insurance).
- extra88 9y ago“Fringe” rate in the organization I’m in is less than 50% so 150% for a cashier is a stretch. To figure the cost that high you’d have to add some things like some fraction of their supervisor’s pay (which would be unfair because they’d have to be there anyway).
- ggm 9y agoI'm probably not the target audience. I queue up to use a checker. I like talking to them as they squeeze my Charmian and if they get paid to swipe things past barcodes while studying before university class we're all winning. Self checkout is slower for more than two or three things and th conversation is bad. FELLOW ROBOT GOOD DAY HOW IS YOUR IBN PRODUCT CODE LASER MINE IS RED
- CM30 9y agoI'm much the same way, though I think another reason behind preferring the human checkers is the fact most self checkout machines are horrible in terms of usability. Oh no, you removed an item from the bagging area! Time to shut down the whole machine until some staff member comes over and unlocks it again! Why? Who in their right mind thought this was a good design decision? It doesn't stop theft, it doesn't stop scams, it doesn't do anything other than infuriate legitimate customers at seemingly random. Or in another example, trying to find the item you're buying if it's not a standard product with a bar code on the bottom. If the shop has a bakery or meat counter or whatever, that usually means lots of scrolling through pages trying to find the item you bought while hoping you can remember what the name of the damn thing was on the shelf in case two items look almost identical. Or in case you can't make out certain details on a tiny icon properly. A human cashier can usually sort this stuff out much quicker than a customer using a self service machine could.
- racer-v 9y agoThere's one thing that prevents me from using self-checkouts: they have an annoying synthesized voice that says things like "place your items in the bag" or "please insert cash". I'm opposed on principle to voice interfaces that can't be muted, and machines telling me what to do. So far my best experience was with a checkout that let me change the language, so at least I couldn't understand it.
- wlesieutre 9y agoUnexpected item in the bagging area
- jonnycomputer 9y agoA trustless society is no society at all.
- rdtsc 9y agoSomeone I know was working at a grocery story when they were introducing self-checkout. The store did an internal test and they asked employees to try to steal using self-checkout. It was incredibly easy to do. However they went with it anyway. The idea was that people were honest and overall it was still an improvement. However one thing that's different now compared to 15 years ago is there are online communities where those who are dishonest can share tips and tricks. Someone already mentioned but this exists: https://www.reddit.com/r/Shoplifting/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Shoplifting/ --- If you're here to preach morals, enjoy your very brief stay. If you're here to learn and share, please help contribute to our wonderful community ... ---
- DoofusOfDeath 9y ago> If you're here to preach morals, enjoy your very brief stay. If you're here to learn and share, please help contribute to our wonderful community ... I'm not sure, but it seems like you're implying that preaching morals cannot be a contribution to your community. If so, I think it raises some interesting issues about community and morality.
- rdtsc 9y agoExactly it just seems like a strange sub doesn't it. Even has nice mascot - the cute Reddit alien with a mask on. Are there subs for other crimes like medical malpractice, robbery? What about more serious ones say rape or contract killing. I am sure assassins would "benefit" from sharing tips and tricks of the trade. At first I thought, oh maybe these are people who are hungry and have to feed their family so they are stealing an extra bag of rice or potatoes. But I see them bragging about electronics, media, expensive clothes. The one that caught my attention is bragging about stealing thousands a month from Whole Foods. They justify it by saying Whole Foods treats their employees badly.