4 ms·
I mean, you're right that people get less medical care if their out-of-pocket costs are higher. The problem is they're really poor at judging for themselves wh
by emodendroket 9y ago
I mean, you're right that people get less medical care if their out-of-pocket costs are higher. The problem is they're really poor at judging for themselves whether procedures are necessary and so they end up sacrificing their health or sometimes outright dying because they didn't get care they needed. "Skin in the game" is one of those zombie ideas that just don't die.
- pdonis 9y ago> "Skin in the game" is one of those zombie ideas that just don't die. No, the idea that people who have no skin in the game--regulators and bureaucrats--can make better decisions than the people directly involved, particularly about matters with as much at stake as health care--is one of those zombie ideas that just don't die. No regulator or bucreaucrat ever suffers any negative consequences because of bad decisions about other people's health care. As for people being poor at judging for themselves whether procedures are necessary, another comment upthread already addressed that: there are plenty of other areas (auto repair, for example) where most people don't have the technical knowledge to judge for themselves whether procedures are necessary, yet markets seem to function in those areas. Furthermore, under the current system in the US, people have little incentive to become more knowledgeable, because they are not going to be given a choice anyway; they're going to get whatever their health insurance provider says is the standard care. Under a market system, people would have much more of an incentive to actually learn about the various options. And there would also be much more of an incentive for independent third parties to provide information, particularly information that health care providers might not want people to know. More generally, the reason market advocates, like me, advocate markets is not that they always give optimal outcomes. They don't. But in cases where they don't, non-market alternatives give outcomes that are even worse.
- tomkarlo 9y agoAnd yet the data shows that when you leave the decision to regulators and bureaucrats, you seem to get better value for the healthcare dollar than if you let individuals make their own decisions. The US, in particular, spends more and sees worse outcomes than other counties. This shouldn't be a surprise. An individual is going to not make very good decisions about how healthcare dollars are allocated over the course of their life. They're going to usually tend to underspend on preventative care (which has the highest ROI) and tend to overspend on end-of-life care (which has a lower ROI). You can see this played out in things like the US's infant mortality rate (3X other developed nations) and life expectancy (31st worldwide, declining).
- pdonis 9y ago> The US, in particular, spends more and sees worse outcomes than other counties. I think this "conclusion" depends strongly on how you define "worse outcomes". > An individual is going to not make very good decisions about how healthcare dollars are allocated over the course of their life. Not if they have no incentive to learn how, no. And our current system gives them no such incentive, since they don't control the dollars to begin with. In other words, the system complains that people don't do something that the system prevents them from doing.
- tomkarlo 9y agoIt's not very hard to define "worse outcomes"... the US trails other developed nations in just about every wide-reaching healthcare metric at this point. If you have counter-examples, feel free to raise them. > In other words, the system complains that people don't do something that the system prevents them from doing. Uh, this has nothing to do with the system, and mostly everything to do with behavioral economics and risk pooling. People are poor at investing in preventative care, because the benefit is extremely hard to perceive at the individual level. And they over-invest in end of life care, because, well, they don't want to die. That's not the result of "the system", that's human nature. Attempting to build a healthcare system on how we "should" act instead of how we actually do isn't a plan.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn addition, the "market-based" proposals to address this problem mostly exacerbate it. The suggestion is always that patients need more "skin in the game" -- in other words, that they need to be responsible for even more costs out-of-pocket -- and yet it's completely predictable that fewer people are going to seek preventative care if they have trouble paying for medicine now. This also ends up being a pretty unfair way to apportion care because a rich man couldn't care less about a $100 fee and a poor man can find it prohibitive.
- s_kilk 9y ago> I think this "conclusion" depends strongly on how you define "worse outcomes". One example would be how the US has one of the worst infant mortality rates in the developed world.
- emodendroket 9y ago"Regulators and bureaucrats" deny people healthcare now; they just work for profit-seeking entities rather than being public servants at least nominally committed to the public good. The example of an automobile doesn't seem apt. Are you going to trade in Grandma for a new one when the treatments prescribed get too expensive and they can't figure out what's wrong with her?
- uberduber 9y agoI think pharmacists would disagree with you about "skin in the game." People with high deductible plans or no insurance who are forced to pay large amounts of money for their drugs are more compliant. Those who get $500 drugs with a $5 copay often don't take them and then will lie about not taking them wasting everyone's time.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean, without a doubt it reduces utilization. I just don't see the trade-off of people foregoing preventative care and the like as worth it.