3 ms·
>So we ban child porn to try to curb the production of more of it. Its production is what is harmful, We also ban computer generated child porn even though the
by slg 9y ago
>So we ban child porn to try to curb the production of more of it. Its production is what is harmful,
We also ban computer generated child porn even though there is no victim involved in the production of that. If you use this deepfake technology and stick an 18 year old's face on a porn video it is legal but if you do the same thing with a 17 year old it isn't. The production of those two videos is the same. The only difference is the potential victim if the video became public.
>The real way to reduce this risk is to either spread the idea that all video is suspect, and you can't assume who you see on video is who it appears to be, or to perfect technology that can instantly detect when this system has been used.
That sounds great in theory, but people don't work like that. We are built to believe what we see. We all know that almost every magazine cover has been mercilessly Photoshopped and yet the images on those covers have still been shown to have a strong influence on people's own body image.
- kuschku 9y ago> If you use this deepfake technology and stick an 18 year old's face on a porn video it is legal but if you do the same thing with a 17 year old it isn't. The production of those two videos is the same. The only difference is the potential victim For reference, artificially created child porn (e.g. in mangas, or in other ways created) is in a legal grey zone in many areas, including Japan and Germany. It is absolutely illegal in other, e.g. Sweden.
- jstarfish 9y ago> For reference, artificially created child porn (e.g. in mangas, or in other ways created) is in a legal grey zone in many areas, No. The grayness only applies to non-photorealistic works. Once you start making photorealistic deepfakes or diptychs, where the end result appears to be photographic, the color becomes much more black and white the world over.
- kuschku 9y agoIn some jurisdictions the grayness also applies to the "victimless crime" part, because no person was harmed during creation of the video. But yes, it's a much more complex legal case.
- TomMarius 9y ago> We also ban computer generated child porn even though there is no victim involved in the production of that. Many places don't do that.