5 ms·
I understand the narrative, its the 'tiger outside the village'or the 'wolf in the forest' sort of tale that there is this "bad thing" that will randomly attack
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I understand the narrative, its the 'tiger outside the village'or the 'wolf in the forest' sort of tale that there is this "bad thing" that will randomly attack/kill/impoverish people that collectively we could eliminate if we just had the will, as a community, to do so. And I don't disagree, we could overcome the badness if we had the will.
Where I part company with the narrative is over looking how we have structurally made the 'collective' so large as to prevent such a decision to be taken.
I expect that if you were to poll San Francisco you would find overwhelming support for a single payer, 'state' (and by that I'm using the notion of the collective government not the state of California) administered health care system for residents. No doubt it would be paid for by taxing some of the wealthiest residents or as part of some sort of rent/property taxation plan.
You might even be able to get this passed (agreed to) for the entire state of California.
However, country wide consensus on the issue is elusive and often divisive.
The saying goes that "all politics are local" and to a large extent that is true. But I wonder why it is that the state of California was progressive enough to legalize marijuana but can't get something like this done? The current punch line is "This isn't a problem in North America if you are Canadian."[1] so why is that the case in California? We've got the largest state economy in the US, we've got the largest population base, and we're bigger than France[2]. So what is the hangup with just showing the rest of the country how things 'should' be done rather than complain about how things are being done 'wrong' ?
[1] And yes I know there are plenty of complaints about the system there as well, it is still better than what you get south of the border.
[2] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/american-state-bigger-economy-than-india/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/american-state-bigger...
- danans 9y ago> But I wonder why it is that the state of California was progressive enough to legalize marijuana but can't get something like this done? The current punch line is "This isn't a problem in North America if you are Canadian."[1] so why is that the case in California? We'll see. Ironically, and optimistically, the attack on the ACA at the federal level might push California voters towards supporting universal health coverage. But marijuana is a different issue than healthcare, because in order to legalize it, you don't need to tax the haves more. It's only opposed by social conservatives, who are not a huge contingent in CA. Universal coverage in CA, however, would need to involve some form of redistribution downwards (just like the ACA did), and many Californians aren't as progressive when it comes to that. You see this same phenomenon in NIMBY anti-development housing policies, and in the underinvestment in public education. The demographics of this tendency are strange, too. The older generation has a strong skew against progressive social policies, but sometimes young, well-to-do, and childless people are also opposed to more downward redistribution, because the things that some of the progressive policies affect (healthcare, education, etc), are a non issue for them (at least so far).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI think that captures it well.
- philipkglass 9y agoI think that single payer is a great plan for a country. I don't think that its cost-saving merits would be evident in a single-state experiment. If California alone offered single-payer health coverage I would expect it to become a magnet for people with expensive health problems from the other 49 states, who either currently pay a lot for medical care or go without medical care. The savings of a single-payer system for Californians could be swamped by the increased costs from people who become Californians out of medical desperation. And then every vested interest currently opposed to American single payer health service would say "see, we told you it's too expensive." Individual states could easily experiment with e.g. gay marriage or legalizing cannabis before the rest of the country, because the first has negligible revenue impact and the second actually enriches state coffers. But I don't think that you can run the same one-state experiment with single payer health care without incurring steep costs from medically desperate migrants from other states.
- sharemywin 9y agoThat's why California needs a wall!
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThis is a good counter argument, although as I see it there are assumptions here that are hard to test. You started with "I think that single payer is a great plan for a country. I don't think its cost-saving merits would be evident in a single-state experiment." I completely agree that the scale is an important part of how well one could evaluate the success. If you read reference #2 in my comment you saw that Calfornia's GDP is slightly larger than that of France, and France has a universal health care system[1]. My thought is that if it was good enough for an economy like France then California is a large enough test case. I could not make such a case for Wyoming for example. The argument that 'it would be a magnet, and all these high cost patients would move here' has intuitive appeal but I struggle with it. Here are my challenges with that sort of rebuttal, first I would like to understand better how France deals with the situation given that migration around the EU is fairly easy, and by some accounts France has the best health care, are they over burdened by the high cost cases flooding in? Also there are plenty of reasons to want to live in California but the high cost of living (excluding health care) has been a disincentive for many. As I see it, the set of people who would move to California, for the health care, would be that population who could otherwise afford the cost of living, or by covering their medical costs could now afford the cost of living. And I wonder how big a group that is relative to the overall existing population. I also assume that someone would rather live in a home and pay for health care than be homeless in California and get free health care. There is also the 'reverse' effect where people who are currently bankrupt/underwater and already live in California, becoming productive again after the burden of health care was removed. So what is the net change? There is also a big fuzzing effect on the healthcare debate which conflates the cost of providing medical services and the cost of insurance. I am convinced by the evidence of concierge doctors and all cash procedures that are significantly less expensive than the 'advertised' or 'billed' prices for procedures, that a form of capture has occurred whereby the medical services providers and the medical insurance providers are colluding (possibly inadvertently) to maximize those costs in order to maximize the transfer of money from patients/businesses into their possession. And while I recognize that state efforts to minimize that (a state insurance commissioner who oversees and regulates that capture) have not been as successful as I would like, I am not convinced that the problem isn't solvable. After all, places like France solved it for some definition of solved. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_France
- BookmarkSaver 9y agoSetting up single-payer in California would end up being unnaturally more expensive because of the tradeoff with some federal benefits. Also, in the current national political environment, there is very little chance that if implementation of such a plan were to actually go forward, that the federal government wouldn't start coming up with punitive measures (because fuck those rich elitist Hollywood liberals).
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Setting up single-payer in California would end up being unnaturally more expensive because of the tradeoff with some federal benefits. How so? Are you just referring to the overlap with Medicaid (a state benefit with federal standards) and Medicare? You'd need to get federal permission to do it, but you could conceivably formally do it by expanding Medi-Cal (the states Medicaid program) to cover the entire population, with those not eligible federally being an optional state-funded population (California already does that with some populations, but obviously not as broadly) and simultaneously make it (or a carve out within it) a Medicare Managed Care Plan (there are, again, Medi-Cal/Medicare joint managed care plans in the state already.) There'd be some administrstive and compliance costs for this, and some coverage and other mandated limiting (but not eliminating) flexibility particularly on the Medicare side. The Administration’s plan to block-grant Medicaid would, while it's likely to be horrible for CA financially in any case, both reduce the administrative burden and federal involvement here, and reduce the marginal cost of a single payer system. > Also, in the current national political environment, there is very little chance that if implementation of such a plan were to actually go forward, that the federal government wouldn't start coming up with punitive measures (because fuck those rich elitist Hollywood liberals). That's a valid concern, though even the pretense of a facially-neutrsl policy reason may be hard to come up with. OTOH, that assumes the political composition of the present federal government, with undivided Republican control, survived long enough to effect any single-payer program.