5 ms·
Two types of bacteria, Bacteroides fragilis and a strain of E. coli, can pierce a mucus shield that lines the colon and normally blocks invaders from entering
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Two types of bacteria, Bacteroides fragilis and a strain of E. coli, can pierce a mucus shield that lines the colon and normally blocks invaders from entering
The above text in the article contains a link to an abstract. The abstract does not talk about piercing the mucus lining. It talks about biofilm.
Biofilm is essentially a large colony of bacteria, so large it begins terraforming the body in order to create conditions conducive to self preservation. I have seen a number of articles over the years on how to successfully break up biofilm and thereby reverse antibiotic resistance. They generally boil down to finding some means to make the environment less acidic. There is generally a strong correlation between inflammation, acidity and infection.
This is probably not a simple relationship. The terraforming activities of biofilm suggests bacteria will foster acidity to promote inflammation etc. So the relationship is interactive. It is not as simple as "acidity causes antibiotic resistance".
I don't have these studies at my fingertips. I have no plans to try to dig them up. I am leaving the comment so that other people can look into that if they are interested.
I wasn't reading this stuff in order to support debate points in an online forum. I have a genetic disorder that predisposes me to developing antibiotic resistant infections and I was trying to suffer less.
So, you can take this comment as testimony that these studies exist and may have bearing on the topic of discussion here.
But I am not going to debate this with people who are inevitably monstrously disrespectful towards me and who act like the last 17 years of my life did not happen because I can't link you to a study. The reality is they don't get any less monstrously disrespectful when I do link to studies and supporting articles and explain my thinking etc. So I don't plan to play that game today.
TLDR: If you are interested, you might go looking up studies on how to break up biofilm. They do exist and they contain potentially useful clues to how to stop this kind of colonization of the gut by hostile invaders.
- epmaybe 9y agoI have always been taught that antibiotic resistance came from bacterial mutation. Are you suggesting that this biofilm is contributing to this resistance as well or instead of mutation?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMy dad fought in WW2. He used to tell this story: First, invaders would toss a grenade into a room, stunning all occupants, then promptly rush in and capture them at gun point. Then people began creating a safety zone in the corner with sand bags. When the grenade hit the floor, you dive for cover. After it goes off, you stand up with your weapon, getting the upper hand on the soldiers entering the room. Then they began tossing the grenade without pulling the pin. People dove for cover and waited for the grenade to go off. Meanwhile, you promptly enter and now you have the jump on them. So then people would hear the grenade hit the floor and look to see if the pin had been pulled before deciding how to react. When antibiotics were introduced, the world announced the end of disease. Now, we have antibiotic resistant super bugs. Antibiotic resistance is an arms race. It is probably not one dimensional. If infectious process were one dimensional, then the initial prediction that antibiotics heralded the ended of disease should have been accurate. But the only thing I am trying to suggest is that studies exist and people who are interested can look them up for themselves, read them and draw their own conclusions. I am sick to death of trying to discuss what I think about such things. It is never a positive experience.
- epmaybe 9y agoSorry that you haven't had a productive discussion with others regarding this. I just remembered that I have indeed heard about biofilms and their ability to prevent antibiotic activity. However, I have only heard about them in the context of secretions by specific kinda of bacteria (e.g. pseudomonas aeruginosa) that form this wall around foreign objects preventing the efficacy of antibiotics. It is why we have to change out certain catheters after a specified amount of time.
- Fomite 9y agoFor your interest: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12195733 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12195733 Biofilms do a number of things - they can help promote between-organism signaling that can promote the upregulation of resistance, they can physically protect from antibiotic penetration (one of many resistance mechanisms), and they can potentially change the behavior of the bacteria itself, which will have impacts on the antibiotic's efficacy (for example, bacteriostatic antibiotics are less of a problem if bacteria aren't proliferating anyway).
- abandonliberty 9y agoWow, what an incredibly defensive tone. You join a discussion, refuse to provide evidence, and pre-emptively accuse those who disagree with you of being monsters. Interesting. This is a very good community with few monsters, typically dealt with expediently by both the community and excellent moderators. I would expect someone who has been through this before to have some pretty good sources, but you share none. This indicates that they are weak and lacking or do not exist. You also share frustration at people not accepting your personal anecdote as data. This further reduces your credibility. You seek to poison the well and insult those with differing points of view, and refuse to engage in dialogue. Perhaps you'll find your monster in the mirror. As written your comment is both manipulative and lacking value. It's offensive and insulting to this community. I'm glad you found something that works for you. If you would give this community a chance you would find it very open minded if you approach it rationally. Hacks, like anecdotes, tend to be exceptions or new discoveries.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI have been here 8.5 years. The comment is informed by long experience, including a recent incident where multiple people chose to focus on my personal medical history, and not in a nice way, and utterly disregarded the actual point I was trying to make. Further, your comment is filled with personal swipes in violation of community guidelines. Edit: Here is a link to that incident so people can see for themselves: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16201406 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16201406
- abandonliberty 9y agoI'm curious, what do you see as a personal swipe?
- arkades 9y agoThis isn’t the first thread I’ve seen you pop up in making medical claims, some more credible and some less, but always wrapped in some measure of indignation and “this is my personal experience and you cannot discount it.” This is a forum for technically and scientifically inclined people. We like data. Your personal experience, regardless of what it may mean to you, isn’t data. You’re very welcome to share your thoughts and what evidence supports them, but you don’t get to shout your ideas out into a public discussion and damn people for having the “monstrousity” of questioning or criticizing. If you can’t tolerate questioning, you should probably host your own blog and keep the comments disabled.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYes, I recall you being one of the people derailing the discussion in the recent incident while ignoring my actual point. And now you are justifying your right to do that because "science." The only medical claim I am making here is that there are studies about biofilm that might interest people. I am tired of people feeling like it is open season on me because the reason I am aware of these studies is because of my health issues. That doesn't seem to be a standard applied to any other member. I am not remotely the only person here who has a serious medical condition and manages it with diet, lifestyle or alternative remedies. I am not trying to promote those remedies here. I do, in fact, have my own blog as an outlet for talking about that stuff elsewhere. That should not be reason to say I am not allowed to mention that studies exist and if I do someone is completely justified in attacking me or suggesting I am making stuff up about my medical situation. You are free to think I am completely deluded about my medical situation and imagined the whole thing. It has zero bearing on the fact that studies of biofilm exist and people can look them up if they are interested.
- arkades 9y ago> I am tired of people feeling like it is open season on me because the reason I am aware of these studies is because of my health issues. You keep making the threads about your personal health issues, and couch all your opinions in that context. No one is dragging it there but you.