4 ms·
I am pretty sure even in places with socialized medicine, they don't always pay for experimental treatments. Walter White had insurance in the show, but they re
by cortesoft 9y ago
I am pretty sure even in places with socialized medicine, they don't always pay for experimental treatments. Walter White had insurance in the show, but they refused to pay for an experimental treatment he wanted to get. That will always happen, and needs to happen, in any insurance system; we can't just pay for every quack treatment just because someone who is sick hopes that it would work.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoThe experimental treatment issue is more regarding how govt organizations like the FDA handle experimental protocols. One should be able to waive most of the red tape surrounding an untreatable illness to an established body, like a medical teaching university or similar. And in many cases, this could result in the worsening or death of the patient. Yet, this kind of protocol is definitely frowned upon. Unfortunately because of how hamfisted the FDA is, I would dare-say that more people die from not having access to experimental treatments. Instead, you have to go to $somewhere_else to get the requisite treatment. Some sources show that this is likely true, but would need further study. http://www.fdareview.org/05_harm.php http://www.fdareview.org/05_harm.php
- madengr 9y agoAll treatments are experimental, at the beginning. Very frustrating.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI have a good friend who is type 1 diabetic. Her 1 year term at a university elsewhere ran out, and obtained a job elsewhere. Both have insurance. But the insurance is the problem... Let me explain. Since she's T1, she takes insulin. There's different types of insulin. Fast acting, slow acting, and various compounds and mixtures of each. In her case, she was prescribed Humalog, and has taken it for the last few years. On Jan 1, at the start of her new job, the job offered a different insurance. Humalog was considered an "Uncovered drug". In other words, this maybe what the doctor prescribed, and what your body is used to - but the insurance company is the primary "doctor" that makes medical decisions above and beyond your PCP. She didn't have much choice. She went on an insulin that was "covered". The insurance said it was "virtually the same". Bullshit. She took too much the 3rd day and had to take the day off, while asking friends to check up on her. Diabetic comas and death are a thing. She's never had that happen before. (Her A1C stays around 5.1-5.2 , which is impressive for any diabetic.)
- dfraser992 9y agoI'm not going to argue with you about "the insurance company is the primary "doctor" that makes medical decisions above and beyond your PCP." They certainly shouldn't be. But unless she is some rare outlier (I would need a bunch more information about the situation), their stance is logical and acceptable. My first impression, and I certainly may be wrong, is that anyone with a 5.1 HbA1c is controlling things a bit too tight. Her life, I won't argue, but switching insulins is not that precarious. Source: me, diabetic for 30 years now. Hell, I've fasted (no food) for 3 weeks and am still alive... In the grand scheme of things, my attitude is eking out a year or two at most at the end of your life due to totally tight control over 30, 40 years is not worth the effort. Losing weight and eating more vegetables (and less carbs) is more important.
- cortesoft 9y agoRight, but don't you think there should be SOME limits on what is covered? I don't think we should be paying $10,000 for someone to get a homeopathic treatment. There has to be SOME process for determining if something should be covered, otherwise you will have SO MUCH fraud, as people make fake 'experimental' treatments and get the insurance to pay for it.