3 ms·
"They seem to think morality is an individual action radically isolable from cooperation with others" Morality is allways individual action, as we are all indi
by hutzlibu 9y ago
"They seem to think morality is an individual action radically isolable from cooperation with others"
Morality is allways individual action, as we are all individuals.
Also if we individuals decide to form a group, for example for insurance and help those in need.
"If one company refrains from pollutants, it is "donating" profits to a moral cause not persuasive to other businesses"
Unless it openly adverts about this practice amd people who do care, are therefore willing to spend more money on this company.
This is happening a lot right now with organic food and other things (sure, some might only do it, for themselve - better food quality, but not all and even those still feel better, as they know they also help biodiversity and a enjoyable landscape)
edit: and those laws don't exist there, because people don't care there. Laws are just another way of expressing the will of people. I just prefer laws to be the last way and not the standard.
- goatlover 9y ago> Morality is allways individual action, as we are all individuals. We are all individuals, but we're also very much social animals, and morality is a social matter. You're not born into the world knowing right from wrong, you learn it from others. When individuals make moral choices, they do so in a social context.
- hutzlibu 9y agoOk, I believe we are arguing semantics here ... But sure morality is in social context, but still I choose to act moraly or not. That was my point. And I can also choose a different morality from the mainstream. The option to care for animals/nature for example is something quite new (or very old). And it changed, because people decided to care about it. And there are still many who have the old codex, that we as man can do whatever we want to lower lifeforms. (to which some include humans of different color/class/gender)
- mjburgess 9y agoOur bodies are physically isolated from others. Our emotions, ideas, etc. are not. When a crowd at a football game emotes, they all emote together.. inevitably and causally functioning as a coherent whole. Because the individuals cannot chose their reactions, they react the same way. They adopt a purpose, agency, goals and emotional structure that is only rationally intelligble when applied to the whole group. Morality is founded in this inevitable common reaction to circumstances which binds people together under common purpose. Isolating people destroys their ability to act acording to their moral desires... you impair yourself to be how you would wish to be. That's to say nothing of the mere collective action problems involved in any system of "mere individuals" whose cooperation cannot be guaranteed. NB. incidentally, (nearly?) all human success is founded in coherent group action. The individual is a stupid useless distractable ape. Only in concert with a common-purpose-with-others do we succeed. This is, after all, what a "business" is.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"When a crowd at a football game emotes, they all emote together.. inevitably and causally functioning as a coherent whole. Because the individuals cannot chose their reactions, they react the same way. " Definitely not. Only if I feel part of the group, I feel and emote with the group. But if I think football(or soccer) is stupid and the crowd full of stinking alcoholics, then you won't find me cheering with the group. I experienced both. But that's also why you won't find me near a stadium. But with society in a bigger context, it is not so easy to choose.
- mjburgess 9y agoYeah, you're a lone wolf. No you arent. You're an ape. You arent chosing anything you feel, including this rebelliousness which may have its origins in fear of unpredictable group emoting. I have that fear too, I am equally mistrusful of groups and of authority. But that mechanism is merely a feedback cycle into group emotional regulation. Your fear is just another tool of group cohesion. We are fundamentally a social species it is core to the construction of our psychology. Your dissent isnt lonefulness, in which you wouldnt even be commenting here.. your impetus to involve yourself with others is your group drive. Even if, internally, this seems "rebellious" -- rebellion is a mode of group interaction.
- hutzlibu 9y agoHm, you got me wrong there. Even though I am lonewolfing quite a lot, I know I am a social being and I like to be part of a group. I am just turned off by most mainstream group's, which actually look to me that the main thing that is holding them together, is either force or alcohol. But those who do likes that, I don't mind. I am just into different groups.
- mjburgess 9y agoYou're conflating being "turned off" with some mythical form of individualism. What you mean by individualism is actually a form of group dynamic. > is either force or alcohol. In fact it is neither. It is the very same thing that provides you with impetus to comment here.
- ams6110 9y agoBut who defines what "organic" means and who verifies that food labeled "organic" actually is? History has shown that absent any regulation and enforcement, if buyers want "organic" labels on their food, sellers will put "organic" labels on food regardless of what the food contains. Antibiotics and hormones? Pesticides? Those things are organic, under some definitions of the word.
- jstarfish 9y agoMy favorite-- even people without gluten sensitivities have been deluded into thinking it's universally bad, so they'll happily opt for anything with a gluten-free sticker on it... ...regardless of the fact that the product in question has no wheat component to it at all.
- hutzlibu 9y agoOk, I don't know about the US situation, but here in europe we have different labels. One by the EU and other ones from various private organisations like Demeter(more strict). And it cost money and you get controls, if you want that label for your product - so that works as intended. And no antibiotics (unless sickness), no pesticides, etc.. Very clear defined. Also no genetically engineered food, even though I would not mind those. Basically everybody can make up their label, yes, but it has only meaning and value, if I trust that organization. And I do trust both the EU as well as Demeter. If there would be a new label, I would investigate if it is worth anything.