As the other commenters have pointed out, publishing knowledge is not the same as acting as an impartial referee or judge. In the latter case, his inability to

As the other commenters have pointed out, publishing knowledge is not the same as acting as an impartial referee or judge. In the latter case, his inability to make fair decisions in life is directly relevant to his qualification for a job that involves making fair decisions affecting other people. Unfortunately I don't think this thought experiment is very relevant.